×

Sad Songs, Artificial Intelligence and Gracenote’s Quest to Unlock the World’s Music

It’s all about that vibe. Anyone who has ever compiled a mix-tape, or a Spotify playlist for that matter, knows that compilations succeed when they carry a certain emotional quality across their songs.

That’s why the music data specialists at Gracenote have long been classifying the world’s music by moods and emotions. Only, Gracenote’s team hasn’t actually listened to each and every one of the 100 million individual song recordings in its database. Instead, it has taught computers to detect emotions, using machine listening and artificial intelligence (AI) to figure out whether a song is dreamy, sultry, or just plain sad.

“Machine learning is a real strategic edge for us,” said Gracenote’s GM of music Brian Hamilton during a recent interview.

Gracenote began its work on what it calls sonic mood classification about 10 years ago. Over time, that work has evolved, as more traditional algorithms were switched out for cutting-edge neural networks. And quietly, it has become one of the best examples for the music industry’s increasing reliance on artificial intelligence.

How computers learn that Gaga’s “Lovegame” is a “sexy stomper”

First things first: AI doesn’t know how you feel. “We don’t know which effect a musical work will have on an individual listener,” said Gracenote’s VP of research Markus Cremer during an interview with Variety. Instead, it is trying to identify the intention of the musician as a kind of inherent emotional quality. In other words: It wants to teach computers which songs are truly sad, not which song may make you feel blue because of some heartbreak in your teenage years.

Still, teaching computers to identify emotions in music is a bit like therapy: First, you name your feelings. Gracenote’s music team initially developed a taxonomy of more than 100 vibes and moods, and has since expanded that list to more than 400 such emotional qualities.

Gracenote’s engineers are teaching the company’s AI systems that Lady Gaga’s song “Lovegame” is a “sexy stomper.” Sean Ryan/IPS/REX/Shutterstock

Some of these include obvious categories like “sultry” and “sassy,” but there are also extremely specific descriptors like “dreamy sensual,” “gentle bittersweet,” and “desperate rabid energy.” New categories are constantly being added, while others are fine-tuned based on how well the system performs. “It’s sort of an iterative process,” explained Gracenote’s head of content architecture and discovery Peter DiMaria. “The taxonomy morphs and evolves.”

In addition to this list of moods, Gracenote also uses a so-called training set for its machine learning efforts. The company’s music experts have picked and classified some 40,000 songs as examples for these categories. Compiling that training set is an art of its own. “We need to make sure that we give it examples of music that people are listening to,” said DiMaria. At the same time, songs have to be the best possible example for any given emotion. “Some tracks are a little ambiguous,” he said.

The current training set includes Lady Gaga’s “Lovegame” as an example for a “sexy stomper,” Radiohead’s “Pyramid Song” as “plaintive,” and Beyonce’s “Me Myself & I” as an example for “soft sensual & intimate.”

Just like the list of emotions itself, that training set needs to be kept fresh constantly. “Artists are creating new types of musical expressions all the time,” said DiMaria. “We need to make sure the system has heard those.” Especially quickly-evolving genres like electronica and hip-hop require frequent updates.

To a computer, compression can sound like a musical style

Once the system has been trained with these songs, it is being let loose on millions of tracks. But computers don’t simply listen to long playlists of songs, one by one. Instead, Gracenote’s system cuts up each track into 700-millisecond slices, and then extracts some 170 different acoustic values, like timbre, from any such slice.

In addition, it sometimes takes larger chunks of a song to analyze a song’s rhythm and similar features. Those values are then being compared against existing data to classify each song. The result isn’t just a single mood, but a mood profile.

All the while, Gracenote’s team has to periodically make sure that things don’t go wrong. “A musical mix is a pretty complex thing,” explained Cremer.

With instruments, vocals, and effects layered on top of each other and the result being optimized for car stereos or internet streaming, there is a lot to listen to for a computer — including things that aren’t actually part of the music.

“It can capture a lot of different things,” said Cremer. Unsupervised, Gracenote’s system could for example decide to pay attention to compression artifacts, and match them to moods, with Cremer joking that the system may decide: “It’s all 96 kbps, so this makes me sad.”

The world’s music, categorized by the world’s emotions

Once Gracenote has classified music by moods, it delivers that data to customers, which use it in a number of different ways. Smaller media services often license Gracenote’s music data as their end-to-end solution for organizing and recommending music. Media center app maker Plex for example uses the company’s music recommendation technology to offer its customers personalized playlists and something the company calls “mood radio.” Plex users can for example pick a mood like “gentle bittersweet,” press play, and then wait for Mazzy Star to do its thing.

Gracenote also delivers its data to some of the industry’s biggest music service operators, including Apple and Spotify. These big players typically don’t like to talk about how they use Gracenote’s data for their products. Bigger streaming services generally tend to operate their own music recommendation algorithms, but they often still make use of Gracenote’s mood data to train and improve those algorithms, or to help human curators pre-select songs that are then being turned into playlists.

This means that music fans may be acutely aware of Gracenote’s mood classification work, while others may have no idea that the company’s AI technology has helped to improve their music listening experience.

Either way, Gracenote has to make sure that its data translates internationally, especially as it licenses it into new markets. On Tuesday, the company announced that it will begin to sell its music data product, which among other things includes mood classification as well as descriptive, cleaned-up metadata for cataloging music, in Europe and Latin America. To make sure that nothing is lost in translation, the company employs international editors who not just translate a word like “sentimental,” but actually listen to example songs to figure out which expression works best in their cultural context.

And the international focus goes both ways. Gracenote is also constantly scouring the globe to feed its training set with new, international sounds. “Our data can work with every last recording on the planet,” said Cremer.

In the end, classifying all of the world’s music is really only possible if companies like Gracenote do not just rely on humans, but also on artificial intelligence and technologies like machine listening. And in many ways, teaching computers to detect sad songs can actually help humans to have a better and more fulfilling music experience — if only because relying on humans would have left many millions of songs unclassified, and thus out of reach for the personalized playlists of their favorite music services.

Using data and technology to unlock these songs from all over the world has been one of the most exciting parts of his job, said Cremer: “The reason I’m here is to make sure that everyone has access to all of that music.”

Popular on Variety

More Music

  • Queen and Adam Lambert Live

    How the Queen + Adam Lambert Tour Brought the Opera to Arenas

    Just as “Bohemian Rhapsody,” the biopic of late Queen frontman Freddie Mercury, wowed moviegoers last year, stage design firm Stufish Entertainment Architects has helped Queen + Adam Lambert’s current U.S. tour deliver a screen spectacular of its own. The tour, which plays New Orleans on Aug. 20 and Atlanta on Aug. 22, touched down at [...]

  • Mass Appeal and Universal Launch Hip-Hop

    Nas, Mass Appeal and Universal Music Launch Hip-Hop Label in India, Sign Divine

    Mass Appeal and Universal Music Group today announced the launch of Mass Appeal India – a new label dedicated to amplifying India’s burgeoning hip-hop culture on a global scale. The new label’s operations will be based Universal Music India’s headquarters in Mumbai and will function as a multi-channel partnership between the two companies. According to the announcement, Mass Appeal India will sign and [...]

  • Trey Anastasio of Phish performs at

    Phish Concert Camp Out Canceled Due to Plague-Infected Prairie Dogs

    The plague, or Black Death, decimated the European population in medieval times and has returned to ruin Phish concert-goers’ camping plans. The band announced Tuesday that camping and vending will be canceled for their Labor Day weekend performance at Dick’s Sporting Goods Park in Commerce, Colo. due to concerns of plague-infected colonies of prairie dogs. [...]

  • Songs for Screens Powered by Mac

    Songs for Screens: 'American Horror Story' Makes 'Suddenly Last Summer' Sizzle Again

    FX Network’s “American Horror Story” returns for a ninth season next month, and promos for the next chapter of the anticipated series, dubbed ‘AHS 1984,’ have been airing frequently across cable television throughout August. In the short yet effective spot (see below), the Motels’ melancholic, moody “Suddenly Last Summer” plays as aerial footage of an [...]

  • Edge, left, Adam Clayton, and Bono

    New York’s PlayStation Theater to Close (EXCLUSIVE)

    New York’s PlayStation Theater, a 2,100-capacity venue located in Times Square and operated by Bowery Presents, will close at the end of 2019, a source close to the situation tells Variety. The venue will close with a New Year’s series of shows from the Disco Biscuits. The theater, which is located two stories beneath the [...]

  • Jonas Leijonhufvud and Sven Carlsson

    Yellow Bird U.K. Developing 'Spotify Untold' Limited Series

    Yellow Bird U.K. has optioned the screen rights to tell-all book “Spotify Untold” with plans to develop it into a limited series for television. Sven Carlsson and Jonas Leijonhufvud’s novel details the story behind the Swedish start-up which became one of the world’s leading music services and its attempts to take on U.S. giants including [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content