×

Tom Petty, Kenny Rogers, Anthony Perkins, More Slam Spotify’s Proposed $43 Million Licensing Settlement

As Spotify continues to clear the decks for an expected public offering this year or next, it has hit another potential roadblock.

In May, the company proposed a $43 million settlement in an effort to resolve any claims that the company hasn’t paid proper mechanical licenses for song compositions. That deal is still awaiting a judge’s approval.

In a court filing dated Tuesday, an unusual collection of musicians including Tom Petty, Kenny Rogers, Weezer frontman Rivers Cuomo, Sonic Youth’s Kim Gordon, David Cassidy, Black Keys frontman Dan Auerbach, actor (and occasional classical composer) Anthony Perkins and many others slammed the $43 million proposal (the news was first reported by The Hollywood Reporter).

“The Settlement Agreement is procedurally and substantively unfair to Settlement Class Members because it prevents meaningful participation by rights holders and offers them an unfair dollar amount in light of Spotify’s ongoing, willful copyright infringement of their works,” the filing reads in part. It also claims that after attorney fees, the $43 million is down to $28.7 million.

“According to its own publicity, Spotify has about 30 million songs,” it continues. “If as few as one-quarter of those songs, 7.5 million, were unlicensed then, taking the $28.7 million left in the Settlement Fund after attorneys’ fees are paid and dividing that number by 7.5 million songs, the result is a settlement payment of $3.82 per infringed song. As the Court is well aware, Spotify faces potential liability of up to $150,000 per infringed composition for willful infringement and $30,000 for nonwillful infringement, plus attorneys’ fees and costs. While a discount of some amount is to be reasonably expected as part of a compromise settlement, the discount potentially afforded Spotify in this case is a 98.7% discount for nonwillful infringement and a discount for willful infringement so close to 100% as to give Spotify a practical free pass on willful infringement.”

Less than $4 per song is a strong number to rally the troops, and not insignificantly, the first artist named in the filing is singer-songwriter Melissa Ferrick, who with Cracker frontman David Lowery has been one of the lead instigators in the royalty battle against Spotify. Their class-action suits were settled by the $43 million fund in May — but apparently, not permanently.

More Biz

  • Gary Levine and Jana Winograde Showtime

    Showtime, HBO Broaden Scope as Parent Companies Aim to Grow Their Audiences

    For years, the halo around premium cablers such as HBO and Showtime has been integral to their branding. Their parent companies in a past life — Time Warner and CBS, respectively — seemed to be content with the tens of millions of subscribers each had accumulated. But now, shepherded by new corporate owners — AT&T’s [...]

  • Debmar-Mercury Betting on Nick Cannon, 'Schitt's

    Listen: Why Debmar-Mercury Is Betting on Nick Cannon, 'Schitt's Creek' and Syndication

    They put their homes up as collateral to finance the business in its infancy more than 15 years ago. Today, Debmar-Mercury co-presidents Mort Marcus and Ira Bernstein are getting ready to launch not one, but two new first-run series in the fall, adding to a roster that includes “The Wendy Williams Show” and “Family Feud.” [...]

  • Bob Chapek Disney CEO

    Why Wall Street Is Unhappy (for Now) With Disney's CEO Change

    We all knew the end was coming. Bob Iger had promised, time and again, that the end was coming. But the rather abrupt announcement Tuesday afternoon that he would relinquish his longtime role as CEO of the Walt Disney Co. — and that theme parks head Bob Chapek would succeed him at the top of [...]

  • Dau

    'Dau' Director Defends Controversial Russian Competition Film: 'It's Not Hollywood'

    “Dau. Natasha,” the Russian art project-turned-movie franchise competing at the Berlinale, has triggered headlines in the local and international press over the years due to its epic scale, scenes of graphic violence and anecdotes of an allegedly oppressive work environment for women. Hours before the film’s premiere at a presser on Wednesday, Ilya Khrzhanovsky, who [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content