×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Sarah Palin’s Defamation Lawsuit Against The New York Times Dismissed

A federal judge has dismissed Sarah Palin’s defamation lawsuit against the New York Times, finding the newspaper did not act maliciously in accidentally linking the former vice presidential candidate’s name with a June 14 shooting spree that injured several members of Congress.

“If political journalism is to achieve its constitutionally endorsed role of challenging the powerful, legal redress by a public figure must be limited to those cases where the public figure has a plausible factual basis for complaining that the mistake was made maliciously, that is, with knowledge it was false or with reckless disregard of its falsity,” wrote U.S. Judge Jed Rakoff of the Southern District of New York in his opinion dismissing the case on Tuesday.

In an op-ed piece about gunman James Hodgkinson shooting Republican congressman Steve Scalise and others playing baseball in Virginia that ran online June 14 and in print the following day, the Times editorial board made comparisons to the January 2011 shooting rampage in which Jared Lee Loughner killed six people, seriously wounding house member Gabby Giffords. The Times stated that Loughner was motivated by a Palin political action committee map featuring Democratic politicians in the crosshairs of a gun sight, evidence labeled the “SarahPAC Map.”

However, news reports of the 2011 event eventually discredited the theory of Loughner acting under the influence of the circulated SarahPAC Map. (The online Times article actually hyperlinked to an ABC News story specifying the two events were not linked.)

Palin filed suit June 27.

Although the editorial was signed by the New York Times editorial board, the facts revealed that a draft by editorial writer Elizabeth Williamson, subsequently rewritten by editorial page editor James Bennett contained the error. Judge Rakoff wrote the error off as an unintentional mistake – one that did not meet the standard for defamation, which is malice or reckless disregard. The Times subsequently ran multiple corrections.

“What we have here is an editorial, written and rewritten rapidly in order to voice an opinion on an immediate event of importance, in which are included a few factual inaccuracies somewhat pertaining to Mrs. Palin that are very rapidly corrected,” Judge Rakoff wrote. “Negligence this may be; but defamation of a public figure it plainly is not.”

More Biz

  • Mergers and Deals Placeholder

    Tegna to Buy 11 TV Stations From Nexstar for $740 Million

    Tegna has set a deal with Nexstar to buy 11 TV stations — mostly Fox and ABC affiliates — serving eight markets for $740 million. The sale is contingent on Nexstar closing its $4.1 billion acquisition of Tribune Media, which will make Nexstar the nation’s largest TV station owner by far. Nexstar projects the Tribune [...]

  • EMMA APPLETON as FEEF SYMONDS

    'Traitors' Producer 42 Hires Literary Manager Eugenie Furniss

    Eugenie Furniss is joining London- and Los Angeles-based management and production company 42 as literary manager, it was announced Wednesday. The company’s slate include movie “Ironbark,” a Cold War thriller starring Benedict Cumberbatch, and TV series “Traitors,” a spy thriller coming to Netflix in the U.S. at the end of the month. Furniss joins 42 [...]

  • Disney Fox Takeover Placeholder

    Fox Corp. Pays Disney Sale Dividend, Sets May 9 Investor Meeting

    Fox Corp. has handed over an $8.5 billion check to help Disney offset tax costs related to the 21st Century Fox acquisition. As spelled out in the Disney-21st Century Fox merger agreement, the Murdoch clan’s newly established Fox Corp. was on the hook to pay a special dividend to 21st Century Fox on the latter’s [...]

  • Kevin Tsujihara

    Kevin Tsujihara's Ouster Kicks Off a Week of Major Disruption in the Media Business

    The sudden ouster of Warner Bros. Entertainment chief Kevin Tsujihara kicked off what is likely to go down as one of the most extraordinary weeks in Hollywood history, spelling enormous turmoil and transition across the media landscape. In addition to the news about Tsujihara, which comes amid a wider shake-up of leadership at AT&T’s WarnerMedia, [...]

  • Disney Fox mega deal acquisition Illustration

    Disney Closes $71 Billion 21st Century Fox Deal

    After 15 months of wrangling and planning, Disney has formally sealed the deal on its $71 billion acquisition of 21st Century Fox. “This is an extraordinary and historic moment for us — one that will create significant long-term value for our company and our shareholders,” Disney chairman-CEO Bob Iger said in a statement on Tuesday [...]

  • Chinese Tech Firm Huawei Seeks Content

    Beleaguered Chinese Tech Firm Huawei Seeks Content for Expansion Into Southeast Asia

    One of the most surprising first-time attendees at FilMart is Chinese tech giant Huawei, which has come to Hong Kong to acquire the video content it needs to support its strategy of expansion into Southeast Asia. The company is currently embroiled in a PR nightmare as it defends itself against accusations that its equipment could [...]

  • Viacom HQ LA

    Viacom Goes to War With AT&T Over DirecTV Carriage Deal

    Viacom has declared war against AT&T, blasting the telco giant on several fronts as the companies wrestle over a carriage renewal deal that is vital to Viacom’s long-term financial health. As of today, Viacom has begun running crawls and promo spots on its channels warning viewers that Nickelodeon, Comedy Central, BET, MTV and other channels [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content