×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Appeals Court Refuses to Reinstate President Trump’s Travel Ban

An appeals court ruled against reinstating President Donald Trump’s travel and immigration ban.

A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that the government had “not shown a likelihood of success on the merits of it appeal, nor has it shown that failure to enter a stay would cause irreparable injury, and therefore we deny this emergency motion for a stay.” The question before the judges was on whether Trump’s executive order, issued last month, should be put on hold while the weighty issues of its constitutionality are considered.

Trump’s travel ban had been challenged by attorneys general from the state of Washington and Minnesota, and dozens of tech companies, including Amazon, Google, and Netflix.

The appellate judges considering the case were Michelle Friedland, an appointee of President Barack Obama; Richard Clifton, an appointee of President George W. Bush; and William Canby, an appointee of President Jimmy Carter.

A district court judge granted a temporary restraining order last week that put Trump’s executive order on hold nationwide. The Trump administration appealed the district court’s decision.

“SEE YOU IN COURT, THE SECURITY OF OUR NATION IS AT STAKE!” Trump tweeted in reaction to the ruling.

Trump’s order temporarily restricted entry into the United States from seven Muslim-majority countries, and halted the flow of refugees into the U.S. for 120 days.

Earlier in the week, at a one-hour hearing before the 9th Circuit, Noah Purcell, attorney for Washington state, argued that reinstating it would harm the state, separate families, and prevent students and faculty from entering the country.

August Flentje, representing the federal government, argued that Judge James Robart’s temporary restraining order was an “extraordinary” action in that it enjoined a presidential national security decision “based on some newspaper articles.”

Technically, the 9th Circuit was not considering the merits of the case — whether Trump’s order was a constitutional violation in singling out Muslim-majority countries. The executive order restricted travel from Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, and Yemen, and suspends entry indefinitely of all Syrian refugees.

But the motivations behind Trump’s order were brought up at Tuesday’s hearing.

The judges noted that Washington state and Minnesota, in challenging Trump’s executive order, had presented evidence in support of their argument that the president intended to disfavor Muslims. The states cited Trump’s campaign statements about his intent to implement a “Muslim ban.”

“The States’ claims raise serious allegations and present significant constitutional questions,” the judges said in the ruling.

The judges declined to limit the scope of the temporary restraining order. They noted that the federal government had offered no evidence that “any alien from any of the countries named in the order has perpetrated a terrorist attack in the United States. Rather than present evidence to explain the need for the Executive Order, the Government has taken the position that we much not review its decision at all. We disagree…”

In their ruling, the 9th Circuit judges also rejected the administration’s claim that the president’s decisions about immigration policy are “unreviewable.”

“There is no precedent to support this claimed unreviewability, which runs contrary to the fundamental structure of our constitutional democracy,” the judges said.

More Biz

  • China's Alibaba to Take Majority Control

    Alibaba to Take Majority Control of Alibaba Pictures

    Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba is to take majority control of its films unit Alibaba Pictures. The $160 (HK$1.25 billion) deal was announced on Monday. The companies said that Alibaba will increase its stake in Hong Kong- and Singapore-listed Alibaba Pictures, through a share subscription. It will lift the parent company’s stake from 49% to 51%, [...]

  • Guy Moot

    Is Sony/ATV’s Guy Moot Headed for Top Job at Warner/Chappell?

    Ever since Jon Platt announced in September that he will be stepping down from his post at the helm of Warner/Chappell Publishing to take the top job at Sony/ATV when Martin Bandier’s contract is up at the end of March, speculation has been rife about who will take over for him. One name has been [...]

  • The King Eric Clapton A Life

    Rashida Jones, Lili Zanuck Talk Grammy Nominations and the Music-Documentary Gold Rush

    Nothing takes you back to time and a place like the music of a particular era. That’s one big reason why music documentaries are flourishing at a time of enormous demand for high-end docu productions. This year’s five Grammy Award nominees for best music film reflect the appetite for stories about renowned and beloved musical figures, [...]

  • il bussetto best business card holder

    Office-Appropriate Gifting: The Best Gifts For Your Colleagues and Bosses

    You can do better than a handshake or bottle of wine to wish your boss a Happy Holiday this season. Here are 10 gifts that show your appreciation for your colleagues or manager, while also helping you stand out from the card and cookie-wielding pack. 1. Personalized Beer Growler Whether they are using it for [...]

  • viceroy-los-cabos-review

    Winter Hotel Guide: Where The Stars Stay in Los Angeles, New York and Beyond

    Whether for a business meeting, a private event, or an intimate celebration for family and friends, these are the hotels that Hollywood keeps on its list. From storied properties that are rich in film and fashion lore, to new players on the hospitality scene, here’s where to book your next stay. 1. Hotel Shangri-La (Santa [...]

  • best tech gifts ipad apple

    Retail Analysts Reveal Top Tech Gifts of 2018

    It’s shaping up to be a busy holiday season for tech and electronics companies, as gaming consoles, streaming devices and televisions top the list of most anticipated gifts, according to retail analysts. New data from Adobe Analytics forecasts that the holiday shopping season (the period from November 1 to December 31) will see more than [...]

  • best harry potter gifts art

    Harry Potter 20th Anniversary: The Best Gifts For Harry Potter Fans

    2018 marked a big milestone for “Harry Potter,” as the franchise celebrated the 20th anniversary of “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” release in the U.S. Since that first book was summoned onto store shelves, the Wizarding World has become a phenomenon not just in America, but around the world, spawning a successful film franchise, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content