You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

What’s Next for Net Neutrality: A Summer Battle

Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), tweeted out one of his fears on Friday as media attention fixates on the drama of the Trump White House.


He was referring to the Trump-led effort to repeal Obamacare and the FCC move to roll back the foundation for its net neutrality rules.

The distraction of a potential all-consuming White House scandal is of concern to advocates banking on a public outcry over healthcare and the internet, in particular net neutrality, an issue that can easily get into the policy weeds.

So far, many people have noticed.

More than 2 million people have weighed in on the latest FCC proposal, which would repeal the commission’s 2015 designation of internet service as a common carrier, or “Title II” in regulatory terms. To many net neutrality advocates, such a move would weaken and undermine the rules, which prohibit ISPs from discriminating in how they deliver content to the consumer.

It’s even caught the attention of a few celebrities, like Francis Ford Coppola, who warned of giving major corporations control of the internet, and William Shatner, who quoted Commissioner Mignon Clyburn and tweeted, “Net neutrality must stay!”

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai says that when it comes to his proposal, the commission “will follow the facts and the law where they take us.” The proposal, he said, “is the start of a new chapter in the public discussion about how we can best maintain a free and open internet while making sure that ISPs have strong incentives to bring next-generation networks and services to all Americans.”

Still, Pai is a longtime critic of the FCC’s current approach, and with fellow Republican commissioner Michael O’Rielly, he has the votes to repeal.

So what happens next? If it is anything like the last net neutrality battle, the 90 days ahead will be marked by strong rhetoric and powerful rebuttal, and it may get a bit raucous.

Open Comment Period: The FCC proposal — which you can see in full here — is now in a period of public comment. The deadline is July 17, and the cutoff point for reply comments is Aug. 16. Pai has said that he expects a final vote later this year.

About 4 million comments were received by the FCC the last time it took up net neutrality, a reflection of just how charged the issue had become. It was a contrast to previous efforts by the FCC to establish rules, when the debate largely centered around D.C. policy circles.

Some groups, like Free Press, are collecting comments to be delivered to the FCC’s site, while “Last Week Tonight” host John Oliver established a URL, gofccyourself.com, to make it easier to file comments. Pai unveiled his proposal to FreedomWorks, a conservative group which, along with other organizations pushing for deregulation, are likely to campaign heavily for the repeal.

The question, though, is whether this becomes in any way a liability for lawmakers on Capitol Hill. When Congress rolled back Obama-era FCC privacy rules earlier this year, Republican lawmakers saw some backlash, including angry constituents at town halls, and there is some reason to believe that net neutrality will become an issue with constituents this summer.

Congress. Just before the FCC voted on Thursday to put its proposal out for public comment, Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) called for bipartisan legislation. “It is time for Congress to finally settle this matter,” he said of the issue, which has raged as a D.C. debate since the early 2000s.

Democrats, though, are sounding the alarm about the FCC’s proposal, and there are few indications that they are about to sit down and hash out a compromise. They see the Republican-led effort to roll back the privacy rules as a misstep that may be used against the GOP in next year’s midterm elections, and the same may be true when it comes to net neutrality.

Thune has suggested that the closer that the FCC gets to repealing the rules, the more willing Democrats may be to sitting down and hashing out a piece of legislation. But lawmakers who are willing to do that also will have to contend with an array of public internet groups and other activists, as well as major Internet firms, if the end result is loaded with potential loopholes.

Courts. If the FCC goes ahead and rolls back Title II — which seems likely — it will likely face a court challenge.

This week, Abigail Slater, the general counsel of the Internet Association, which represents major companies like Facebook, Google and Amazon, said that the burden will be on the Pai-led FCC to show why, after just two years, it is necessary to reverse course on net neutrality. Both sides now have competing sets of numbers to prove their case that the 2015 order either had no effect on investment in the Internet, or that it has hindered it. As much as net neutrality may again draw interest well outside the Beltway this summer, if it ends up in the courts it will likely become a battle of policy procedure and reliable data.

More Biz

  • 'Zootopia' Land Coming to Shanghai Disneyland

    Disney to Open 'Zootopia' Land at Shanghai Theme Park

    The Shanghai Disneyland theme park is to be expanded with the construction of a themed land based on the “Zootopia” animated film and its characters. It will be the first “Zootopia” land at any Disney park worldwide. “The rapid rate of expansion at Shanghai Disney Resort demonstrates our confidence and commitment to the company’s future [...]

  • David Glasser

    David Glasser to Launch $300 Million Shingle With Ron Burkle's Backing (EXCLUSIVE)

    David Glasser, the former chief operating officer of the Weinstein Co., is launching a $300 million film and TV company with the backing of billionaire investor Ron Burkle, Variety has learned. The formation of the production outfit, named 101 Studios, marks a fresh start for Glasser, who was in line to become CEO of the [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein arrives at New York

    Judge Refuses to Pause Weinstein Class Action Case

    A judge on Tuesday denied Harvey Weinstein’s request to put a class action lawsuit on hold pending the outcome of his criminal trial. Ten women have sued Weinstein in federal court in the Southern District of New York, accusing him of violating the federal sex trafficking statute. The suit also alleges that an array of [...]

  • Andrea Ganis Promoted to President of

    Atlantic Records Elevates Andrea Ganis to President of Promotion

    Andrea Ganis has been promoted to the newly created position of president of promotion for Atlantic Records, it was announced today by Atlantic Chairman & COO Julie Greenwald and Chairman & CEO Craig Kallman. In her new role, she will continue to oversee all promotion activities for Atlantic and its subsidiary labels while serving on [...]

  • Roma

    Netflix Joins the Motion Picture Association of America

    UPDATED WASHINGTON — Netflix has joined the Motion Picture Association of America, a move that reflects its evolution as a major player in the movie business. The MPAA currently has six major studios as members, and it collected about $38 million in membership dues in 2017, according to its most recent filing with the IRS. [...]

  • Fate of 'Simpsons' Up in Air

    What Will Happen to 'The Simpsons’ as Disney Takes Over Fox?

    When “The Simpsons” ends its 30th and current season this spring, it will have racked up 663 original episodes — having a season ago passed “Gunsmoke” (635) as the longest-running scripted program in television history. But with the Walt Disney Co.’s acquisition of 21st Century Fox pending, one of TV’s least likely institutions could prove more [...]

  • Best Worst Performances Pink

    Pink, Muse, Chris Stapleton to Headline Citi Sound Vault During Grammy Week

    Pink, Muse and Chris Stapleton will headline Citi Sound Vault, the three-night live-music platform taking place at the Hollywood Palladium during Grammy week. Pink will kick off the Live Nation-produced series on Feb. 7, followed by Muse on Feb. 9 and Stapleton on Grammy night, the 10th. “This will be my first time performing at the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content