×

Trump’s Supreme Court Nominee Cites His Decision in A&E Case in Query Over Libel Laws

Neil Gorsuch, President Donald Trump’s pick to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court, was asked at Tuesday’s Senate confirmation hearing whether he agreed with longstanding precedent when it came to libel and defamation.

It’s a key concern in media circles, as Trump said during the campaign that he wanted to “open up” libel laws to make it easier for plaintiffs in defamation cases. The landmark 1964 Supreme Court decision in New York Times Company v. Sullivan requires a high standard for public figures to prove libel, including actual malice.

At the hearing, Gorsuch noted that New York Times v. Sullivan has been the “law of the land for gosh, 50, 60 years.”

While he didn’t explicitly say whether he agreed with it, he pointed to an appellate decision he made in a case involving A&E Networks and a prison inmate, who sued the network for airing a documentary that labeled him as a member of an Aryan Brotherhood gang when he was merely assisting them.

“Our court declined to grant that relief, saying substantial truth is protected, even if it is not strictly true,” Gorsuch said.

But Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.), who had posed the defamation questions to him at the marathon hearing, also asked him to comment on the 1972 Supreme Court decision in Branzburg v. Hayes, in which the high court ruled that the First Amendment did not protect reporters from testifying before a grand jury.

Gorsuch did not offer much on that point, as he generally avoided any tinge of comment on potential future cases. He even declined to weigh in on whether cameras should be allowed in the Supreme Court, the final judicial frontier for media exposure.

Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee at times expressed frustration at Gorsuch’s unwillingness to weigh in on controversial cases, such as Roe v. Wade. He praised Judge Merrick Garland, but declined to comment on what happened to him, characterizing it as wading into politics. President Barack Obama nominated Garland to the Supreme Court last year, but Republicans refused to give him a hearing. The nomination died, leaving President Trump to pick Gorsuch last month.

Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) asked Gorsuch about the Supreme Court’s decisions that led to the legalization of same-sex marriage.

Gorsuch declined to tell Franken his personal views on the subject, but said that it was “absolutely settled law.” He did note that there were other issues related to same-sex marriage that were still pending.

Later in the day, Gorsuch was asked about Trump’s attacks on federal judges, like those who sidelined his initial travel ban.

While not commenting on Trump’s remarks specifically, Gorsuch said, “When anyone criticizes the honesty or integrity or motives of a judge, I find that disheartening. I find that demoralizing.”

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), who had been questioning Gorsuch, asked if that included the president.

“Anyone is anyone,” Gorsuch said.

Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.), praised Gorsuch and said that he was a bit worried over who Trump would pick.

“Quite frankly, I was worried about who he would pick, maybe someone on TV.”

More Biz

  • Discovery CEO David Zaslav Sees 2018

    Discovery CEO David Zaslav Sees 2018 Compensation Soar to $129.4 Million

    Discovery Inc. president-CEO David Zaslav is once again making headlines for an enormous compensation package. Zaslav’s 2018 compensation soared to $129.44 million in 2018, fueled by stock options and grants awarded as the longtime Discovery chief signed a new employment contract last July that takes him through 2023 at the cable programming group. Zaslav received [...]

  • Jonathan Lamy RIAA

    Jonathan Lamy Stepping Down From RIAA

    Jonathan Lamy, the Recording Industry Association of America’s longtime executive VP of communications and marketing, is stepping down from his post after 17 years, he announced today. As he put it in an email to Variety, “I started back in 2002, which means it’s been 17+ years, four different RIAA CEOs, three format changes and [...]

  • Fox Layoffs

    Disney-21st Fox Layoffs: TV Divisions Brace for Deep Cuts

    A second day of layoffs has begun on the Fox lot in the wake of Disney completing its acquisition of 21st Century Fox on Wednesday. Longtime 20th Century Fox Television Distribution president Mark Kaner is among the senior executives who were formally notified with severance details on Friday morning. 21st Century Fox’s international TV sales [...]

  • anthony pellicano

    Hollywood Fixer Anthony Pellicano Released From Federal Prison

    Anthony Pellicano, the Hollywood private eye whose wiretapping case riveted the industry a decade ago, was released from a federal prison on Friday, a prison spokeswoman confirmed. Pellicano was sentenced in 2008 to 15 years, following his conviction on 78 charges of wiretapping, racketeering, conspiracy and wire fraud. He had been in custody since 2003, [...]

  • This image taken from the Twitter

    HBO’s Reaction to Trump’s ‘Game of Thrones’ Campaign

    Everyone wants a piece of the “Game of Thrones” lemon cake. From Bud Light to Red Bull the world of Westeros is open to a lot of brand partnerships, unless you’re using that iconic typeface to push a political agenda. In November of 2018 President Donald Trump unveiled a “Thrones” inspired poster with the words [...]

  • Leaving Neverland HBO

    'Leaving Neverland' Lawsuit Proves to Be a Judicial Hot Potato

    The Michael Jackson estate sued HBO last month for airing the documentary “Leaving Neverland,” which accuses the late King of Pop of serial child sexual abuse. Since then, the case has had a difficult time finding a judge to handle it. Three federal judges have recused themselves in the last week, citing potential financial conflicts [...]

  • Members of the public mourn at

    Guy Oseary’s New Zealand Fundraiser Nears $150,000, Continues Raising Money

    In the wake of the horrific shootings at New Zealand mosques last week that killed some 49 people, Maverick chief Guy Oseary launched a GoFundMe campaign to “support those affected by this tragedy at this very difficult time,” and began it with an $18,000 donation. Boosted by donations from many celebrities — including Amy Schumer, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content