×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Trump’s Supreme Court Nominee Cites His Decision in A&E Case in Query Over Libel Laws

Neil Gorsuch, President Donald Trump’s pick to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court, was asked at Tuesday’s Senate confirmation hearing whether he agreed with longstanding precedent when it came to libel and defamation.

It’s a key concern in media circles, as Trump said during the campaign that he wanted to “open up” libel laws to make it easier for plaintiffs in defamation cases. The landmark 1964 Supreme Court decision in New York Times Company v. Sullivan requires a high standard for public figures to prove libel, including actual malice.

At the hearing, Gorsuch noted that New York Times v. Sullivan has been the “law of the land for gosh, 50, 60 years.”

While he didn’t explicitly say whether he agreed with it, he pointed to an appellate decision he made in a case involving A&E Networks and a prison inmate, who sued the network for airing a documentary that labeled him as a member of an Aryan Brotherhood gang when he was merely assisting them.

“Our court declined to grant that relief, saying substantial truth is protected, even if it is not strictly true,” Gorsuch said.

But Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.), who had posed the defamation questions to him at the marathon hearing, also asked him to comment on the 1972 Supreme Court decision in Branzburg v. Hayes, in which the high court ruled that the First Amendment did not protect reporters from testifying before a grand jury.

Gorsuch did not offer much on that point, as he generally avoided any tinge of comment on potential future cases. He even declined to weigh in on whether cameras should be allowed in the Supreme Court, the final judicial frontier for media exposure.

Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee at times expressed frustration at Gorsuch’s unwillingness to weigh in on controversial cases, such as Roe v. Wade. He praised Judge Merrick Garland, but declined to comment on what happened to him, characterizing it as wading into politics. President Barack Obama nominated Garland to the Supreme Court last year, but Republicans refused to give him a hearing. The nomination died, leaving President Trump to pick Gorsuch last month.

Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) asked Gorsuch about the Supreme Court’s decisions that led to the legalization of same-sex marriage.

Gorsuch declined to tell Franken his personal views on the subject, but said that it was “absolutely settled law.” He did note that there were other issues related to same-sex marriage that were still pending.

Later in the day, Gorsuch was asked about Trump’s attacks on federal judges, like those who sidelined his initial travel ban.

While not commenting on Trump’s remarks specifically, Gorsuch said, “When anyone criticizes the honesty or integrity or motives of a judge, I find that disheartening. I find that demoralizing.”

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), who had been questioning Gorsuch, asked if that included the president.

“Anyone is anyone,” Gorsuch said.

Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.), praised Gorsuch and said that he was a bit worried over who Trump would pick.

“Quite frankly, I was worried about who he would pick, maybe someone on TV.”

More Biz

  • Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon - The

    CAA's Packaging Fee Becomes Flashpoint in 'Walking Dead' Litigation

    The issue that is at the heart of the WGA’s present standoff with talent agencies has flared up as a source of tension in the litigation between AMC Networks and Frank Darabont and CAA over profit participation on “The Walking Dead.” The practice of talent agencies receiving packaging fees for helping to assemble the creative [...]

  • Sony Music to Deliver ‘Real Time’

    Sony Music to Deliver ‘Real Time’ Data, Royalty Payments to Artists

    Sony Music today announced two new payment features for its artists — “Real Time Royalties” and “Cash Out” — through its artist portal beginning this fall. 

A memo sent to artists Monday morning and obtained by Variety says  the initiatives will “allow our artists and royalty participants to view and withdraw earnings faster than ever [...]

  • Whitney Houston

    Whitney Houston Estate Plans Hologram Tour, Album, Musical

    In the seven years since Whitney Houston’s death, there has been relatively little of the asset-exploitation that usually follows the passing of a music icon, apart from a smattering of previously unreleased recordings, a pair of harrowing documentaries and a lot of unflattering press. But according to an article in the New York Times, the [...]

  • rocketman-elton-john-costume

    Elton John Biopic 'Rocketman' Taps Lucky Brand Collaboration as Part of Promo Push

    Paramount has set a May 28 release date for its Elton John-inspired clothing collection with retailer Lucky Brand, which celebrates the performer’s iconic style and new biopic, “Rocketman” (see tickets and showtimes here). The limited-edition collaboration arrives in stores three days before the film hits theaters, though it’s available for purchase right now on LuckyBrand.com. [...]

  • Huawei Restricted From Using Google's Android

    Huawei Restricted From Using Google's Android as U.S.-China Tensions Mount

    Google has prevented controversial Chinese tech firm Huawei from accessing the latest versions of the Android mobile phone operating system. The move follows U.S. government attempts to blacklist the Chinese firm. “We are complying with the order and reviewing the implications,” Google sources told news agencies Sunday. “Huawei will only be able to use the [...]

  • ‘Hitsville: The Making of Motown’ Acquired

    ‘Hitsville: The Making of Motown’ Acquired by Showtime for U.S.

    Polygram Entertainment, Universal Music Group’s film and television division, along with Capitol Music Group, Motown Records and Fulwell 73 announced today that “Hitville: The Making of Motown” has been acquired by Showtime for release in North America with plans for a fall premiere, and Altitude for theatrical release in the UK and Ireland. The feature-length [...]

  • Sammy Shore Dead: Comedy Store Co-Founder

    Sammy Shore, Co-Founder of The Comedy Store, Dies at 92

    Sammy Shore, the well-known stand-up comedian who co-founded The Comedy Store in Hollywood, died in Las Vegas, Nev. from natural causes. He was 92. Shore founded The Comedy Store with writing partner Rudy Deluca on April 7, 1972. His ex-wife, Mitzi Shore, took ownership of the club in the divorce settlement, and the venue went [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content