×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Manhattan D.A. Urges More Harvey Weinstein Victims to Come Forward

Criminal prosecution against indie mogul faces hurdles, experts say

The Manhattan District Attorney’s office, which is under fire for its handling of a sex assault allegation against Harvey Weinstein in 2015, is now urging other Weinstein victims to come forward.

In a statement, Chief Assistant D.A. Karen Friedman Agnifilo blasted Weinstein’s “pattern of mistreating women,” saying it was “disgraceful and shocks the conscience.”

“Any individual who feels that she may have been the victim of a crime by this person in Manhattan is strongly encouraged to contact our Office’s Sex Crimes Hotline at (212) 335-9373,” Agnifilo said.

The office is taking criticism following a devastating story in the New Yorker, which detailed numerous incidents of sexual harassment and alleged rape. The story cited the case of Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, who told New York police in March 2015 that Weinstein groped her at his Tribeca office. Gutierrez agreed to wear a wire, and captured Weinstein saying “I’m used to that,” and urging her to join him in his hotel room.

Police sources cited in the story say the case could have been charged as sexual abuse in the third degree, a misdemeanor. One police source was livid that the D.A.’s office opted not to file a charge.

In the statement, Agnifilo defended the decision not to prosecute, saying police had failed to consult with prosecutors before the recorded conversation took place.

“While the recording is horrifying to listen to, what emerged from the audio was insufficient to prove a crime under New York law, which requires prosecutors to establish criminal intent,” Agnifilo said.

The statute of limitations on misdemeanors in New York is two years, meaning that even if the D.A.’s office changed its mind it would be too late to bring charges.

However, the New Yorker story also includes an allegation that Weinstein forced an actress, Lucia Stoller, to perform oral sex at his office in 2004. The story does not indicate that she went to the police. Conceivably, that could prosecuted as a criminal sexual act in the first degree, a Class B felony, which does not have a statute of limitations in New York state. The D.A.’s office declined to comment on that case.

“It could be prosecuted any time you get the evidence,” says Bennett Gershman, professor at the Pace University School of Law. “From a practical standpoint, you have all the obstacles in terms of faded memories, lack of forensic evidence… All those issues would be on the table. It’s just a question of what the facts prove and whether or not the prosecutor has enough evidence to go ahead, and whether the prosecutor wants to.”

Much of Weinstein’s alleged misconduct is said to have taken place at the Peninsula Hotel in Beverly Hills. However, no agency has submitted a complaint against Weinstein to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office, a spokesman said.

California recently amended the law to eliminate the statute of limitations for felony sex crimes. However, that change did not apply retroactively. The previous limit was 10 years.

Any confidential settlements with victims would not prevent prosecutors from bringing a charge, but it could make it difficult to win a conviction, says Laurie Levenson, a professor at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles. A jury might be less likely to accept the word of someone who took a payment, she says.

“We don’t know what we don’t know,” she says. “There could be other victims who come forward… Prosectors could very well be looking at the list of other actresses he worked with.”

Beyond statutory issues, the Weinstein Company reportedly had employees sign non-disclosure agreements about working for the indie film and television studio. Lawyers say that criminal prosecutors would likely be able to get around those agreements to compel witnesses to testify.

“An NDA is not going to trump law enforcement’s interest in obtaining the information that they’re looking for,” said Benjamin D. Andreozzi, the principal attorney at Andreozzi & Associates, P.C., and a lawyer who has worked on sexual abuse cases. “Any subpoena will trump any contractual agreement.”

Employment attorneys said that there are takeaways from the allegations against Weinstein, namely that safeguards that were put in place to prevent employees and contractors from having their rights trampled over failed.

“It’s unlikely that he was the only person who knew about what he was doing,” said Matt Oster, a partner at Wolf, Rifkin, Shapiro, Schulman & Rabkin, LLP. “How could all of this happen in a complete vacuum? More likely, there were a number of people who knew what was going on. He was a powerful man, they were intimidated, and they let it happen. It was a complete breakdown of the system.”

Brent Lang contributed to this report.

More Biz

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett's Bail Set at $100,000, Must Surrender Passport

    A Chicago judge set a $100,000 bond for Jussie Smollett on Thursday, as the “Empire” actor made his first court appearance. Smollett faces one felony count of filing a false police report. Police allege that Smollett staged a Jan. 29 attack, telling police that he was accosted by two men who used racial and homophobic [...]

  • Michael Jackson Estate Accuses HBO of

    Michael Jackson Estate Sues HBO for Non-Disparagement Contract Breach

    The estate of Michael Jackson sued HBO on Thursday, accusing the cable channel of violating a non-disparagement clause by agreeing to run “Leaving Neverland,” a documentary accusing Jackson of sexual abuse. The suit seeks to compel HBO to litigate the matter in a public arbitration process, and claims that the estate could be awarded $100 [...]

  • Allison Kaye

    Scooter Braun Names Allison Kaye Partner at Ithaca Holdings (EXCLUSIVE)

    On the back of a history-making debut by Ariana Grande, who claims the top three songs on the Billboard Hot 100 chart this week (tying the Beatles), Scooter Braun has appointed his longtime deputy Allison Kaye to partner at Ithaca Holdings LLC, which houses SB Projects. She was previously president of music at the 12-year-old [...]

  • Tidal Launches $1 Million Program to

    Tidal Launches Unplugged, $1 Million Program to Support Emerging Musicians

    Tidal, the streaming platform headed by Jay-Z, today announced the launch of a million-dollar artist grant program intended to support emerging musicians. Called Tidal Unplugged and funded by a donation from venture capitalists and philanthropists Mark Lampert and Robert Nelsen, the program will kick off March 1 in Detroit, where Lampert’s grandfather started his musical career. [...]

  • Patti Smith, Sharon Van Etten Lead

    Patti Smith, Sharon Van Etten, Lead Initial Lineup for Renovated Webster Hall

    New York’s classic venue Webster Hall, which will reopen this spring after a months-long renovation, has announced the first run of shows after its relaunch: Patti Smith and Her Band, Broken Social Scene, MGMT, Empire of the Sun, Old Dominion, Sharon Van Etten, Built to Spill, Real Estate, Chromeo and Big Thief are among the [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett Charged With Filing False Police Report

    “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett has been charged with filing a false police report, the Chicago police said Wednesday. “Detectives will make contact with his legal team to negotiate a reasonable surrender for his arrest,” police spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said on Twitter. Smollett is due to appear in court for a bond hearing at 1:30 p.m. [...]

  • Coast Guard Lieutenant Hit List

    Coast Guard Lieutenant Targeted CNN, MSNBC Anchors and Democrats for Attacks

    Anchors at CNN and MSNBC and prominent Democrats were targeted for attack by a Coast Guard lieutenant arrested Friday on a firearms charge, according to federal prosecutors in Maryland. In court documents revealed Tuesday, prosecutors describe the firearms and controlled substance charges Christopher Paul Hasson is facing as “the proverbial tip of the iceberg.” CNN’s [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content