You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Net Neutrality Debate Focuses on Key Metric: Is Investment Up or Down?

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, in calling for the rollback of the foundation for the agency’s net neutrality rules, has justified the proposal in part by citing a key statistic: Among the dozen largest internet providers, U.S. broadband capital expenditures fell by 5.6% between 2014 and 2016.

The commission on Thursday is likely to officially launch the process of repealing the underpinnings of its current net neutrality rules, a process that already has generated more than 1.6 million comments.

But the issue of investment — and whether the FCC’s passage of net neutrality regulation proved so onerous to internet providers that they scaled back their plans — will be a major part of the battle over the next several months.

On Wednesday, the Internet Association, representing such internet companies as Google, Netflix and Facebook, presented their own study refuting Pai’s figures. Far from seeing investment go down, ISPs actually have increased their expenditures on capital, according to their study.

Among their figures: Telecom investment rose 5.3%, or $7.3 billion, among publicly traded companies between 2013-14 and 2015-16. The figures are based on SEC filings and a report from Free Press, which released a 125-page report earlier this week.

It’s important because if the FCC reverses course on net neutrality — and Pai has the votes to do so — it is likely that the move will be challenged in court. It’s there that the FCC will have to demonstrate its justification for doing so, just two years after the rules were passed.

Abigail Slater, the general counsel for the Internet Association, said on a conference call with reporters on Wednesday that the ISPs “bear the burden” of showing that their investment has been impacted and that it is a result of Title II. She also said that another issue has to be taken into consideration: growth in investment from internet firms like Google, Netflix and the like, not just ISPs.

If the current approach to net neutrality is rolled back, she said, “edge competition will suffer and consumer choice will suffer as well.”

The FCC’s move on Thursday would merely launch a public comment period, expected to last throughout the summer, on Pai’s proposal to repeal the FCC’s 2015 classification of internet service as a common carrier. That regulatory maneuver — known as “Title II” — established the foundation for the FCC to impose rules banning ISPs from blocking or degrading content, or from selling so called “fast lanes” to give speedier access to their subscribers. Pai’s proposal leaves open the question of just what the rules should be if the FCC gets rid of the “Title II” classification.

Those who favor repealing Title II, like broadband industry trade association USTelecom, argue that the figures cited by the Internet Association and Free Press include such things as Sprint’s leased handsets and AT&T’s investments via DirecTV and a Mexican affiliate. In other words, their numbers include things that don’t really reflect broadband investment.

Hal Singer, senior fellow at George Washington Institute of Public Policy, wrote in a blog post on Wednesday that “the hypothesis being tested is whether Title II discouraged investment in the core of the network; a diversion of investment to non-core areas is not proof that Title II ‘is working,’ as Free Press claims.”  He said that the figures showing an investment decline, coming from USTelecom, are considered “by many to be the industry gold standard.”

On the Internet Association press call, its representatives said that their figures rely on data that is standard practice in the industry. “We use a broader set of companies,” said Christopher Hooton, chief economist for the Internet Association. “We would argue that it is a more representative sample.”

They also point to figures that NCTA- The Internet and Television Association, representing cable companies, has on its site showing the growth of the cable industry’s investment in infrastructure. The figures only include investment from cable — not telecom internet providers — so it is not the entire industry.

Those figures some from SNL Kagan. In March, the research firm, a group within S&P Global Market Intelligence, provided figures showing that revenue in U.S. and Canada for networking equipment used to deliver cable, DSL and fiber broadband increased from $2.29 billion in 2015 to $2.95 billion in 2016. An SNL Kagan spokesman said that Canadian spending is a small percentage of the total, and does not count investments made in new fiber or other materials, as well as aggregation switches and routers.

This may be really getting into the weeds when it comes to net neutrality, but based on where things are headed, it’s a good indicator that the battle ahead will be as much about numbers and figures as it is politically charged online campaigns and on-the-street protests.

More Biz

  • Tokyo Film Festival and Market Choose

    Tokyo Film Festival and Market Set Separate Dates in 2019

    The Tokyo International Film Festival and its accompanying rights market, TIFFCOM, will be held on separate dates this year. Some film executives may have to choose to attend one or the other. The film festival Wednesday announced that it will be held from Monday, Oct 28 to Tues, Nov. 5. Previously, the TIFFCOM market said [...]

  • Jeremy Vuernick

    Capitol Music Group Promotes Jeremy Vuernick to Executive VP of A&R

    Jeremy Vuernick has been promoted to Executive Vice President of A&R for Capitol Music Group, it was announced today by CMG COO Michelle Jubelirer and president Ashley Newton. In his elevated position, Vuernick will draw upon his broad experience as an A&R executive to sign and develop artists for the company, as well as oversee recording projects for new and [...]

  • Darnell Strom

    Darnell Strom to Lead UTA's Newly Created Culture and Leadership Division

    Darnell Strom has joined UTA and is set to lead its newly created Culture and Leadership division. Strom will represent and work with existing and new UTA clients who want to expand their diverse businesses and cultural influence at the intersection of entertainment, media, entrepreneurship, politics, the arts, and thought leadership. Strom brings years of [...]


    British Lawmakers Reject Prime Minister's Brexit Plan, Heightening Uncertainty

    British lawmakers have resoundingly rejected Prime Minister Theresa May’s terms for the U.K.’s withdrawal from the European Union, heightening the country’s sense of uncertainty and paralysis less than two months before the exit is supposed to take effect. Parliament rejected May’s Brexit plan by a 432-202-vote Tuesday evening, one of the biggest parliamentary defeats in [...]

  • Dan Cohen nonesuch records

    Nonesuch Promotes Dan Cohen to Senior VP of Marketing

    Dan Cohen has been named Nonesuch Records’ senior vice president of marketing, the company announced today. In his new role, Cohen oversees marketing, sales, publicity, new media, and content creation for the long-running Warner Music Group label. Cohen reports to Nonesuch President David Bither and is based at the label’s headquarters in New York. Cohen [...]

  • hollywood debt

    Can Hollywood's Biggest Media Companies Avoid Getting Crushed by Debt?

    Randall Stephenson, AT&T’s chairman-CEO, summoned all of his folksy Oklahoma earnestness as he made an enthusiastic pitch to Wall Street analysts about the telephone company’s bold efforts to transform itself into a multimedia powerhouse. It was late November, less than six months after AT&T had wrapped up its $85 billion acquisition of Time Warner. But [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content