×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

FCC Chairman’s Net Neutrality Proposal Questions Need for Any Rules at All

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai this week proposed reversing the regulatory framework for net neutrality, leaving vague the question of just what the rules of the road for the internet should be.

The text of his proposal, unveiled on Thursday, asks whether many of the most significant rules are needed at all.

It seeks public comment on whether some of the most significant regulations that govern how internet providers handle traffic — such as those prohibiting blocking or throttling of content — are necessary, or if the commission still needs to keep or modify the existing rules.

“The Commission partially justified the 2015 rules on the theory that the rules would prevent anti-competitive behavior by broadband internet access providers’ seeking to advantage affiliated content,” the proposal noted. “With the existence of antitrust regulations aimed at curbing various forms of anticompetitive conduct, such as collusion and vertical restraints under certain circumstances, we seek comment on whether these rules are unnecessary in light of these other regulatory regimes.”

The proposal is just the first step in a months long process as Pai seeks to repeal the underpinnings of his predecessor’s net neutrality rules. After a commission vote on May 18, the proposal and its questions posed will go up for public comment, which is expected to be a big battle to win consumer interest and sentiment.

Pai’s proposal notes that before 2015, many large ISPs voluntarily abided by a blocking rule “in the absence of a regulatory obligation to do so.”

“Do we have reason to think providers would behave differently today if the Commission were to eliminate the no-blocking rule?” the proposal asks.

Pai’s proposal also is skeptical of an existing rule banning so-called paid prioritization, or the ability of internet providers to sell to content companies or other internet sites speedier access to the consumer. The fears and warnings that, left unchecked, the internet would devolve into fast lanes and slow lanes, giving an advantage to big media and internet companies, helped drive support for the FCC’s 2015 action.

“What are the trade-offs in banning business models dependent on paid prioritization versus allowing them to occur when overseen by a regulator or industry actors?” Pai’s proposal asks. “Is there a risk that banning paid prioritization suppresses pro-competitive activity? For example, could allowing paid prioritization give internet service providers a supplemental revenue stream that would enable them to offer lower-priced broadband internet access service to end-users? What would be the impacts on new startups and innovation?”

Pai makes the case that the FCC’s current rules, adopted in 2015, have diminished investment largely because the commission, in a party-line vote, reclassified the internet as a common carrier. That regulatory maneuver, referred to as “title II,” gave them the legal grounds to pass a robust set of rules that ban ISPs from blocking or throttling traffic, or from selling “fast lanes” to whoever wants to pay for the speediest access to the consumer.

The proposal makes clear that Pai wants to repeal title II, but it still leaves unclear what, if any, rules the FCC should adopt if the commission takes that action. Instead, it leaves it up for public comment on whether the no blocking, no throttling and no paid prioritization rules should be kept, modified or eliminated altogether.

But a read through the proposal leaves little doubt that Pai and his staff are skeptical of the need for many of the FCC rules, which critics have long characterized as “a solution in search of a problem,” and advocates say are at the heart of net neutrality. Pai has said that he is a fan of a set of guiding principles for the industry that were introduced in 2004 by then-FCC Chairman Michael Powell, who now leads NCTA — the Internet & Television Association.

Another question in the proposal, left up for comment: “Is there any evidence of market failure, or is there likely to be, sufficient to warrant pre-emptive, comprehensive regulation?”

Some Republicans on Capitol Hill hope that as the FCC process moves along, Democrats will want to negotiate on legislation to settle the issue once and for all.

More Biz

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    Agencies Offer to Restart Talks With WGA to End Packaging Fee Standoff

    Hollywood’s largest talent agencies have offered to restart negotiations with the WGA to end the standoff over the guild’s effort to impose new rules on talent agents. In a letter to WGA West president David Goodman sent Wednesday, UTA co-president Jay Sures extended an olive branch and suggested resuming talks next week. UTA later sent [...]

  • Woodstock 50 Files Appeal Seeking Return

    Woodstock 50 Files Appeal Seeking Return of $18 Million From Former Financial Partner

    In the latest round of the ongoing legal battle between the organizers of Woodstock 50 and their erstwhile partners Dentsu Aegis, attorney Marc Kasowitz announced that the festival has filed an appeal for Dentsu to return some $18.5 million the financial giant withdrew from the organizers’ bank account. That money has been a point of [...]

  • Spider-Man Homecoming

    Film and TV Productions Are Using Drones for Scouting Locations, Lighting and More

    Since a ruling by the Federal Aviation Administration in 2014 that cleared the use of drones in film and TV production, the acquisition of footage by these unmanned flying machines has become de rigueur for aerial shooting in cases when cranes or aircraft are impractical or unsafe.  As such, drones have been greeted enthusiastically not [...]

  • White House Communications Director Hope Hicks,

    House Judiciary Committee Issues Subpoena for Fox Spokeswoman Hope Hicks

    The House Judiciary Committee has issued a subpoena for Hope Hicks, the Fox Corporation communications chief who previously worked as the communications director in President Donald Trump’s White House. The call for Hicks to appear before the committee was issued Tuesday. Hicks could not be reached for immediate comment on the matter. Hicks was in [...]

  • Stephanie Dalton City National Bank

    Why City National Handles Financing for Half the Shows on Broadway

    Seen a Broadway show lately? If the answer is yes, then there’s a pretty good chance that Stephanie Dalton and her team at City National Bank have played a role in the financial life of the production. That can mean anything from managing the cash that a show takes in at the box office to [...]

  • Broadway Theater Placeholder

    The Great Green Way: Inside Broadway's Economic Boom

    Here’s an old Broadway story, probably apocryphal, but with the ring of truth: A worried producer checks in on his ticket sales to see how his show is doing. “We had a terrible night, boss,” the treasurer tells him. “We did one penny.” The producer sulks through Shubert Alley and runs into a rival. “How’s [...]

  • TV Ad Sales Upfronts

    TV's Upfront Market May Be More Complex Than Networks Expected (EXCLUSIVE)

    TV’s “upfront” ad-sales market has started to simmer. What will be required to bring it to full boil? TV networks and media buyers hope to answer that question in coming weeks – if not days. In this annual market for advance commitments to buy commercial time, Madison Avenue and TV sales executives haggle over the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content