ASCAP Joins BMI in Dept. of Justice Licensing Smackdown

As the U.S. Department of Justice continues its effort to upend the licensing terms governing songwriters, it now faces a unified front of resistance, with ASCAP throwing its lot in with BMI, filing an amicus brief in support of what is normally a competing performing rights organization.

SESAC and GMR also filed friend-of-the-court briefs supporting BMI’s position, leaving the DOJ to faces off against every major performing rights organization and, essentially, federal court judge Louis Stanton whose September ruling on the matter favored BMI. The DOJ then appealed to the Second Circuit, filing multiple requests for extension, the last of which was denied. With battle lines drawn, the DOJ has loaded for bear with friendly firepower from tech firms like Google, Netflix and iHeart Media, among others. Oral arguments are expected to commence late this year or early in 2018.

At the heart of the battle is whether or not the government has the authority to go beyond the language of the actual consent decrees rules under which BMI and ASCAP have been operating since 1941. ASCAP contends that since the government’s arguments concerning the BMI decree would in theory also apply to ASCAP’s consent decree, it has a vested interest.

Indeed, ASCAP, seeming to bank on a favorable outcome for BMI, is actively requesting that any decision issued by the Second Circuit apply equally to ASCAP. “As the Government has previously acknowledged, it is important that ASCAP and BMI operate under the same set of rules and that the industry have a ‘common understanding’ of both decrees,” the organization states.

In filing the amicus brief, ASCAP CEO Elizabeth Matthews commented that “ASCAP, and its more than 625,000 members, stands shoulder to shoulder with BMI in our unified fight for the rights of songwriters.” ASCAP calls out the DOJ, pointing out that “although the government argues that ‘years of interpretations by federal courts’ support its interpretations of the decrees, there is, in fact, no case that holds that consent decrees require full-work licensing.”

The full-work licensing the government seeks to impose on songwriters would allow for any copyright holder in a song that has multiple “owners” (or writers) to license the song on behalf of the entire group, with first-mover deals setting terms for everyone.

The Songwriters of North America (SONA) have separately filed suit against the DOJ, combating the same 100-percent licensing principle. SONA argues that by forcing property owners to surrender ownership rights either against their will or at the very least without their specific approval, the government’s vision of 100 percent licensing violates the fifth amendment of the U.S. Constitution, also known as the “takings clause.”

BMI, ASCAP and the other friendly PRO amicus briefers contend that this new and seemingly novel government interpretation of the consent decrees, if implemented, would be extremely disruptive to the licensing marketplace.

It is accepted industry practice for license fees to be priced, and music creators’ royalties paid, on the basis of fractional shares. Music users typically obtain licenses from all PROs and do not rely on a single PRO license for a full-work grant. The switch to a single-license system could impact songwriters’ already ailing bottom-lines, the tunesmiths contend.

The DOJ now has a week to reply to the songwriter-favoring comments.

Popular on Variety

More Music

  • Maya Thurman Hawke at the Premiere

    Maya Hawke Debuts Two Singles Ahead of Album Release

    Fresh off her Manson cult role in Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” Maya Hawke is turning to music. The “Stranger Things” star released two new singles Friday, “To Love a Boy” and “Stay Open,” both of which will appear on her yet-to-be-titled upcoming album. Hawke wrote the lyrics and Grammy-winning singer-songwriter Jesse [...]

  • Woodstock Festival of Arts and Music

    As Woodstock Turns 50, the Fest's 10 Most Sacred Music Moments (Watch)

    Cars were left abandoned along the New York Interstate. Electrical and speaker systems fuzzed and popped. Amps blew then went silent. The rain was endless as the mud sank deep and rank. Young children ran naked and dazed through crowds of strangers. Food was scarce. Water, unclean. Looking back, Woodstock seems a more apocalyptic, than [...]

  • 'ZZ Top: That Little Ol' Band

    Film Review: 'ZZ Top: That Little Ol' Band From Texas'

    Settling in to watch “ZZ Top: That Little Ol’ Band From Texas,” you may have a burning question that applies to almost no other rock documentary, and that is: Who, exactly, are these guys? The ones behind the beards? If you’re old enough, of course, you probably know that ZZ Top started out, in 1969, [...]


    Jay-Z to Acquire Ownership Stake in NFL Team (Report)

    Jay-Z will soon acquire a “significant ownership interest” in an NFL team, TMZ reported on Friday. The team was not disclosed, but a source told the site the deal will happen in the “near future,” adding that the billionaire rapper “wants to continue to be a change agent for the NFL.” Jay-Z’s company, Roc Nation, [...]


    How 'Blinded by the Light' Brought Bruce Springsteen's Music to the Screen for a Song

    Blinded by the Light co-writer/director Gurinder Chadha knows firsthand what it feels like to be an outsider. Born in Kenya when the country was a British colony, she grew up part of the Indian/Asian diaspora who made their way from East Africa to London. For that reason, the 59-year-old’s movies has always dealt with the [...]

  • Blake Shelton, Trace AdkinsCMA Music Festival

    Blake Shelton Takes a Shot at 'Old Town Road' in New Single

    Blake Shelton and Trace Adkins have just released a duet, “Hell Right,” that seems to have a beef with “Old Town Road.” But is it a light-hearted, maybe even affectionate slam — or should anyone read culture-war significance into the two country stars expressing a preference for Hank Williams Jr. over Lil Nas X, the breakout [...]

  • Led Zeppelin Stairway to Heaven

    Department of Justice Backs Led Zeppelin in ‘Stairway to Heaven’ Copyright Case

    The U.S. Department of Justice has weighed in on the next big music copyright case on the horizon following the Katy Perry “Dark Horse” decision, and taken Led Zeppelin’s side in the long-running copyright dispute that pits the writers of the group’s anthem “Stairway to Heaven” against the publishers of the earlier song “Taurus” by [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content