×

Production Design Artists Debate Hand Versus Computer Drafting

Much is written about the enormous impact of technology in such film disciplines as cinematography and visual effects, but production design has also been hugely affected. One of the big issues these days within art departments is balancing traditional hand drafting with computer drafting.

Hand draftspeople are traditional artists who work with pencils to draw sets, bringing a production designer’s vision to life through sketches, construction blueprints and physical models. Computer draftspeople use technology to do the same thing and work with digital models that can be edited rapidly in ways that physical miniatures cannot.

Longtime set designer Scott Herbertson (“Avatar”) was a pioneer. He transitioned from hand to computer drafting in the early ’90s and considers the computer an asset that allows multiple set designers to work together more effectively, sharing files while drafting sets. “It gives the art department more control of the final look of a movie,” Herbertson says.

Computer-drafted plans also are easily shared among departments. While there’s no standard program, department heads can convert the set designer’s files for their own purposes, allowing each to work more efficiently. Though plans have always been distributed production-wide, the scanned PDF of hand drafting doesn’t allow for the same flexibility.

But while the computer may hasten the process for other departments, within the art department that isn’t always the case. If hand and computer set designers begin a job at the same time, two days in, those drafting by hand will be ahead, according to Greg Papalia, who hand-drafted sets for “War for the Planet of the Apes.”

That’s because hand draftspeople begin with construction blueprints of the proposed set, which refine the production designer’s vision and are used to obtain approval of the concept from the director and producers. Computer draftspeople, on the other hand, begin the process from a different point, transforming the production designer’s idea into a digital 3D model. Once approved, they then start the construction drawings in which the hand draftspeople are already immersed.

These 3D models may not always be practical, but production designers have come to appreciate the additional visuals. “Spider-Man: Homecoming” supervising art director Brad Ricker has found the recent designers he’s worked with to be very digitally oriented.

War for the planet of the apes Production Design
CREDIT: Courtesy of 20th Century Fox

Post-production-driven films would seem at first to benefit most from a fully digital art department, but that might not always be true. Anything can be hand-drafted, and Ricker, Papalia and Herbertson all agree that hand is better than digital for organic environments such as trees, caves and logs. Despite “Apes’” huge reliance on digital motion capture, Papalia estimates it was 75% hand-drawn.

Says Ricker: “It’s antithetical to digital design yet very natural for hand drafting to make things that are twisted, broken, crushed and misshapen.” Hand drawing also adds an element of creativity, he notes. “With computer drafting, you don’t draw a column two or three times, you draw it once and then copy it. When drawing by hand, there’s no reason to make all of the columns the same; you can add character as you go.”

Regardless of approach, Papalia says set designers must understand related crafts. “Very often you have carpenters working with wood, fabricators working in steel, sculptors working in many materials, and then you’ve also got visual effects concerns,” he says. “All of that boils down to the designer defining points in space — how far one element is from another.”

No one is more invested in those points than the construction coordinator, who’s responsible for deciphering plans to actually build the sets. Mike Villarino (“The Greatest Showman”) has overseen the construction of some of the industry’s most elaborate sets. “The biggest thing I’ve noticed,” he says, “is when people draw by hand it seems like they encounter the same issues I do when I try to build. A lot of times when I get computer prints, they’re missing information.”

Part of the problem, Herbertson believes, may be that there are no longer tests and portfolio reviews to standardize skills. “You had lead set designers who actually functioned like lead set designers and supervised juniors,” he says. “Now, it’s just a title.”

While the best art departments may have both hand and computer set designers, giving the crew a breadth of skill at its fingertips, things continue to evolve: Most new designers don’t even study hand drafting in school. For now, though, there are still many hand drafters on the union roster.

“In the end,” says Herbertson, “good design is good design.”

War for the planet of the apes Production Design
CREDIT: Courtesy of 20th Century Fox

Popular on Variety

More Artisans

  • Motherless Brooklyn BTS Edward Norton

    Edward Norton Hails His 'Motherless Brooklyn' Crew for Their 'Career-Best' Work

    Edward Norton wrote, directed, produced and stars in Warner Bros.’ “Motherless Brooklyn,” but he’s quick to give credit to his behind-the-camera collaborators. Norton told Variety: “I think this is career-best work for some of these people.” The film is set in 1950s New York, and the team accomplished a lot on a budget of $26 million [...]

  • American Society of Cinematographers Honoring Frederick

    American Society of Cinematographers to Honor Frederick Elmes

    The American Society of Cinematographers will honor Frederick Elmes with a lifetime achievement award. The ASC is also honoring Donald A. Morgan with the career achievement in television award, Bruno Delbonnel with the international award; and Don McCuaig with the presidents awards. The accolades will be presented at the annual ASC awards gala on Jan. [...]

  • Camerimage includes 'Joker' in Main Competition.

    Camerimage Main Competition includes ‘Ford v Ferrari,’ ‘Joker’ and ‘The Irishman’

    Several awards season contenders — including “Ford v Ferrari” (pictured), “Joker” and “the Irishman” — will screen in the main competition at Camerimage, the cinematography-oriented film festival that will take place in Torun, Poland, on Nov. 9-16. In alphabetical order, the selected films are: “Amundsen” (Norway); director: by Espen Sandberg: cinematographer: Pål Ulvik Rokseth “Bolden” [...]

  • First still from the set of

    How the 'Jojo Rabbit' Production Team Created a Child's View of Nazi Germany

    When picturing Nazi Germany during World War II, most people think of black-and-white or sepia-toned images of drab cities. For the cinematographer and production designer of “Jojo Rabbit,” a film set squarely in that time and place, it became clear that the color palette of the era was far more varied than they could have [...]

  • National Theatre Live Midsummer's Night Dream

    National Theatre Live Marks Decade of Stage-to-Screen With Immersive ‘Midsummer’

    National Theatre Live has filmed nearly eight dozen theatrical productions over the last decade, bringing theater to the cinema using top technologies and talents in the videography space. This month, on the eve of its 10th anniversary, its production of “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is challenging the technical producers and crew with an immersive stage [...]

  • 180423_A24_Day_03B_0897.jpg

    How Bright Bulbs Enabled 'The Lighthouse's' Tough Black-and-White Shoot

    Early in development on “The Lighthouse,” writer-director Robert Eggers asked cinematographer Jarin Blaschke if he thought they could capture the look they were going for digitally. Blaschke answered no: Digital wouldn’t let them achieve the texture they had in mind — “what we photography nerds would call ‘micro-contrast.’ [The look] was never going to be [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content