×

Production Pros Weigh Pros and Cons of Helicopters vs. Drones

It’s hard not to hum Wagner’s “Ride of the Valkyries” from “Apocalypse Now” as Kevin LaRosa II of Helinet Aviation carefully lines up the Airbus AS350 B2 helicopter he’s piloting behind the company’s newly acquired Sikorsky Black Hawk.

DP Hans Bjerno, controlling the camera from a seat in back, grabs a shot of the former military chopper silhouetted against the big orange morning sun.

The convoy is traveling north of L.A. to Sable Ranch in Santa Clarita, Calif., to film a sequence for the upcoming CBS series “SWAT” in which star Shemar Moore will stand in the open door of the Black Hawk, firing a rifle at hostage takers below.

Originally, producers planned to use a drone for the scene. But after consulting with LaRosa, it was determined that the downwash from the Black Hawk’s rotor blades would be too much for a drone to withstand, so the scene was reconfigured for a trailing helicopter, which opened up a horizon of possibilities, according to LaRosa. “I can be doing 120 knots with a helicopter, a 90-degree bank and following something in,” says the pilot, a second-generation movie chopper operator who serves as Helinet’s VP of aerial film production. “You can’t do that with a drone — at least not yet.”

Nonetheless, drones play a major role in today’s moviemaking. They may not be as strong, fast or Wagner-evocative as a helicopter, but they can do things larger craft can’t, like fly through trees and tight spaces. They can execute hybrid camera moves, sweeping down like a crane, circling the subject like a handheld SteadiCam, then rising into the sky like a helicopter minus the hurricane-level winds.

“If you have an alley that you’re doing a foot chase through or a tight motorcycle chase that doesn’t have a lot of speed, a drone’s great,” says veteran stunt coordinator and second unit director Andy Gill. “But if you’re using cars like we do on ‘The Fast and the Furious,’ you need a chopper.”

The cost differential is steep. A used AS350 runs around $1 million on the low end, and that’s before it’s outfitted with camera controls and Helinet’s Shotover F1, a gimbal-like device. A DJI M600 drone (top speed: 40 mph) equipped with a Ronin-MX gimbal that can hold digital cinema cameras such as the Red Epic and Arri Alexa Mini can be purchased new for $6,000. And a DJI Inspire 2 with a built in 4K camera (top speed just under 60 mph) retails for $6,200.

Top aviation companies can charge a production anywhere from $10K to $25K per day for a helicopter and crew, and roughly half that for their drone services. But there are independent drone operators with insurance and FAA clearance who charge $100 to $300 per hour. Yet producers who try to save money with a drone sometimes end up paying for a helicopter as well.  “I’ve had a lot of calls for reshoots where they can’t get the shots with the drone because the wind is too high,” says Bjerno. “There are no wind conditions that really will shut down a helicopter.”

The reason helicopter shoots are so pricey is clear when LaRosa touches down on set. A Teamster-driven water truck sprays down the landing area to reduce debris kicked up by the rotors’ downwash — but not so much that crew members don’t take cover behind vehicles whenever the choppers take off or land — and a refueling truck is on standby to refill the AS350’s 143-gallon tank and the Black Hawk’s even thirstier 363-gallon tank. By contrast, a drone runs on rechargeable batteries that fit in the trunk of a car.

The convenience and affordability of drones has also created a glut of people offering to fly them for productions. “There’s so much competition, you’ve got to keep the prices down [on drone work] or you don’t get any jobs,” says Helinet production coordinator John Burton.

If something goes wrong with a copter, the destructive potential is greater. Drones, too, require a serious degree of professional vigilance. “You still have to do the same safety lockups — what we call sanitize the streets — and make sure there are no pedestrians around,” says location manager Eric Hooge. With pro-level drones now carrying redundant battery systems, their crash risk has been reduced.

While choppers may still rule the skies in the eyes of some production pros, others are discovering new uses for drones, from location scouting to 3D modeling.

“When we get the technology in people’s hands, a light-bulb moment happens and they say, ‘This is perfect for X, Y and Z,’” says Michael Perry, managing director of drone maker DJI North America. “And often that X, Y and Z aren’t what they thought it was for originally.”

Watch the video “Choppers vs. Drones: The Battle for Cinematic Air Supremacy” below. 

Popular on Variety

More Artisans

  • Camerimage includes 'Joker' in Main Competition.

    Camerimage Main Competition includes ‘Ford v Ferrari,’ ‘Joker’ and ‘The Irishman’

    Several awards season contenders — including “Ford v Ferrari” (pictured), “Joker” and “the Irishman” — will screen in the main competition at Camerimage, the cinematography-oriented film festival that will take place in Torun, Poland, on Nov. 9-16. In alphabetical order, the selected films are: “Amundsen” (Norway); director: by Espen Sandberg: cinematographer: Pål Ulvik Rokseth “Bolden” [...]

  • First still from the set of

    How the 'Jojo Rabbit' Production Team Created a Child's View of Nazi Germany

    When picturing Nazi Germany during World War II, most people think of black-and-white or sepia-toned images of drab cities. For the cinematographer and production designer of “Jojo Rabbit,” a film set squarely in that time and place, it became clear that the color palette of the era was far more varied than they could have [...]

  • National Theatre Live Midsummer's Night Dream

    National Theatre Live Marks Decade of Stage-to-Screen With Immersive ‘Midsummer’

    National Theatre Live has filmed nearly eight dozen theatrical productions over the last decade, bringing theater to the cinema using top technologies and talents in the videography space. This month, on the eve of its 10th anniversary, its production of “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is challenging the technical producers and crew with an immersive stage [...]

  • 180423_A24_Day_03B_0897.jpg

    How Bright Bulbs Enabled 'The Lighthouse's' Tough Black-and-White Shoot

    Early in development on “The Lighthouse,” writer-director Robert Eggers asked cinematographer Jarin Blaschke if he thought they could capture the look they were going for digitally. Blaschke answered no: Digital wouldn’t let them achieve the texture they had in mind — “what we photography nerds would call ‘micro-contrast.’ [The look] was never going to be [...]

  • Advanced Imaging Society Honors 10 Women

    AIS Honors 10 Women in Tech

    Celebrating 10 years of achievement in entertainment technology, the Advanced Imaging Society today named 10 female industry innovators who will receive the organization’s 2019 Distinguished Leadership Awards at the its 10th annual Entertainment Technology Awards ceremony on October 28 in Beverly Hills. The individuals were selected by an awards committee for being significant “entertainment industry [...]

  • Will Smith Gemini Man Special Effects

    How the 'Gemini Man' VFX Team Digitally Created a Younger Version of Will Smith

    More human than human — yes, that’s a “Blade Runner” reference — yet it sounds like an unattainable standard when it comes to creating believable, photorealistic, digital human characters. But the visual effects team on Ang Lee’s “Gemini Man” set its sights on something even more difficult: creating a digital version of young Will Smith [...]

  • Jest to Impress Cartoon Network Virtual

    New In-House VR Program Helps Cartoon Network Artists Add a Virtual Dimension

    Teams of animators and artists from across Cartoon Network’s numerous properties are getting the chance to expand into virtual reality storytelling via the company’s pilot program, Journeys VR. The work of the first three teams — including experiences based on action, nature and comedy — was unveiled to global audiences Oct. 1 on Steam and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content