Unscripted TV Lawsuits Indicate Need for Change (Guest Column)

Two intractable forces have turned a once-healthy unscripted-TV ecosystem toxic over the past several years.

The first is the decline of cable channels, which are facing an existential threat from cord-cutting, the grim long-term outlook for their advertising and affiliate revenues, and intensified competition from streaming services like Netflix.

The second is the number of independent production companies that have been gobbled up by international media conglomerates for stunning amounts of money, providing their owner-producers with enviable paydays.

It’s only natural that this windfall is going to stir some resentment from the companies that own cable channels. After all, if it weren’t for the channels that take the financial risk of licensing these series, the production companies wouldn’t be reaping the benefits of the hit TV properties that drive their gaudy valuations.

In reaction to these shifts in the media landscape, some short-sighted buyers are trying to penalize their key producers for the systemic downturn in the cable business. These less enlightened networks have responded to the shrinking revenue pie by trying to squeeze more out of producers, endangering their profits.

All sorts of costs that were part of the program budget — requests for extra edits, executive-producer fees for talent, certain legal fees — are now loaded against the producers’ 10% profit margin, in some cases forcing it down to less than half of that. State tax incentives that used to be shared by producer and channel are now being demanded entirely by some channels. Additionally, production companies are expected to provide bonus footage for channels’ digital extensions at no extra charge, and to cover the cost of an endless loop of expensive development reels in place of pilots.

By financially choking the very producers on which the networks have always depended, these channels will see impoverished development going forward. For producers and buyers to survive, the ecosystem must get healthy again. Smart cable networks must continue to work in partnership with producers rather than alienate them by demanding free rights they really don’t want and won’t ever properly exploit.

My association, PactUS, has undertaken a series of initiatives to offer solutions to some of the more stubborn industry-wide issues brought to light by the LMNO/Discovery legal wrangling that has been chronicled by Variety. This begins with identifying alternative sources of funding, and working with flexible buyers who are willing to give increased global or digital rights in exchange for lower license fees. We are also taking steps to directly address a major issue raised by Discovery in its countersuit, which asserted that there were “false budgets” that “went far beyond ‘padding,’ or generous but good-faith estimates of actual costs.”

In an era when producers have to counter margin pressures and harsh cost environ- ments, PactUS has embarked on a multi-faceted project that will generate data from both sides through a series of meetings with cable channels and producers, plus other elements that will lead to PactUS publishing new industry guidelines. That can help all parties come to the budgeting and cost-reporting process in a more structured and easy manner that helps strengthen partnerships between networks and indies.

And to guard against the specter of a company being plunged into an awful hole by the actions of a consultant or employee, PactUS has organized a members’ catastrophe insurance program to protect them in these types of devastating circumstances.

Yet one primary ingredient is still needed to prevent the headwinds of change in the cable business from blowing out the heart of an entire industry: the ability of everyone involved to recognize that deal dynamics need to return to a more level playing field if creativity is to bloom.

PactUS president David Lyle previously served as CEO of National Geographic Channels, president of Fox Look and Fox Reality Channel, and president of entertainment for FremantleMedia North America.

More Voices

  • Hollywood Has Come Far With Diversity

    An Insider's Look at Hollywood's Diversity Efforts and How Far It Still Needs to Go

    I am a white man working in Hollywood. I grew up in Beverlywood, an all-white, predominantly Jewish, Los Angeles neighborhood sandwiched between 20th Century Fox Studios and MGM, where my elementary school had only one black student. I am compelled to write about diversity in Hollywood because “diversity” — in front of and behind the camera [...]

  • Venice Film Festival A Star is

    How Venice, Toronto and Telluride Festivals Stole Cannes' Luster (Column)

    In all the years I’ve been attending film festivals, I have never seen a lineup that looked as good on paper as Venice’s did this fall, boasting new films by Alfonso Cuarón (“Roma”), Damien Chazelle (“First Man”), Paul Greengrass (“22 July”), Mike Leigh (“Peterloo”) and the Coen brothers (“The Ballad of Buster Scruggs”) in competition, [...]

  • Black Women in Medicine BTS

    Hollywood Needs to Include People With Disabilities on Both Sides of the Camera (Guest Column)

    In five years, nothing has changed. Despite open calls for greater diversity and inclusion, recent research shows that there was little change in the number of characters with disabilities in popular films in 2017. A study conducted by the Annenberg Inclusion Initiative of the University of Southern California’s Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism found that [...]

  • Seven Seconds

    Fighting the Racial Bias at the Core of Hollywood’s Cop Shows (Guest Column)

    If fiction is the lie that tells a deeper truth, the TV crime genre has been, for the most part, the lie that simply tells a lie. As a storyteller (Veena) and an advocate for racial justice (Rashad), we collaborated for the past two-and-a-half years in an attempt to reimagine the roles of cops, victims, [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein Trial

    Column: Documentarian Barry Avrich Ponders Whether Harvey Weinstein Will Be Convicted

    Will Harvey Weinstein go to jail? That’s perhaps the most debated topic in Hollywood. It’s a question that makes me miss my friend Dominick Dunne, the controversial Vanity Fair columnist who would have already succeeded in interview-ing the chambermaids at Harvey’s sex-addiction clinic. Dunne once prophetically told me there would be a massive reckoning in Hollywood. He [...]

  • Janet Mock Pose

    'Pose' Writer Janet Mock on Making History With Trans Storytelling (Guest Column)

    I first met Ryan Murphy on location in Hollywood in July. The set was a nightclub, filled with background actors staged as glistening go-go dancers, shirtless revelers, and twirling drag queens. They were all basking under the glow of a spinning disco ball — a fitting setting for my first Hollywood job interview. I was [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content