TV Review: Joel McHale’s ‘The Great Indoors’ on CBS

A new CBS sitcom pits a snarky Gen X-er against three tech-savvy millennials

Joel McHale, Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Susannah Fielding, Chris Williams, Christine Ko, Shaun Brown, and Stephen Fry

The Great Indoors” has shades of NBC’s “Community” right from the start. In “Community,” lead Joel McHale was Jeff Winger, a sour and unwilling leader for a group of misfits. In “The Great Indoors,” he’s Jack Gordon, a sour and unwilling mascot for a group of millennials. Like Jeff, Jack is arrogant, sarcastic, and convinced that his deadpan delivery works well with women; like Jeff, Jack probably has a good heart underneath all those pectoral muscles. And as in “Community,” Jack begins “The Great Indoors” on the cusp of being dragged into an unwilling life lesson about the inevitability of change.

The difference is that “The Great Indoors” doesn’t seem to understand that McHale’s character is a jerk. In the first few minutes of the pilot, Jack (Joel McHale) turns to his co-workers and observes, sarcastically, that they are “so diverse.” The three younger employees are slightly bemused, unsure how to respond to a statement of fact, as the audience laughs on cue. In the same segment, Jack also tells one of the employees that he has a “made-up job title” and refers to the web team as the “digital daycare division.”

The premise of the sitcom is that Jack, the editor of an outdoor adventure magazine, returns from a long trip in the field to discover that print operations are being shut down. He’s being pulled back into the office to create web content, a transition that is all too familiar to anyone plugged into the publishing industry in the last decade. While he was climbing mountains and camping in the woods, the world has changed. In order to navigate his new reality, Jack is joined by his three young co-workers (Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Christine Ko, and Shaun Brown) and his rich, older mentor, Roland (Stephen Fry, impeccable as always). With two different generational gaps on display, “The Great Indoors” should have a built-in sense of perspective on Jack’s selfish panic.

It doesn’t. The writers seem too enamored of the opportunity to rely on the laziest possible jokes about millennials in particular. The sitcom could have a little bit of melancholic sweetness to it, but “The Great Indoors” instead takes it upon itself to issue value judgments on an entire generation of people, and the result is perplexing and off-putting. It makes for a rather uncomfortable half-hour, where the audience is asked to identify with an undermining, insulting protagonist.

In the second episode released to critics, Jack and the millennials take on dating apps, and the sitcom settles into the familiar paces of a workplace sitcom. When “The Great Indoors” can distance itself from the massive Generation X chip on its shoulder, it becomes warmer and funnier — positioning Jack as the self-absorbed lout he is, while also allowing his snark to propel the other characters to action. But as long as the show so openly loathes its young people, it’ll be disappointing, unfunny, and eminently skippable.

TV Review: Joel McHale's 'The Great Indoors' on CBS

Comedy, 13 episodes (2 reviewed): CBS, Thurs. Oct. 27, 8:30 p.m. 30 min.

Crew: Executive producers, Mike Gibbons, Chris Harris, Andy Ackerman

Cast: Joel McHale, Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Susannah Fielding, Chris Williams, Christine Ko, Shaun Brown, and Stephen Fry

More TV

  • TV News Roundup: 'Million Dollar Mile'

    TV News Roundup: 'Million Dollar Mile' Debuts Exclusive First Look

    In today’s roundup, “Million Dollar Mile” releases an exclusive clip and CBS announces premiere dates for three shows.  DATES More Reviews West End Review: 'Emilia' Film Review: Tim Burton's 'Dumbo' CBS has announced premiere dates for one new series and two returning series. The new action adventure series “Blood and Treasure” will debut with a [...]

  • WGA Agents Contract Tug of War

    Agents Accuse Writers Guild of Threatening to Throw 'Industry Into Chaos'

    The dealmakers appear to be getting nowhere. Negotiators for Hollywood agents and the Writers Guild of America have achieved little progress at their seventh session on Tuesday, with a chaotic scenario looming on April 7. “When Guild leadership is ready to move on from their declared threatening phase, we stand ready to work through these [...]

  • Jussie Smollett Empire

    Assessing 'Empire' Options After Jussie Smollett Charges Dropped

    The shocking Jussie Smollett saga took another twist on Tuesday after prosecutors announced they have dropped all charges against the “Empire” star. Smollett had been indicted on 16 counts of filing a false police report, but now that those counts have all disappeared, studio 20th Century Fox finds itself in a sticky situation as to [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett's Legal Drama Eclipses the Rest of His Story (Column)

    Like so many other stories these days, the Jussie Smollett legal saga seemed governed not by coherent logic, but by chaos, and, in its absence of narrative, invites any observer to find in it the story they prefer hearing. Smollett, the “Empire” star who had been in legal jeopardy due to allegations of staging a [...]

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    Writers Guild Plans for Agency Pact Expiration: 'There Will Be Difficult Moments'

    Leaders of the Writers Guild of America have sent members contingency plans for the possible expiration of its agency franchise agreement on April 7 — and admitted that it may be a rocky road. Members received the letter Tuesday from the guild’s negotiating committee as the WGA and agents were about the hold their seventh [...]

  • univision-dish blackout

    Univision, Dish Network Reach Carriage Deal After Nine-Month Blackout

    Univision and satcaster Dish Network have reached a carriage agreement after a nine-month blackout that marked one of the longest standoffs between a major programmer and distributor. Univision channels went dark on Dish Network’s satellite and streaming platforms on June 30. The sides were at odds over carriage fees that have become increasingly contentious for [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content