TV Review: ‘Making a Murderer’ Revisited by ID’s ‘Steven Avery: Innocent or Guilty?’

Host: Keith Morrison

Investigation Discovery is nothing if not opportunistic, distilling the 10 hours that Netflix devoted to “Making a Murderer” into a one-hour edition of “Front Page With Keith Morrison,” subtitled “Steven Avery: Innocent or Guilty?” While a big step up from Nancy Grace’s incoherent, foaming-at-the-mouth HLN special, the documentary covers a lot of ground without bringing much new to the story, other than unleashing “Dateline NBC’s” Morrison on it, and the ghoulish demeanor that has made his true-crime reporting so ripe for satire.

Aside from recapping Avery’s tale – how he was exonerated on rape charges after 18 years in jail, and subsequently convicted of a brutal murder – the hour basically boils down to a back and forth between two attorneys involved in the second trial: prosecutor Ken Kratz (who declined to participate in “Making a Murderer,” but has been defending himself elsewhere since its December debut), and Avery defense lawyer Jerry Buting. (Notably, both are also featured in “Dateline NBC’s” separate take on the case, “The State of Wisconsin Vs. Steven A. Avery,” which features interviews with many of the same people and is scheduled for Jan. 29.)

In perhaps the newsiest part of the ID special, the last third or so delves into the aftermath of Netflix’s series, with Kratz outlining what he considered oversights and omissions that tip the scales toward a misperception that Avery was railroaded. Buting, for his part, pretty effortlessly refutes most of those, and also discusses who might have killed photographer Teresa Halbach if Avery and his nephew, Brendan Dassey, didn’t.

Still, at the risk of spoiling things – or merely sparing those who might be expecting an answer to the subtitle’s question in an hour’s time – it’s unlikely anyone who has watched “Making a Murderer” will extract much that’s fresh or opinion-changing here. And while the hour is even-handed, its central conclusion boils down to Buting’s observation that with Avery getting a new lawyer, there is surely more to come.

Of course, the whole point of these programs from NBC News’ Peacock Prods. – a genre which ID has dubbed “instamentaries,” thanks to their ability to respond quickly to a story making headlines – is to get there fast and first, way before something like “Law & Order” can. And in that respect, it’s hard to think of anything more ripe for further analysis than the Avery case, which has become a near-obsession for many who raced through it.

What ID has delivered, though, is, in literary terms, the abridged version of “Making a Murderer,” with a brief epilogue tacked on. And if the original contained the twists and turns often associated with a great novel, then think of this as either a public service for those who don’t have the time or inclination to read it or, less charitably, “Making a Murderer” for Dummies.

TV Review: 'Making a Murderer' Revisited by ID's 'Steven Avery: Innocent or Guilty?'

(Special; Investigation Discovery, Sat. Jan. 30, 9 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Peacock Prods.

Crew: Executive producers, Elizabeth Fischer, Knute Walker, Diana Sperrazza. 60 MIN.

Cast: Host: Keith Morrison

More TV

  • Orange is the New Black

    How 'Orange Is the New Black' Changed TV Forever (Column)

    When Netflix debuted “House of Cards” in 2013, it seemed like streaming was going to mimic premium as we already knew it. The premiere of “Orange Is the New Black” five months later ended that notion for good. Based on Piper Kerman’s memoir, the show ostensibly followed Piper (played by Taylor Schilling), a bright but [...]

  • Kian Lawley Starring in Finnish Comedy

    Kian Lawley, Katherine C. Hughes Starring in Finnish Comedy 'Perfect Commando'

    Kian Lawley, who was dropped from movie “The Hate U Give” last year after a video resurfaced of him that included racist comments, has landed a starring role alongside Katherine C. Hughes (“Blue Bloods”) in the Finnish comedy “Perfect Commando.” The series is the latest original for Elisa Viihde’s Aitio streaming service, and will be [...]

  • Chris Hardwick Aziz Ansari MeToo Comeback

    Aziz Ansari, Chris Hardwick's Reemergence Complicate the #MeToo Conversation

    Aziz Ansari’s new Netflix stand-up special “Right Now” marks the comedian’s return to the spotlight more than a year after being publicly accused of sexual impropriety, an allegation that has proved to be divisive, fueling discussions about what is considered consent and what constitutes sexual assault. His isn’t the only redemptive arc forming at the [...]

  • Jenji Kohan with two-time Emmy winner

    Inside 'Orange Is the New Black's' Unlikely Journey to Become Netflix's Most-Watched Original

    Before “Netflix and chill” entered the cultural lexicon, before the streaming platform won its first Emmy, before it started inking deals with major showrunners, Netflix in the early 2010s was testing out a hypothesis about the public’s appetite for premium-quality television shows on the internet. It had recently recovered from the Qwikster debacle — an [...]

  • John Malone

    Liberty Global and Vodafone's $21.5 Billion Cable Deal Cleared by European Authorities

    The European Commission has approved Vodafone’s $21.5 billion deal for a raft of Liberty Global assets in Europe, with conditions attached. The commission had investigated the deal on the grounds that it could reduce competition and lead to higher prices for consumers. It concluded, however, that the deal could go ahead with conditions. These include [...]

  • Harlots

    ITV Takes Majority Stake in ‘Harlots’ Producer Monumental Television

    ITV Studios now has a controlling stake in Monumental Television, the production company that makes Hulu series “Harlots” and that was founded by Oscar-nominated film producers Alison Owen and Debra Hayward. ITV first bought into the company in 2015 and has upped its stake from 26% to 51%. Julian Bellamy, managing director of ITV Studios, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content