You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Super Bowl Ad Review: Shock Top’s Web Trailer May Not Electrify TV Screen

T.J. Miller has an interesting conversation with the top of a beer tap in a funny Super Bowl ad for a brew called Shock Top. Will he have the right conversation with the suds-guzzling crowd watching the game?

The people who make Shock Top would have you believe that it’s an upstart Belgian White, lovingly brewed in some entrepreneur’s tiny office based on a recipe treasured in his or her family throughout the ages. Yet the drink is actually a move by giant Anheuser Busch InBev to succeed in the growing category of craft beers. By devoting some of its massive ad buy – three minutes and 30 seconds – to Shock Top in Super Bowl 50, the beer company hopes to get the masses revved up about what they might think is a insouciant little brew that has nothing to do with Budweiser or Bud Light.

You want Miller to succeed. He plays the buddy no one wants along for the ride in HBO’s arch tech-industry chronicle “Silicon Valley.” He has the kind of slacker sociability that would seem to appeal to the young  (but not too young!) viewers Anheuser wants to quaff its potables on a regular basis.

In the ad, the actor sits down at a bar and is instantly handed a Shock Top (would that all bartenders paid such attention to their customers).  Before he can even take a sip of the brew  – and is this the drink he really wanted? – he is accosted by an anthropomorphic Shock Top icon, a talking orange slice “Wedgehead” with sunglasses who wants to play the dozens, as it were, with the affable fellow.

The red-headed bearded Miller is informed he looks like “an unemployed Civil War general,” appears as if he was “about to get evicted from your parents’ basement,” and resembles “a toddler who took growth serum.” Miller has good retorts. He asks the little fellow if he considers fresh-squeezed orange juice murder. All of this is presented in an “extended trailer” put up on YouTube and other digital venues that makes it easy to watch and listen, and then watch and listen again.

It’s an engaging conversation, but will anyone be willing to eavesdrop on it come Super Bowl Sunday? These sorts of back-and-forth ruminations are great for venues where consumers can come upon them and watch multiple times at their leisure to hear all the nuances and to-and-fro, or get distracted by other elements of the video (is anyone else distracted by the sound Miller’s glass makes on the bar each time he puts it down?).

But a Super Bowl ad has to do more than work well in previews. It has to stand up under the scrutiny of viewers who will likely have had more than one or two Shock Tops – or, Heaven fore-end, some other beer! – and won’t have the ability to study the commercial as much as they would have online. And let’s be honest, the American consumer is busy. Do we think that everyone who watches next week’s Super Bowl is going to have studied the ads as if they were required reading or some kind of homework assignment?

There is some reason to be optimistic. Samsung ran a massive two-minute long commercial in Super Bowl XLVII featuring Seth Rogen and Paul Rudd reprising some of the insult-tossing conversations they had in the 2007 film “Knocked Up.”  By buying up 120 seconds of ad time, however, the electronics manufacturer had some assurance its commercial would dominate its assigned ad break and capture more attention.

Shock Top won’t have that luxury, and why should it? Yes, American consumers are drinking less beer and hard liquor, according to data from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, but when they do, more of them drink Bud and Bud Light than they do Shock Top. And that’s the way it will likely stay.  So those are the brands that will get more of the spotlight on February 7.

Anheuser will have to cut its Shock Top palaver down to 30 seconds for Game Day, and is likely banking that consumers will spend more time with its extended promotion than they will while eating wings, guacamole and being dazzled by more than 70 different pitches from national and local sponsors of the game. This is, for all intents and purposes, a Web ad – and a very funny one. But Super Bowl ads work best on TV.

Grade: B –

Popular on Variety

More TV

  • Game of Thrones Emmys

    Yes, 'Game of Thrones' Deserved to Win Outstanding Drama Emmy (Column)

    Your mileage may vary, as they say, but let’s stipulate that the final season of “Game of Thrones” was a huge disappointment to many viewers, who loudly expressed their displeasure on the internet about what a damn mess it was. And yes, many shows in the Emmys’ outstanding drama category this year were better television. [...]

  • Emmys Snubs and Surprises 2019

    Emmys: The Biggest Snubs and Surprises

    Although HBO juggernaut series “Game of Thrones” and “Veep” both came to an end this year and therefore were seeing their final chances to be celebrated at the Emmys, the voting members of the Television Academy did not just tick all of the boxes for those two behemoths and call it a night. In fact, [...]

  • Orange Is the New Black

    Emmys: 'Orange is the New Black,' 'Crazy Ex-Girlfriend' Left Off Farewell Segment

    Fox decided to set aside some time at this year’s Emmys to say farewell to some of the biggest shows which have left the small screen in recent months. However, while the brief segment highlighted landmark shows such as “The Big Bang Theory,” it was also marked by some notable omissions. The segment only lasted [...]

  • Jharrel Jerome accepts the award for

    'When They See Us' Star Jharrel Jerome: 'Our Strongest Stories Are the Stories of Pain'

    “When They See Us” star and newly-minted Emmy winner Jharrel Jerome was posed a tough question backstage after his win. A reporter asked Jerome why it seems that people of color seem to only win major awards for stories that detail their trials and tribulations. “Unfortunately I think our strongest stories are the stories of [...]

  • Phoebe Waller-Bridge - Outstanding Comedy Series

    'Fleabag' Nearly Sweeps 2019 Comedy Emmys With Surprise Best Series Win

    Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s critically-acclaimed auteur comedy “Fleabag” had only one chance to clean up at the Emmys, and while it didn’t fully sweep comedy categories, it came damn near close. The Amazon Prime Video half-hour took the coveted comedy series category, as well as lead comedy actress (for Waller-Bridge), comedy writing (also for Waller-Bridge) and comedy [...]

  • D. B. Weiss and the team

    'Game of Thrones' Wins Drama Series Emmy for Final Season

    Though a vocal set of fans weren’t happy with the final season of “Game of Thrones,” the Television Academy was. “Game of Thrones” once again won the drama series Emmy on Sunday night for its eighth season. This is its fourth win in the category overall and second consecutive one (it also took the trophy [...]

  • Billy Porter Emmy Win 2019 Pose

    Billy Porter Makes History With Emmys Win

    Billy Porter won the 2019 lead drama actor Emmy for his role of ballroom MC and mentor Pray Tell on FX’s “Pose.”  This historic win makes Porter the first openly gay, black man to win in this Emmy category. This is the Tony Award winner’s first-ever Emmy accolade, and he took the stage celebrating his [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content