Judge Rejects ‘New Girl’ Idea Theft Case

A federal judge has rejected claims that the Fox series “New Girl” was lifted from a screenplay called “Square One.”

U.S. District Judge Stephen Wilson granted summary judgment to creator Elizabeth Meriwether, Fox, WME Entertainment, Peter Chernin and other defendants. He concluded that the plaintiffs, Stephanie Counts and Shari Gold, had provided insufficient evidence to show that Meriwether or Chernin had access to their script “Square One.” Even if they had, he wrote, they also failed to show that there was “substantial similarity” between the two works, a prerequisite before such idea theft cases can move forward.

The two writers claimed that they wrote a TV script based on Counts’ personal experiences when she learned that her husband was cheating on her and moved into a three-man bachelor pad. They later wrote a feature-length screenplay and submitted it to agents, production companies and talent.

A central feature of their case was that they submitted “Square One” to Adam Venit and later David Karp, both agents at WME, which also represented the principals behind “New Girl.” The agency’s Cori Wellins represented Meriwether and Rick Rosen represented Chernin.

But Wilson wrote that the two writers “have only provided additional theories of access, rather than a qualitatively stronger theory of access than that of bare corporate receipt.” He noted that Venit and Karp did not represent any clients involved in “New Girl.” Although WME gave “Square One” favorable coverage, accessible through an agency database, Wilson wrote that such a fact still fell short of establishing that Wellins or Rosen accessed it.

All of the defendants except WME were represented by a legal team led by Jonathan Zavin of Loeb & Loeb. Counts and Gold were repped by Francis Malofiy of Francis Alexander. WME was represented by Michael J. Kump of Kinsella Weitzman Iser Kump and Aldisert.

More TV

  • Maya Hawke'Once Upon a Time in

    Maya Hawke Reflects on Robin's 'Stranger Things' Coming Out Story

    Robin Buckley shocked viewers everywhere when she came out as a lesbian to Steve Harrington on the floor of a bathroom stall, but actress Maya Hawke says the twist wasn’t always set in stone. Hawke tells Variety that it wasn’t until episode four or five that she and the Duffer Brothers came to a final decision [...]

  • Love Island - Pictured: Kyra Green,

    TV Ratings: Is 'Love Island' Deserted?

    Two weeks have passed on “Love Island” and plenty of singles have coupled and uncoupled in their bid for love and a fat $100,000 pay check. However, there’s one couple that doesn’t seem to be hitting it off: CBS and “Love Island.” Ratings for the show have been far from paradisiacal, and with the network [...]

  • Jenny Wall Eryk Casemiro Nickelodeon

    Jenny Wall Named Nickelodeon CMO, Eryk Casemiro Named Senior VP of Nickelodeon Preschool

    Nickelodeon has hired two new executives, tapping Jenny Wall to become chief marketing officer and Eryk Casemiro to become senior vice president of Nickelodeon Preschool. Most recently CMO at Spotify-owned Gimlet Media, Wall will be responsible for all on- and off-air consumer marketing, brand creative and content launches across all of Nickelodeon’s platforms, including Nicktoons, [...]

  • Liz Garbus on Why We May

    Liz Garbus on Why The World May Never Know 'Who Killed Garrett Phillips'

    By the time Liz Garbus’s two-part documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” debuts on HBO, there could be a new public lead in the case of the murdered titular 12-year-old. As least, that’s what many may hope after the new St. Lawrence County district attorney admitted a new tip earlier this spring. Garbus says she would [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content