TV Review: ABC’s ‘Notorious’ and ‘Conviction’

Two new ABC procedurals follow very similar templates to very different levels of quality

It’s remarkable how interchangeable “Notorious” and “Conviction” are. Hayley Atwell is in one, and Piper Perabo leads the other, but you’d be forgiven for confusing the lesser details, like which one is a take on Larry King or has a presidential campaign subplot. Both are steamy procedurals that combine legal thriller with media circus, playing up high-profile clients, sensational crimes, and the sexy people involved. Both are led by beautiful white women, making the most of their business formal wardrobes in expensive high heels and blazers. Both women have smoldering sexual tension with a man — the second-billed actor — that crosses both personal and professional boundaries, while also throwing off sexual tension that tries very hard to light the screen on fire (and occasionally succeeds).

And, most importantly, both read as messy, incomplete dramas that appear to be blatant attempts to rework the “Scandal” template with a few different bells and whistles. The similarity of the two shows suggests that ABC is looking for a new, buzzy female-driven hit to add to its repertoire, and hopes that tossing out two baited hooks to the viewers is better than one. But because both shows feel incomplete — either because they are lacking key connective tissue or because they are stuffed with too much connective tissue — it’s hard to imagine audiences taking the bait for either.

Of the two, it’s “Conviction” that is the stronger pilot. Primarily this is because of the force of character that Atwell, an actress with talent well beyond what’s required of her here, brings to the role of Hayes Morrison, a former president’s daughter who might become one again, as now her mother is running for president. Hayes has a problem with drugs and a problem, too, with staying out of trouble, so in the pilot she’s shoehorned by her mother into the thankless job of heading up a conviction review team under the Manhattan District Attorney, played by Eddie Cahill. But Hayes finds a certain amount of self-respect in the process of trying to exonerate the wrongly convicted, and surrounded by a team with varying degrees of respect for her, falls into the accepted format for a case-of-the-week procedural. “Conviction’s” problem is that it wants Hayes to be all things — moral center, bad girl, political pawn, power attorney, femme fatale. Atwell is skilled, but with just 42 minutes and a whole murder case to get through, her First Daughter backstory and the wide net cast for her character feel a lot like grasping at distant, barely visible straws.

Still, “Conviction” is a fun watch, and a series that will likely resolve its initial hiccups. “Notorious,” on the other hand, is a nearly wall-to-wall mess. Perabo is the producer for a news show that, we’re informed, is a big deal; and for some reason, that means that she has a strong relationship with a charismatic defense attorney played by Daniel Sunjata. Naturally, the two alternate between helping and manipulating each other, but so confusingly — and so listlessly — that it’s hard to get invested in the outcome. “Notorious” is based on the behind-the-scenes relationship between “Larry King Live” producer Wendy Walker and high-profile defense attorney Mark Geragos, who has defended celebrities like Michael Jackson, Winona Ryder, Chris Brown, and Scott Peterson.

But the “Notorious” pilot fails to sell its version of “Larry King Live” — “Louise Herrick Live,” anchored by Kate Jennings Grant’s character — as culturally significant or particularly well-regarded. Similarly, Sunjata’s Jake does not get the appropriate treatment to transform him into a smarmy, savvy lawyer to the stars. As a result, every convoluted plot twist of the pilot feels like an unnecessary embellishment on top of an already nonsensical premise — because the show also fails to explain why this producer and this lawyer being friends with each other is unusual or interesting. And while “Conviction” at least draws together a cheerful ensemble who are already halfway settled into their series-long personae, very few characters in “Notorious” fail to make an impression. Jennings Grant stands out as a scene-stealing diva in the midst of a pilot desperately throwing everything it has at the screen.

It’s interesting that ABC is so keen to sell a show in this mold that it’s offered viewers two choices of varying quality. Watching both back-to-back is to observe several types of press conferences, interrogations, alleged murderers, and sexy encounters with coworkers — when those same coworkers aren’t trying to sell each other out. It’s a specific fantasy of work, romance, and crime; a specific meditation on celebrity, scandal, and the media’s relationship to both. Above all, it’s interesting just how much of both shows takes place on screens watching screens; just as in “Notorious,” Perabo’s character Julia watches her own show and other broadcasts, in “Conviction” Atwell’s Hayes watches the coverage of her own public appearances and press conferences with a jaundiced eye. The sexiness of both shows isn’t just the actors getting action; it’s the attention paid to watching, the scrutiny of scrutiny. And, of course, the peppy pop music accompanying each montage.

TV Review: ‘Notorious’
Drama, pilot reviewed: ABC, Thurs. Sept. 22, 9 p.m. 60 min.
Crew: Executive producers, Josh Berman, Jeff Kwatinetz, Josh Barry, Kenny Meiselas, Mark Geragos, Wendy Walker, Jennifer Cecil, Mike Listo.
Cast: Piper Perabo, Daniel Sunjata, Kate Jennings Grant, Aimeé Teegarden, J. August Richards, Sepideh Moafi, Ryan Guzman, Kevin Zegers

TV Review: ‘Conviction’
Drama, pilot reviewed: ABC, Mon. Oct. 3, 10 p.m. 60 min.
Crew: Executive producers, Mark Gordon, Liz Friedman, Liz Friedlander, Nicholas Pepper
Cast: Hayley Atwell, Eddie Cahill, Shawn Ashmore, Merrin Dungey, Emily Kinney, Manny Montana, Daniel Franzese

Popular on Variety

TV Review: ABC's 'Notorious' and 'Conviction'

More TV

  • TV News Roundup: 'Silicon Valley' Final

    TV News Roundup: 'Silicon Valley's' Final Season Sets October Premiere Date

    In today’s roundup, “Silicon Valley” returns to HBO on Oct. 27 and Quibi greenlights a new cooking competition show “Dismantled.” DATES The fifth season of Netflix‘s “Peaky Blinders” will premiere on the streamer Oct. 4. The newest season will continue to follow one gangster family in the lawless streets of Birmingham, UK during the midst [...]

  • Peter Fonda Dead: 'Easy Rider' Star

    Peter Fonda, Star of 'Easy Rider,' Dies at 79

    Two-time Oscar nominee Peter Fonda, who became a counterculture icon when he co-wrote, produced and starred in seminal 1969 road movie “Easy Rider,” then showed Hollywood he could act about three decades later in “Ulee’s Gold,” died on Friday from lung cancer at his home in Los Angeles. He was 79. His sister Jane Fonda [...]

  • CineLink Drama Brings High-End Series to

    CineLink Drama Brings High-End Series to Sarajevo

    When the organizers of the Sarajevo Film Festival’s CineLink Industry Days surveyed the local TV landscape several years ago, they recognized the chance to make an impact. “We decided five years ago that we need to do something,” says CineLink industry coordinator Armin Hadzic. “The [regional] TV and public broadcasters were coming from another age.” [...]

  • SCHOOLED - ABC's "Schooled" stars Bryan

    'Kids Are Alright' Creator Joins 'Schooled' Season 2 as Showrunner

    Tim Doyle is taking over as showrunner and executive producer on the upcoming second season of “Schooled” at ABC, Variety has confirmed. Doyle takes over from Season 1 showrunner and series co-creator Marc Firek, who has exited the series to focus on development. The news comes just months after Doyle’s 1970s-set comedy series, “The Kids [...]

  • Matthew Miller'Lethal Weapon' TV series screening,

    'Lethal Weapon' Team Lands Put Pilot Order at Fox for Cop Drama 'Dead Eddie' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Matt Miller and Alex Taub are staying in business with Fox. The pair, who previously worked together on Fox’s series adaptation of “Lethal Weapon,” have scored a put pilot commitment at the broadcaster for a new drama project, Variety has learned exclusively. The drama is titled “Dead Eddie.” In the series, after a near-death experience, misanthropic [...]

  • Krypton Syfy

    'Krypton' Canceled After Two Seasons at Syfy, Network Not Moving Forward on 'Lobo' Spinoff

    “Krypton” has been canceled after two seasons at Syfy. In addition, the NBCUniversal cabler is not moving ahead with a planned “Lobo” spinoff. “Krypton,” set two generations before the destruction of Superman’s titular home planet, follows Superman’s grandfather Seg-El (Cameron Cuffe) as a young man faced with saving his home planet or letting it be [...]

  • Alexis Martin Woodall

    Alexis Martin Woodall Named President of Ryan Murphy Productions

    Longtime producer Alexis Martin Woodall has been tapped to become the president of Ryan Murphy Productions, giving her oversight of the Netflix-based company. As president, Woodall will manage Murphy’s company, continuing to be hands on in executive producing its TV productions and producing its films. “Alexis is brazen, sharp and incisive — qualities that have [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content