×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

How TV Tuned in More Upfront Ad Dollars: Soap, Toothpaste and Pushy Tactics

Madison Avenue is flirting with TV more seriously than it has in years, but behind the winks and kisses are signs of a relationship that continues to fray.

The nation’s five big English-language broadcast networks secured between $8.41 billion and $9.25 billion in advance ad commitments for primetime as part of the annual “upfront” market, according to Variety estimates. It’s the first time in three years they’ve managed to break the $9 billion mark. The upfront finish is a clear signal that Madison Avenue is putting more faith in TV even as digital-video options abound. Last year, the volume of advance ad commitments totaled between $8.02 billion and $8.69 billion, a noticeable decline from the previous year.

2010: $8.1B to $8.7B

2011: $8.8B to $9.3B

2012: $8.8B to $9.3B

2013: $8.6B to $9.2B

2014: $8.17B to $8.94B

2015: $8.02B to $8.69B

2016: $8.41B to $9.25B

Source: Variety estimates

Beneath the impressive hikes and the happy talks they will likely spur with investors, however, is a new wrinkle in these annual talks between U.S. TV networks and the advertisers who support them. The networks demonstrated a new aggressive streak, according to several ad buyers familiar with the 2016 haggling, pressing back against previously established deals that guaranteed lower rate increases and favoring sponsors who would do more business at higher rates.

“We turned away a lot of volume. We’re working on mix on the cable side to try to get higher, more profitable advertising into our mix in some of our cable channels,” said Steve Burke, chief executive of Comcast’s NBCUniversal Wednesday during a conference call with investors. “But there was plenty of volume. And we could have sold more if we wanted to.” Other networks may have suggested that clients who didn’t want to pay the bigger increases wait until the “scatter” market, when ad time is sold closer to air date – and is usually more expensive.

In the modern era of TV, so beset by competition from new streaming-video rivals, some ad dollars are better than others. During upfront haggling in 2016, executives at the nation’s big broadcast TV networks placed new pressure on agreements that guarantee sponsors low or moderate rate hikes over a multi-year period. In some cases, the networks threatened to do more business with a marketer in a particular category that would favor the highest rate hikes, leaving rivals scrambling. Imagine, for a moment, what sponsors like Verizon or AT&T might do if they were told T-Mobile could have more and better inventory because it had agreed to rates that favored the network. Or consider how a marketer like Procter & Gamble might react upon being informed a multi-year deal it signed in the past promising low rate increases would continue to be honored, but that others who were willing to pay what the market might bear would have better access to ad time. Those are aggressive maneuvers, to be sure.

At a time when TV advertising is under duress, however, the gloves have to come off. “I’m a little bit surprised, frankly, that they didn’t do this two or three years ago,” said one buying executive. “The networks were really optimizing bad money out this year.”

There are reasons to be bold. Ad dollars devoted to mobile advertising are expected to be greater than those allocated to TV around the world by 2018, according to a June report from Publicis Groupe ad buyer ZenithOptimedia. “Mobile advertising is growing at a blistering pace: it grew 95% in 2015, and we forecast 46% growth for 2016, followed by 29% growth in both 2017 and 2018,” the report said. “Mobile is already the primary means of accessing the internet.”

With TV’s video viewership migrating to other screens, the networks can’t just parcel out 30-second ad berths and TV-show product placement willy-nilly. They have to squeeze the most out of each commercial slot.

This was the year to tighten the clutch. As much as viewers have embraced mobile tablets and on-demand streaming, there is a growing sense that high-quality programming helps commercials stand out best. Executives on both sides of the table reported that some of the nation’s big consumer packaged goods giants were taking ad money away from content created by new digital players in favor of stuff from the networks in which they have more faith. Pharmaceutical manufacturers and consumer-electronics makers were also big spenders in this year’s market, these buyers said.

Some of the proof came in the haggle. The networks were able to press for the broadest rate increases they’ve seen in years. NBC sought a whopping 12.5% hike in the cost of reaching 1,000 viewers, a measure also known as a CPM that is central to these annual discussions for commercial time. Last year, NBC was able to command rate hikes of just 5%.

CBS pressed for CPM hikes in the 9% to 11% range, compared with increases of just 3% to 5% in 2015. ABC and Fox each pushed for CPM raises of between 8.5% to 10%. In 2015, ABC worked for increases of 45 to 5% and Fox had to offer rollbacks of as much as 2%. The CW this year pressed for rate hikes of between 12% and 14%, compared with just 4% in 2015.

The numbers can be deceiving. TV audiences continue to dwindle, meaning the networks have fewer ratings points to sell. With demand increasing due to a move of money back from digital, the economics are simple: Rates go up. One major ad-buying shop, WPP’s GroupM, pushed against the hikes, particularly with NBCUniversal and Turner, delaying the close of the upfront.

Ultimately, TV won more money than it has in some time. NBC is believed to have secured around $2.53 billion in advance commitments, compared with about $2.3 billion in 2015. CBS is seen securing between $2.26 billion and $2.6 billion for its primetime schedule, according to Variety estimates, compared with between $2.19 billion and $.248 billion last year.

ABC, meanwhile, is expected to secure between$1.7 billion and $1.96 billion, compared with $1.67 billion to $1.88 billion last year. Fox secured $1.47 billion and $1.64 billion, according to Variety estimates, compared with$1.43 billion and $1.56 billion in 2015. The CW is seen securing between $476.6 million and $523.2 million, compared with between $425.6 million and $458.9 million last year.

The numbers represent commitments, not cold, hard cash. Advertisers can yank a portion of their dollars for a variety of reasons, including cancelled programs or a desire to claw back money for business operations. What the flow of money this year says is that Madison Avenue is relying more heavily on TV this year, even as a wealth of new video options proliferate.

Even with this year’s boost, the relationship between sponsors and TV isn’t as strong as it once was. In 2004, six broadcast TV networks – remember UPN and the WB? – lined up around $9.5 billion in advance ad commitments, and it remains to be seen if, in a world filled with new video rivals, whether that figure will be regained in years to come. TV and Madison Avenue have tightened their embrace, but the marketers’ eyes are wandering. TV needs to keep working to make sure its screen stays in focus.

 

 

More TV

  • Netflix to Amend ‘The Devil Next

    Netflix to Amend 'The Devil Next Door' Documentary After Backlash (EXCLUSIVE)

    Netflix will amend elements of its documentary series “The Devil Next Door” after the Polish prime minister and others complained to CEO Reed Hastings about the show, which centers on the trial of John Demjanjuk who was accused of being a notorious Ukrainian concentration camp guard known as Ivan the Terrible. Polish premier Mateusz Morawiecki [...]

  • Stephen Colbert's 'Late Show' Sets New

    Stephen Colbert's 'Late Show' Sets New Head Writer Team

    Stephen Colbert has expanded the circle of people helping to make the ultimate decision about what the funniest things are for him to say each night on CBS’ “Late Show.” Three writers/producers who have been with Colbert for years will get new duties at his late-night program. Ariel Dumas, a longtime writer for Colbert, has [...]

  • Kacey Musgraves poses in the press

    CMA Awards: What Kacey, Maren, Garth, Blake and Dan + Shay Had to Say Backstage

    Backstage at Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena, CMA Awards winners, performers and presenters came back to meet the press after their appearances, including Kacey Musgraves, Maren Morris, Garth Brooks, Blake Shelton, Dan + Shay, Ashley McBryde and Luke Combs. Garth Brooks was named entertainer of the year for the seventh time, and during his acceptance speech, he [...]

  • Killing Eve Sandra Oh Jodie Comer

    SAG Awards: How High-Profile TV Ensembles Increase Individual Performer Category Competition

    While this year’s Primetime Emmy Awards saw categories dominated by multiple performers from the same show (think “Game of Thrones,” which had at least one player represented in each major drama acting category, as well as “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” and “Fleabag,” whose on-screen talent nabbed spots in almost all the comedy categories), that trend [...]

  • BROOKLYN NINE-NINE -- "Honeymoon" Episode 601

    ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’ Renewed for Season 8 at NBC

    NBC has handed an early renewal to “Brooklyn Nine-Nine.” Season 7 of the cop comedy isn’t set to premiere until Feb. 6 2020, but the network has already seen fit to order an eighth season.  During season 6 (its first on NBC after being canceled by Fox in 2018), “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” averaged a 1.2 rating [...]

  • Ted Sarandos - Netflix

    Ted Sarandos Says Disney Plus Launch Changes 'Nothing' for Netflix

    Netflix chief content officer Ted Sarandos claims he’s not getting distracted by huge competitors — like Disney — rumbling into the company’s streaming turf. The exec was asked what has changed for Netflix with the Nov. 12 launch of Disney Plus, which the Mouse House boasted as having signed up over 10 million users so [...]

  • Kristen Stewart Actors on Actors

    Kristen Stewart Reveals She Loves 'Naked and Afraid': 'That Is High-End Reality TV'

    Kristen Stewart (“Seberg”) loves “Naked and Afraid” and wondering what shoes smell like. Stewart discussed her tastes in reality TV and interest in Shia LaBeouf’s (“Honey Boy”) shoes during a conversation for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” LaBeouf began the interview by asking Stewart what she likes to watch in her free time. LaBeouf mentioned [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content