You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Review: ‘The Walking Dead’ Season Finale Finally Brings Negan Up to Bat (SPOILERS)

The character of Negan finally made his long-awaited appearance in “The Walking Dead’s” season finale. In a sense, though, anticipation for his arrival shanghaied this entire flight of episodes, casting one of the longer TV shadows in recent memory. That resulted in a year with some impressive highs – see the moral conundrum of cold-bloodedly murdering members of a rival group – and abundant lows, including the cliffhanging finish.

As the Los Angeles Times’ Mary McNamara astutely observed prior to the finale, the show’s writers have at times sold out their characters, indulging in “Scandal”-like “OMG” moments. Perhaps foremost, the program has engaged in stunts intended to tease out plot threads that a show this popular, frankly, needn’t (and shouldn’t) employ.

There were multiple examples of that this season, from the too-cute spin that surrounded the uncertainty over whether the character of Glenn (Steven Yeun) was dead to the finish of the penultimate episode, where a bullet and a spray of blood provided a big twist to an otherwise so-so hour. And damned if the producers didn’t do that again in the finale (and SPOILER ALERT if you haven’t watched), by opting not to disclose who was on the other end of Negan’s bloodthirsty bat.

Thanks for your patronage, gang. Good luck guessing who’s dead. Have a good summer, we’ll see you around Halloween!

That’s a shame, since the extended 93-minute episode was at times a minor masterpiece of tension and almost unbearable intensity, as Negan’s minions made clear just how overmatched the regulars were, in a prolonged show of force that demonstrated their ruthlessness. Special kudos should go not only to director Greg Nicotero but composer Bear McCreary, whose score ratcheted up those emotions at every turn.

Moreover, Jeffrey Dean Morgan (looking a whole lot less cuddly than he does on “The Good Wife”) was a perfect choice for the key role of Negan, bringing a mischievous smile to his utter brutality. Whatever bad taste the finale might leave in a lot of mouths, the opportunity to see Morgan unleashed in this fashion is a tantalizing prospect for the coming season.

That said, it will take a while to gargle out that cliffhanger. “The end of the story is what people saw,” showrunner Scott M. Gimple stated on “Talking Dead,” the program’s fawning after-show, engaging in more of the irritating double-talk that he delivered in the midst of the “Is Glenn dead?” mania.

In a sense, this storyline has been somewhat complicated by the current strength of its cast, which made the build-up to Negan’s debut – and the anticipation that he would announce his presence by killing somebody very, very significant – all the more frenzied. (Glenn was his victim in the comics, but seriously, that dude’s suffered enough.)

As noted, the frustrations associated with the show’s narrative tactics shouldn’t obscure what it does so well. That ranges from small moments – like those in the finale involving Melissa McBride and Lennie James – to how it has explored matters of morality amid a lawless, kill-or-be-killed world. As this season has made clear time and again, the characters have come an awfully long way from the statement by Rick (Andrew Lincoln) early on that “We don’t kill the living.”

Even so, fans shouldn’t relish having their chains yanked, and it’s not like people wouldn’t tune in for next season’s premiere if they already knew who had gotten his or her skull bashed in. Success, of course, tends to paper over a multitude of ills, and outlets that cover the series (including this one) would rather gripe about its perceived shortcomings than dare sacrifice any of the traffic or ratings that flow from hanging on its every beat. Indeed, the number of movie ads in the finale – most aimed at an elusive young-male demographic – offered an awesome display of the show’s commercial power, as if one is required.

Still, to borrow one more baseball metaphor, with such a murderers’ row of aces in its bullpen, “The Walking Dead” shouldn’t have to resort to throwing the creative equivalent of junk pitches. And that’s why despite its highlights, the finale simply drove home the sense that while this season wasn’t a complete swing and a miss, those in charge continue to make aggravating unforced errors.

More TV

  • Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

    COLA Announces California On-Location Awards Winners

    “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” “Dolemite is My Name,” and HBO’s “Ballers” are among the winners of this year’s COLA awards. The COLAs recognize location managers, public employees and other professionals who help facilitate on-location production across the Golden State. This year’s awards program was held at the Universal Hilton. Finalists and winners are [...]

  • Christmas Town Hallmark

    Hallmark Reverses Decision to Ban Same-Sex Marriage Commercial

    The owner of TV’s Hallmark Channel on Sunday reversed a decision to ban a commercial depicting a same-sex wedding, suggesting that it was not in keeping with the company’s well-known slogan, “When you care enough to send the very best.” Earlier this week, Hallmark Channel decided to reject an ad from online-weddings firm Zola which [...]

  • Chuy Bravo seen at Focus Features

    Chuy Bravo, 'Chelsea Lately' Sidekick, Dies at 63

    Chuy Bravo, Chelsea Handler’s sidekick on her E! talk show “Chelsea Lately,” has died in Mexico City. He was 63. According to reports, the Mexican American actor died suddenly after being hospitalized with stomach pains while visiting family in Mexico. Handler posted a tribute to Bravo on Instagram shortly after reports of his death began [...]

  • SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE -- "Scarlett Johansson"

    'Saturday Night Live' Parodies 'A Marriage Story' with Kellyanne Conway (Watch)

    Scarlett Johansson may be nominated for a Golden Globe for her performance in “A Marriage Story,” but when she hosted the Dec. 14 episode of “Saturday Night Live,” she slid into a less flashy role for that sketch comedy’s parody of the new dramatic film. Johansson took on the role of therapist to Kate McKinnon’s [...]

  • SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE -- "Scarlett Johansson"

    'Saturday Night Live': Kate McKinnon's Greta Thunberg Tells Trump to 'Grow Up' (Watch)

    With the December holidays upon us, “Saturday Night Live” took a brief detour from its usual parodies of political press conferences and the impeachment hearings to instead begin its Dec. 14 episode with a sketch about average families discussing the state of the world over dinner — with a special message from Greta Thunberg (as [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content