You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Emmy Awards Should Expand to 10 Nominees in Peak TV Era

How many is too many?

When it comes to the Emmy Awards, it’s hard to find consensus on any subject — but one thing is clear, there are never enough to go around.

But the very idea of adding awards is fraught. You’ll be hard-pressed to find anyone who thinks the show itself should be longer. Host Jimmy Kimmel and producer Don Mischer will have their work cut out for them trying to wrangle the Primetime Emmys in at under the three-hour mark. Things already have gotten so bad over at its cousin, the Creative Arts Emmys, that the show has had to be split into two parts.

There is some good news about this year’s Emmys: With many of last year’s nominees and winners having retired to the TV hall of fame (RIP, “Mad Men,” “Parks and Rec,” “Nurse Jackie”), there’s certainly ample opportunity for new entries to break in.

But now the bad news: It’s an ever-more crowded field, with way too many worthy nominees vying for those precious few slots. With 400-plus series on the air (and TV production showing no signs of slowing), odds are, the majority are going to get slighted.

I’m going to make a (not so) bold Emmy prediction right now: Come nomination day, there’s going to be widespread disappointment. There will be a flood of “snubs” stories (including our own). I might as well start writing it now.

Last year, the TV Academy expanded the number of nominees in comedy and drama series from six to seven, but that was merely a ripple in the pond. (Make that the ocean.) And the new definition of half-hours and hours, while reining in the category-jockeying madness, still frustrates the creative community. “The Academy made everything worse,” gripes one producer. “You’re completely ignoring the actual content of the show. If that’s the case, then change the name of the category to best half hour show and best hour show. It’s just silly.”

Execs complain that defining shows by length does little to level the playing field between broadcast and cable/streaming, a nagging sore spot for the kudosfest. Comedies that run on broadcast are limited to 21 minutes, while their cable and streaming counterparts can stretch to 35 minutes and more, and have far more creative freedom in terms of language and subject matter. Every year, broadcast series are virtually shut out from major wins while they foot the bill for the show itself.

And this year’s big rules change (along with splitting the Creative Arts Emmys into two shows) was the expansion of the short-form categories, bringing digital series into the fold. All due respect to those YouTube rock stars, but their inclusion does little to address the impending major snubs.

So what to do? An informal survey of industry insiders found that the current categories do indeed go a long way to recognizing the best of TV. “Awards shows are always too long, even for those who love them,” says one insider. “But there need to be either more categories or more shows in existing categories to acknowledge the explosion in content.”

A smart, single new category — say, best new show or best ensemble — could go a long way to bringing more nominees into the Emmy tent. Cracks one wag, “It would be interesting to see if the Emmy voters could do a better job recognizing the best ensembles than SAG voters.”

Another proposal: split the drama and comedy categories by number of episodes — best drama, 12 episodes and under; best drama, 13 and over. The argument: Is it fair to compare a series that runs 12 episodes to one that runs 24? Yes, it’s an obvious pander to the broadcast nets, but supporters have a point. It’s like comparing a short story to a novel. The last broadcast series to earn a nomination for best drama was “The Good Wife,” back in 2011.

The most popular solution by far: Steal a page from the Oscar playbook and expand each of the series categories to 10 nominees. The hope would be — as it was for the Academy Awards — that this would allow more popular series to sneak in.

And there would be another benefit: a ratings boost to the show itself: Last year’s outing hit a record low.

“It’s a win-win,” says an insider. “Most people did not watch the shows that won last year. If they added more nominees, they’d be getting shows that at least a few million people have seen.”

More TV

  • Series Mania Unveils 2019 Festival, with

    Series Mania Unveils 2019 Festival Lineup

    PARIS — Graced by Uma Thurman, “The Good Doctor” star Freddie Highmore and “Black Mirror” creators-showrunners Charlie Brooker and Anabel Jones, the 10th Series Mania – and second in Lille, north-east France – will kick off March 22 with Netflix prominent, a broader   geographical reach and a strong presence of women writers and directors. [...]

  • Riz Ahmed CAA headshot

    Riz Ahmed Gears Up for ‘Englistan’ Series and ‘Hamlet,’ Talks U.S. and U.K. TV Biz

    Having worked on both sides of the pond, “The Night Of” star Riz Ahmed thinks the U.S. TV biz could learn from the Brits’ “unpretentious” attitude toward the creative process and the U.K. industry could emulate the Americans’ openness to “new voices.” “The British approach to creativity can be really helpfully unpretentious….That sets us apart [...]

  • Black Panther

    'Black Panther,' 'Crazy Rich Asians,' 'Westworld' Among Costume Designers Guild Winners

    “Crazy Rich Asians,” “The Favourite” and “Black Panther” walked away with top honors at the 21st annual Costume Designers Guild Awards Tuesday night, the final industry guild show before the Oscars on Feb. 24. “The Favourite” and “Black Panther” are up for the Oscar this year, along with “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs,” “Mary Poppins [...]

  • Syfy Cancels 'Nightflyers' After One Season

    Syfy Cancels 'Nightflyers' After One Season

    The George R.R. Martin drama “Nightflyers” has been canceled by Syfy after only one season. Based on the novella from the mastermind behind “Game of Thrones,” the show was seen as a big gamble for the NBCUniversal-owned cable network, as it represented the most expensive series it had ever developed. The network attempted to spark [...]

  • Batwoman Arrow

    The CW's 'Batwoman' Pilot Switches Directors, Adds Dougray Scott

    The CW has added veteran Scottish actor Dougray Scott to its “Batwoman” pilot as well as swapped in Marcos Siega for previous director David Nutter, Variety has learned. The pilot, which stars Ruby Rose as the eponymous caped heroine, is being helmed by DC TV head Greg Berlanti, and was penned by “Vampire Diaries” alum [...]

  • OG Review

    Review: 'O.G.' on HBO

    Jeffrey Wright, the most compelling reason to watch HBO’s new film “O.G.,” is among television’s best actors at switching between codes or manners of being. On “Westworld,” his timeline-toggling android swaps personae so delicately that his performance gains in resonance when recalled in retrospect. (Perhaps that’s why Wright has been so oddly underrated through the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content