You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar Music Contenders: Will Scores From Spring and Summer Be Left in the Cold?

Why is it that so few scores from movies released early in the year seem to be noticed at awards time?

Over the past decade, only six of 50 original-score Oscar nominees – 12% – were for movies released prior to July 1. The one notable recent exception, Alexandre Desplat’s “The Grand Budapest Hotel,” which won the 2014 score Oscar, was released March 7.

What might that mean for this year’s composers? Are they wasting their time entering music from films released earlier in the year? And what about the ever-growing crop of awards consultants and marketing people being paid to call attention to worthy work?

Nominees are chosen by the 293-member Academy music branch and are generally thought to be a strong overview of the best scores of the year. The winner, chosen by the entire membership, is not necessarily the “best,” most composers agree. The nomination, because the choice is made by their professional peers, is considered the real “win.”

Yet last year, two of the year’s top box-office hits, Michael Giacchino’s “Inside Out” (released in June) and Patrick Doyle’s “Cinderella” (released in March) missed out on score nominations despite excellent reviews specifically for their music. And the year before, “Maleficent” (released in May) was also overlooked despite raves for James Newton Howard’s score.

A Variety survey of the past 10 years shows that 82% of the films nominated for original score — 41 of 50 films — were released in the competitive October through December period.

Does that suggest music-branch members have a short memory or pay little attention to films released prior to awards season?

Says one veteran: “Not only do voters forget something that impressed them eight or nine months ago, but the studios don’t promote those projects because they’re spending all of their advertising dollars on the year-end releases. It’s a purposeful strategy: not to discriminate against the good stuff that came early in the year, but to capitalize on the attention span of the voters.”

Another defends the choices by pointing out that the “cynical and cold-eyed” studios tend to release their best product during the last quarter of the year and that first- or second-quarter releases often simply don’t measure up.

A longtime Oscar consultant points out that branch members don’t just listen to the scores, but also size up the movies themselves. “Oftentimes they’re looking at the movie itself. You rarely see a score nominated if they didn’t like the picture,” he says.

Another veteran marketer faults the branch for its short memory, noting “they tend to only look at all the important films that come out in the fourth quarter; they’ll consider something when it seems ‘important.'”

So what does this mean for the ballyhooed musical scores from early 2016, notably Giacchino’s “Zootopia” (March 4), John Debney’s “The Jungle Book” (April 15), Bear McCreary’s “10 Cloverfield Lane” (June 2), or Thomas Newman’s “Finding Dory” (June 17)? Are they, too, out of luck?

All of these will appear on the Academy’s “reminder list,” generally issued in mid-December and consisting of approximately 100 scores (everything that’s been entered and passes muster, rules-wise, with the music-branch executive committee).

But if history is any judge, look for this year’s nominees to come, by and large, from the last quarter of 2016.

More Music

  • Sony Recorded Music Revenues Dip in

    Sony Recorded Music Revenues Dip in 2018 Earnings Report

    As part of Sony’s earnings report for its 2018 fiscal year (which ended on March 31) the company’s music division showed mixed results, with recorded music revenues dropping around 4.5% to 426.9 billion yen ($3.82 billion) and overall revenue up just 1% to 795 billion yen ($7.2 billion). The company attributed the drop to lower [...]

  • Sony Pictures logo

    Sony Pictures Profits Rise to $489 Million but Music Profits Tumble

    Profits at Sony Pictures rose to $489 million for the financial year running to the end of March 2019. That compares with $376 million in the previous financial year. The pictures division result was achieved despite a fall in revenue. That dropped from $9.13 billion in the preceding financial year to $8.87 billion in the [...]

  • Taylor Swift's "ME!" Video Brings the

    Swift Take: Taylor's Dazzling 'ME!' Is a Phantasmagorical Sugar Rush (Watch)

    Taylor Swift has been leaving Easter eggs for her fans, with clues about the title, themes, et al. of her new single. The video, as it turns out, is almost like diving into a literal basket of Easter eggs. The opening title card for “ME!” reads “directed by Dave Meyers and Taylor Swift,” but we [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen Drops New Song, 'Hello

    Bruce Springsteen Drops New Song, 'Hello Sunshine' (Listen)

    While listeners of SiriusXM’s E Street Radio got an advance listen — actually several advance listens — Bruce Springsteen didn’t officially drop his new single, “Hello Sunshine,” until midnight ET — and released an accompanying lyric video as well. While it’s great as far as lyric videos go, of course what really matters here is [...]

  • Pink Hurts 2B Human album

    Album Review: Pink's 'Hurts 2B Human'

    You’d never want to reduce a Pink album strictly to the math, but the strength of her records tends to have a pretty strong correlation to two factors: the number of Max Martin/Shellback productions and the amount of F-bombs dropped. Now, put those two together, and it’s pure gold, but either one is a pretty [...]

  • Beetlejuice review

    Broadway Review: 'Beetlejuice'

    “Such a bold departure from the original source material!” wisecracks the odd-looking fellow sitting on a coffin at the start of the Broadway musical “Beetlejuice.” The weird, nasty and outrageous title character is talking about a short lament just sung by a sad teen at her mother’s gravesite, as he breaks the fourth wall (“Holy [...]

  • Ron HowardBreakthrough Prize, Arrivals, NASA Ames

    Ron Howard Talks New Luciano Pavarotti Documentary

    If one is an anomaly, two are a coincidence and three are a trend, then Ron Howard might strictly become a music documentarian after “Pavarotti” hits theaters. The documentary about the world-famous Italian tenor Luciano Pavarotti comes on the heels of Howard’s “The Beatles: Eight Days a Week” and “Made in America,” a look at [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content