You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Great Expectations for Egyptian Filmmakers

As Egypt’s dire political situation receives belated attention from Western media, festivals are beginning to look at a small number of films coming out of the country. But what are the criteria for selecting these films? Are they chosen for their artistic merit, or do they become a means for programmers to shine a spotlight on different cultures? More troublingly, are Egyptian and other Arab films selected merely as a way for the festivals to display their political affiliations? Much as affirmative action remains a testy subject in the U.S., so too for filmmakers from the Middle East and North Africa, where directors are delighted to be chosen by European and American fests but also question whether their inclusion owes as much to their country of origin as to their movies’ merits.

Understandably, few filmmakers want to accept that burden of responsibility.

“At the end of the day I’m not in charge of representing 300 million people, I’m in charge of representing myself,” says Tamer El Said, whose debut feature, “In the Last Days of the City,” receives its world premiere in the Berlin film festival’s Forum. “Of course I’m part of Egypt, I’m part of the Arab region, I’m part of this culture, but also I’m part of the world. And I have the right to express myself as part of the world.”

It’s a sentiment echoed by other Egyptian directors whose films are in the Berlinale this year. Many expressed concern that the expectations of programmers can lead to a minefield of constricted themes.

“I definitely think that European festivals seek out the political in Egyptian films,” says Heba Amin, director of “As Birds Flying,” playing in Forum Expanded. “Perhaps it’s an extension of the media narrative, or a longing for insight into something that appears confusing and contradictory from the outside. But then again, what is a non-political work? What does that look like?”

This conundrum is echoed by Said, who says, “Everything has politics. It comes anyway. In the end of the day I don’t make films because I have a political message — I make films because I feel there are things that I want to share. The political aspect comes from within. This is something I can’t control.”

Islam Kamal, director of the short “Expired” in Forum Expanded, expressed similar apprehensions.

“When European audiences pass by key words like ‘Middle East,’ a high percentage of them have a flash response of a sociological political film,” he says. “So where does that leave space for directors to make works that are true to their vision, rather than subject to an outsider’s expectations of what that vision should be?”

“Everyone has expectations from a film’s nationality,” adds Maged Nader, director of “Fathy Doesn’t Live Here Anymore,” also screening in Forum Expanded. “But the problem is those expectations are mostly about content more than artistic style or aesthetics. That makes untold pressure to make political films, especially in this moment in our history.”

On top of this pressure from the outside, there’s the challenge of making movies in a state actively engaging in a war against perceived envelope-pushers.

“You look at your work and try to see to what extent everything you do puts you in danger,” says Said. “You become crazy, asking yourself, ‘Am I taking this decision because I’m scared of the consequences, or because it’s good for the film?’”

Mark Lotfy, producer of “Expired,” hopes Egyptian filmmakers won’t bow to a sense of defeat due to a lack of creative encouragement.

“It serves as a resilience mechanism for us not to fall victims to frustration,” he says. “Yet, in the end, content shouldn’t be dictated by political events at home or expectations from abroad.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • AMC theater

    AMC Entertainment Introducing On-Demand Movie Service

    AMC Entertainment will introduce an online video store in the United States on Tuesday. Adam Aron, AMC’s president and chief executive, said that the AMC Theaters On Demand will offer about 2,000 films for sale or rent after their theatrical runs — much like Amazon or iTunes. Disney, Warner Bros., Universal, Sony and Paramount have [...]

  • Scarlett Johansson poses for photographers upon

    Scarlett Johansson 'Pushing' for All-Women Marvel Movie

    After the epic battle scene in “Avengers: Endgame” depicted the female superheroes uniting to protect Spider-Man from Thanos, Marvel fans started wondering if they’ll ever see the women unite for a standalone movie. “Captain Marvel” star Brie Larson generated even more buzz when she told Variety that she and other female co-stars have approached Marvel [...]

  • Ivana Lombardi Netflix

    Annapurna Film Head Ivana Lombardi Named Director of Indies at Netflix (EXCLUSIVE)

    Annapurna Pictures president of film Ivana Lombardi is moving across town to Netflix, after almost a year in her role at Megan Ellison’s company. As of Nov. 6, Lombardi will serve as director of independent films at the streamer. She will report directly to Lisa Nishimura, Netflix’s vice president of independent film and documentary features. [...]

  • Zoe Kravitz 'Big Little Lies' TV

    Zoe Kravitz to Play Catwoman in 'The Batman'

    “Big Little Lies” star Zoe Kravitz has been tapped to play Catwoman, the antiheroine and sometime love interest of the Caped Crusader, in Matt Reeves’ upcoming “The Batman.” Kravitz will star opposite Robert Pattinson as Batman. Pre-production on the Warner Bros.-DC Comics pic is expected to start this summer. No official start date has been [...]

  • Hadley Robinson Amy Poehler

    'Little Women' Actress Hadley Robinson to Star in Amy Poehler's 'Moxie'

    “Utopia” and “Little Women” actress Hadley Robinson has been tapped to star in Amy Poehler’s next directorial effort “Moxie.” Lauren Tsai is also on board to co-star in the Netflix movie. “Moxie” follows a teenage girl (Robinson) from a small town who is inspired by her mother’s Riot Girl past and starts a feminist revolution [...]

  • Samara Weaving

    'G.I. Joe' Spinoff 'Snake Eyes' Adds 'Ready or Not's' Samara Weaving

    Samara Weaving will join Henry Golding in the “G.I. Joe” spinoff, “Snake Eyes.” Haruka Abe, Ursula Corbero, Iko Uwais and Andrew Koji have also boarded the Paramount, Skydance and AllSpark movie. “The Captain” director Robert Schwentke is helming and Brian Goldner is producing. Evan Spiliotopoulos, who wrote “Beauty and the Beast” and “The Huntsman: Winter’s [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content