You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Censorship Of Media Dampens Burgeoning Filmmakers In Arab World

There’s a massive tug-of-war happening in the countries of the Arab world, between a globalized population more fluent in Kanye than the Quran, and an entrenched political class allied with hidebound religious authorities.

Film and TV are at the forefront of this fight, and the people in power have long recognized the force of the moving image in guiding cultural evolution and political awareness. From Egypt’s repressive military dictatorship to the shambolic power struggles in Lebanon, those who rule use censorship as a means of keeping dissent in check, convinced of the age-old formula that thick truncheons and thin skin are the most effective recipe for maintaining dominance.

This means that the politics of the Arab Spring are quashed. With “revolution” branded a dirty word, making criticism of Egypt’s President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, or the king of Morocco, non-starters. Since those in power prop up their positions with the help of mutually supportive religious hierarchies, any socially forward-thinking idea is also taboo, especially expressions of female sexuality and gay issues.

Despite countries in the MENA (Middle East-North Africa) region being socially and culturally diverse, entrenched ruling parties, along with the rise of Islamic conservativism, have sent a chill in the creative communities precisely at the moment when talented filmmakers are itching to tell stories relevant on local and international levels.
Most people in Egypt’s cultural sector have reported being under surveillance — offices raided, apartments watched. A few rare, brave independent news sites like Mada Masr do their jobs wondering how much longer they’ll be allowed to continue.

“Ending censorship was an important demand of the intellects in the revolution,” says Mohamed Diab, whose film “Clash” in Un Certain Regard is the sole Egyptian entry at Cannes this year. “When the Islamists were in power, they couldn’t impose their conservative agenda because they were under much scrutiny. Ironically, now the new regime needs to prove to the Egyptian masses that they are more religious than the Islamists, so we see more people being persecuted and jailed.”

Countries that didn’t experience the revolutions first hand are hardly immune from these impositions. For example, the Algerian government’s long-standing aversion to criticism casts a pall over film production and has forced noted directors like Merzak Allouache to work in France (and when he does shoot in his home country, the films are often banned from the nation’s few remaining theaters). In Morocco, Hicham Lasri’s scabrous satires, with their outright critiques of the monarchy, land him in hot water, while Nabil Ayouch’s “Much Loved” was banned for its unblinkered depiction of prostitution and women’s overt sexuality.

Lebanon may be thought of as one of the more liberal societies in the region, yet the country’s tinderbox political scene means that censorship is a frequent recourse for power players wanting to suppress any message not their own. Farah Shaer’s 2012 short “I Offered You Pleasure,” about Shia pleasure marriages, was rejected by the censors, with the minister of the interior going on television saying the film “puts the state in danger.” Complicating matters in Lebanon, several directors report being contacted by Hezbollah and told to change their scripts, or the militant group wouldn’t allow shooting to begin.

Of course the bastard child of censorship is self-censorship, that invidious but often understandable form of auto-straitjacketing.

“Everyone I know begged me not to make ‘Clash,’ ” Diab says. “They thought in troubled times like these, a political-action thriller would be very dangerous. Ironically, the film isn’t really about criticizing the government or any side; it’s more about self-discovery and the human condition.” He pushed through with the project, but remains wary. “Although I was politically active during the revolution, I decided to stop expressing my opinions even through social media, for fear that anything could stop my very controversial project,” Diab says.

As Egyptian helmer Yousry Nasrallah points out, pressure also comes from producers.
“Mainstream producers will be wary of projects dealing with police corruption or religious issues,” he says. “This, of course, influences writers and directors who prefer to have their scripts produced by big producers rather than by independent companies who rely on the long and winding routes of international funding.”

Certain directors or performers are singled out. It’s no secret that popular star Khaled Abol Naga’s criticism of Sisi has closed many doors in the Egyptian film industry. Even classic films aren’t safe, since the rights to most movies from the Golden Age are owned by Saudi Arabia’s Rotana, which frequently cuts content on pan-Arab broadcasts and DVDs in order to conform to stricter censorship codes.

It can be argued that the publicity surrounding banned and censored films can sometimes help get the word out.

“If it’s banned, it will shed more light on the project and people will realize these censorship laws are arbitrary,” Shaer says. “They’ll hear more about your film, but they’ll also know more about the dictatorship.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Mickey Mouse waves to members of

    Spider-Man, Spicer and Splashy First-Looks: Everything We're Looking For at D23

    As if Disney hasn’t owned enough weekends this year at the box office, the biennial D23 Expo will light up Anaheim, Calif. over the next three days to celebrate the content monolith. From a new Netflix-competing streaming platform to scores of movie and series reveals — along with a few hot controversies to confront — [...]

  • Angel Has Fallen

    'Angel Has Fallen' to Dominate Modest Box Office With $20 Million Weekend

    Gerard Butler and Morgan Freeman are leading the way at the North American box office with “Angel Has Fallen” on its way to about $20 million, early estimates showed Friday. Should forecasts hold, “Angel Has Fallen” will take in about double the next title, Universal’s second weekend of raunchy comedy “Good Boys” with about $10 [...]

  • Aracne

    Sanfic Standout ‘Aracne’ Filmmakers Discuss the State of Chilean Genre

    A key project at this year’s Santiago Lab, the Santiago Intl. Film Festival industry forum for promising Latin American projects, Florencia Dupont’s “Aracne” is representative of a push from the next generation of Chilean filmmakers into genre cinema and the themes it can explore. “Aracne” turns on Beatriz, a young journalist at a small Santiago [...]

  • Eduardo Machuca

    Chile’s Eduardo Machuca Unveils Machuca Films Slate (EXCLUSIVE)

    SANTIAGO, Chile – Eduardo Machuca, the former film co-ordinator of Chile’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, has launched his own production company, Machuca Films. “After 25 years at the ministry, I felt I needed to tap my creative side,” said Machuca, who is also tying the knot on Saturday (Aug. 25) with a former Sanfic staffer, [...]

  • Robert Downey Jr. Disney Legends Ceremony,

    Robert Downey Jr. Reveals He Was Busted for Smoking Pot at Disneyland

    Robert Downey Jr. celebrated his Disney Legend status by sharing the endearing tale of how the first time he visited Disneyland, he was arrested. The Iron Man actor was being honored in Anaheim at Disney’s biennial D23 convention. After a brief introduction by Disney chief executive officer Bob Iger, Downey felt he had to come [...]

  • Thandie Newton Reminiscence

    Thandie Newton Reteams With 'Westworld's' Lisa Joy on 'Reminiscence' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Following her Emmy win for her performance on “Westworld,” Thandie Newton is joining the feature directorial debut of the show’s co-creator. Sources tell Variety that Newton is set to join Hugh Jackman and Rebecca Ferguson in Warner Bros.’ “Reminiscence,” directed by “Westworld’s” Lisa Joy. WB acquired the rights to the package after this year’s Berlin [...]

  • Ming-Na Wen poses at the Disney

    Original 'Mulan' Star Ming-Na Wen Weighs in on Remake's Controversy

    Ming-Na Wen, who played the leading voice role in the original 1998 version of “Mulan,” has spoken out about the recent controversy surrounding Disney’s forthcoming live-action remake, which has been co-opted by China’s authoritarian regime to attack Hong Kong protestors. “We are living in a world right now where there’s so much change and confusion [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content