You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘We Are X’

This glossy, superficial doc profiles the three-decade-plus existence of Japan's premier metal band.

Yoshiki, Toshi, Pata, Heath, Sugizo, Taiji, Hide. (English, Japanese dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4835086/

Nearly as long-running as the U.S. punk-rock band from which their geographic designation distinguishes them, X Japan have been a huge success on their home turf for nearly three decades. But they’ve never really conquered America, something “We Are X” treats as a mystery, but which is pretty easy to explain: Their brand of highly theatrical glam metal was considered passe by the time they first attempted to conquer these shores in the early 1990s. Stephen Kijak’s documentary duly captures the many pyrotechnical, elaborately groomed moods of their “visual rock,” but this glossy history feels like another highly packaged stab at world domination. No doubt a major event for fans, this very authorized, unrevealing look is unlikely to win any new converts not already inclined toward instrumental-solo-heavy prog metal, lachrymose power ballads and ’80s-style hair bands.

Childhood schoolmates Yoshiki (drummer/keyboardist/principal composer) and Toshi (lead singer) were still in their teens when they formed X in 1982. Six years later their first album was released, reflecting an early emphasis on punk-influenced speed metal that soon expanded to encompass dollops of strings, piano and other sweeteners — no doubt a big factor in their success in a market that previously had limited use for heavy music. So did their doll-like personal presentation, with sky-high coifs and no mascara spared. But despite soon reaching enormous popularity, there were problems: A permanent rift with bassist Taiji, and a long-term one with Toshi, whose 1997 departure under the influence of a cult (not named or otherwise detailed here), suspended X Japan’s existence for a decade.

These and other crises are treated with solemn import, but little real insight — the band members (often shot in heroic, full-on-rock-star postures) aren’t about to dim their carefully constructed mystique by offering much in the way of down-to-earth personal disclosures. This comes off as more than a bit evasive, since two past members committed apparently suicide — surely something a documentary ought to address more penetratingly than the subjects allow here. Other omissions are just silly, as when the pic shows two young blonde women who seem to constantly be in Yoshiki’s orbit, yet shrinks from telling us what their professional or private roles (even their names) are.

The film is structured around the days leading up to the current edition of X Japan playing Madison Square Garden — a climactic triumph that seems as thoroughly stage-managed as anything else here. (It’s worth noting, as the film’s publicity materials do, that the docu’s own American director, a rock-doc specialist, had no idea who the band was before being hired to the project.) One can admire their showmanship (also glimpsed in plentiful archival PA, concert and music-video clips) without embracing the humorless, sometimes near-messianic grandiosity of their image, which “We Are X” dutifully reproduces in pseudo-verite form. Packaging is sleek, pacey and colorful.

Film Review: 'We Are X'

Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (World Cinema — competing), Jan. 23, 2016. Running time: 93 MIN.

Production: (Documentary — U.K.-U.S.-Japan) A Passion Pictures production in association with PrettyBird Pictures. Produced by John Battsek, Diane Becker, Jonathan McHugh, Jonathan Platt. Executive producers, George Chignell, Nicole Stott, Patrick Nugent. Co-executive producers, Kerstin Emhoff, Andrew Ruhemann.

Crew: Directed by Stephen Kijak. Camera (color, HD), Sean Kirby, John Maringouin; editors, Mako Kamitsuna, Maringouin; music, Yoshiki; sound, Theresa Radka, Adrienne Wade, Avi Zev Weider, Adam Drakewolf, Marc Hoppe, Dustin Pero, Alex Ramirez, Robert Bourke; re-recording mixer, Mark Rozett; supervising sound editor, Trip Brock.

With: Yoshiki, Toshi, Pata, Heath, Sugizo, Taiji, Hide. (English, Japanese dialogue)

More Film

  • Mindy Kaling (L) and Director Nisha

    Women Directors and Writers Make Gains in Independent Films But Lag on Parity

    Women directors, writers, editors and producers are making inroads, reaching historic highs in the world of independent films — while still lagging in reaching parity with men, a new study shows. The latest Indie Women study, released Tuesday, found that women achieved record-setting levels as directors (33% in 2018-19, up from 29% in 2017-18), writers [...]

  • David Shin

    Disney Shuffles Management in Hong Kong, Australia

    Disney has reshuffled its management in Hong Kong, Taiwan and Australasia following the March completion of its 21st Century Fox takeover. In Hong Kong and New Zealand, Fox executives have been elevated. In Australia and New Zealand, Disney’s management is staying on. David Shin has been appointed VP and GM of The Walt Disney Company [...]


    Shanghai: Chinese Movies Dominate AACTA Asian Film Award Nominations

    Chinese sci-fi hit “The Wandering Earth,” China’s Cannes competition film “Wild Goose Lake,” and Korea’s Palme d’Or-winner “Parasite” are among the nominees for the AACTA Award for best Asian film. The nominees were announced at an event on Monday on the margins of the Shanghai International Film Festival. The winners will be presented on Dec. [...]

  • Jenni Rivera Biopic

    Authorized Jenni Rivera Biopic in the Works

    An authorized biopic of the late singer Jenni Rivera is in the works, seven years after she died in a plane crash at the age of 43. The life rights deal was announced Tuesday with an agreement between Jenni Rivera Enterprises and producers Javier Chapa and Simon Wise of Mucho Mas Media and Donald De [...]

  • Judi Dench

    ‘Blithe Spirit’ With Judi Dench, Dan Stevens, Isla Fisher Scores International Sales

    Filming has started on “Blithe Spirit,” an adaptation of Noel Coward’s classic comedy about love that just won’t die. Judi Dench, Isla Fisher and Dan Stevens are among the cast in the picture, which is helmed by Edward Hall (“Downton Abbey”). Protagonist has closed a raft of pre-sales on the project, which was previously adapted [...]

  • Edward Cheng, Tencent Pictures CEO

    Tencent Pictures' Lineup Is a Mix of Hollywood Content and Chinese Propaganda

    A slate of Chinese propaganda films rubs shoulders with high-profile Hollywood movies on Tencent Pictures’ upcoming lineup.  The firm confirmed its investment in U.S. projects including TriStar Pictures’ “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood,” a film about beloved TV host Mr. Rogers, starring Tom Hanks; “Monster Hunter,” Paul W.S. Anderson’s next film adaptation of a [...]

  • Night scenery of the Bund in

    Shanghai: Festivals Grapple With How to Stay Relevant in the Digital Era

    Festival organizers from around the world Tuesday discussed the challenges of remaining relevant in a digital era at a Shanghai International Film Festival forum. The Festival do Rio’s executive director, Ilda Santiago, noted that online platforms are now an unavoidable part of the film business and creative process, and that “of course not all of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content