Film Review: ‘The Have-Nots’

German helmer Florian Hoffmeister's sensitive, deftly acted debut feature offers an international twist on post-9/11 trauma.

Julia Jentsch, Sebastian Zimmler, Guy Burnet, Ole Lagerpusch, Bibiana Beglau, Aljoscha Stadelmann, Ronald Pickup, Gina Bellmann, Raffiella Chapman, Catherine Walker, Brigitte Zeh. (German, English dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4939384/

Perhaps it’s inevitable that the reach of Florian Hoffmeister’s feature debut “The Have-Nots” somewhat exceeds its grasp. This is a film that attempts little less than to make a grand statement on the disaffection of an entire young, upwardly mobile, international generation in the wake of the seismic existential shock that was 9/11, even working in allusions to World War II. It’s actually more remarkable that Hoffmeister comes fairly close at times to fulfilling such gargantuan ambitions, in the form of a modest, black-and-white relationship drama. Based on Katharina Hacker’s award-winning novel of the same title (“Die Habenichtse”), and distinguished by two quietly credible performances in challenging central roles, “The Have-Nots” deserves praise for revealing an often transparent truth: that the ties that bind us to each other are irrevocably  influenced by events over which we have no control. In short, this world can drive you mad, without you even noticing.

Jacob (Sebastian Zimmler) meets his longtime best friend Hans (Ole Jagerpusch) for a drink following Jacob’s promotion at his Berlin law firm and Hans’ acceptance of a big job in restitution law in London. Both men travel to New York on business; Hans casually encourages Jacob to attend a Berlin gallery opening some days hence which artist Isabelle (Julia Jentsch) an ex for whom Jacob still carries a torch, is expected to attend. Next thing we know, Jacob has curtailed his American trip, leaving Hans behind, to make it to the opening, where he duly meets Isabelle and sparks fly. The scene is set for a bittersweet love story about fate and second chances, until we discover the date: the 11th of September, 2001.

The 9/11 attacks and their effect on the American psyche have been much discussed and analysed, either directly or obliquely, in a multitude of films and TV shows since. But the international slant here feels like territory less well-traveled, as the infamous imagery of burning towers, falling figures and ash-covered passersby unfolds on television screens in Berlin apartments and in newspapers read in European sidewalk cafes. For Jacob and Isabelle, the shock of the attack is real but remote, until the revelation that Hans is among the dead.

In a slipstream of grief and guilt, with an oddly understandable urge to atone by living out Hans’ life rather than his own, Jacob decides to take Hans’ London job, and proposes to Isabelle. At an impasse in her own creative life and shaken on a less personal but no less profound level by the Iraq War era of uncertainty, she accepts. They move to London, to a flat with a dodgy door and downstairs neighbors who are volubly abusive toward their little girl. Their increasing alienation from each other leads Isabelle into an unlikely relationship with volatile junkie and small-time dealer Jim (Guy Burnet), while Jacob works long days on a tricky case and begins to hallucinate Hans in the faces of strangers.

Hans’ death is clearly the crux of the story, though Hoffmeister’s film would arguably have been stronger without that further twist of the knife. Along with his lead actors, he makes a fine job of evoking the sense of dissociation, the generalized loss of stability felt by those who were on the verge of the most defining period of their lives when 9/11 happened. We see clever, subtle connections between the micro — the irrational behavioral impulses that Jacob and Isabelle display — and the macro socio-political situation. This valuable point might have been better made had Jacob had no direct connection to the 9/11 attacks — had the couple’s grief been, as it was for so many millions, more helplessly theoretical than pointedly personal. When Jacob, during a moment of breakdown, confesses to feeling like his and Isabelle’s love was what had killed Hans — that if he hadn’t left New York in hopes of seeing her Hans would still be alive — it is poignant, but in being so particular it undercuts the potential for more universal insights.

Similarly, a subplot about a wartime restitution case feels like an unnecessary extra that does little to enrich the film’s real concern, which is how the times in which we live can affect us on a more intimate level than we like to believe. These processes are invisible to Jacob and Isabelle because they live so deep inside them, but Hoffmeister’s talent is to render them visible to us, the omniscient viewers. Omniscient but not quite godlike, that is — because while we understand the wider patterns that Jacob and Isabelle cannot ever see in their fullness, we are as powerless as they are to change them. As the slightly despairing “happy” ending to this very promising and sensitive debut suggests, some breakages can’t be fixed, only accepted. After that, you can only hope to hell that someone out there will save you from being broken alone.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'The Have-Nots'

Reviewed online, Berlin, June 30, 2016. (In Munich Film Festival — New German Cinema.) Running time: 100 MIN. (Original title: “Die Habenichtse”)

Production: (Germany) A Real Fiction Filmverleih e.K. release (in Germany) of a Unafilm GmbH production in association with Bayerischer Rundfunk, Arte, Rundfunk Berlin-Brandenburg. (International sales: Unafilm, Cologne.) Produced by Titus Kreyenberg. Co-producer, Florian Hoffmeister.

Crew: Directed by Florian Hoffmeister. Screenplay, Mona Kino, adapted from the novel "Die Habenichtse" by Katharina Hacker. Camera (B&W), Robert Binnall; editor, Kathrin Dietzel; music, Adrian Corker; production designer, Cora Pratz; costume designer, Manfred Schneider; sound, Andreas Wölki; sound designer, Moritz Hoffmeister; re-recording mixer, Kostas Varibobiotis; assistant director, Annette Drees; casting, Bernhard Karl, Elaine Grainger.

With: Julia Jentsch, Sebastian Zimmler, Guy Burnet, Ole Lagerpusch, Bibiana Beglau, Aljoscha Stadelmann, Ronald Pickup, Gina Bellmann, Raffiella Chapman, Catherine Walker, Brigitte Zeh. (German, English dialogue)

More Film

  • Gaston Pavlovich

    ’The Irishman’s’ Gaston Pavlovich, Endemol Shine Boomdog Ink Production Pact (EXCLUSIVE)

    “The Irishman” producer Gaston Pavlovich and his Mexico City-based production company Fabrica de Cine have inked an overall development and production deal with Endemol Shine Boomdog, the Mexican outpost of Endemol Shine North America. News comes as “The Irishman” opens the Los Cabos Int’l Film Festival on Wednesday, Nov. 13. The Martin Scorsese Netflix-backed drama [...]

  • Charlize Theron'The Addams Family' film premiere,

    Charlize Theron to Be Honored by Costume Designers Guild (EXCLUSIVE)

    The Costume Designers Guild announced Wednesday that Academy Award-winner Charlize Theron will be honored with the spotlight award. The Spotlight Award honors an actor whose talent and career personify an enduring commitment to excellence, including a special awareness of the role and importance of costume design. “Charlize Theron is a costume designer’s dream, bringing integrity [...]

  • Ford v Ferrari

    'Ford V. Ferrari' Soundtrack Revealed (EXCLUSIVE)

    The full tracklist for the forthcoming 20th Century Fox film “Ford V. Ferrari,” starring Academy Award-winners Matt Damon and Christian Bale, has been revealed below. The film is based on the true story of American car designer Carroll Shelby (Damon) and the British-born driver Ken Miles (Bale), who together battled corporate interference, the laws of [...]

  • Modern-Loves

    Cinepolis Takes Latin America on ‘Modern Loves,’ Drops First Trailer (EXCLUSIVE)

    MEXICO CITY —  Mexico’s Cinepolis, one of the biggest movie theater chains in the world, has acquired rights for Latin America to Matías Meyer’s “Amores Modernos” (Modern Loves), which world premieres at this week’s Los Cabos Film Festival, playing in main competition. In the U..S., “Modern Loves” has been taken by premium Latinx-content streaming platform, [...]

  • THE IRISHMAN (2019)Ray Ramano (Bill Bufalino

    Los Cabos Film Festival: 10 Takes on the 2019 Edition

    MEXICO CITY —  A crossroads for the film industries of Mexico, the U.S. and Canada, Los Cabos Intl. Film Festival opens its doors on Wednesday, Nov. 13 with a lineup which takes on board hot-button issues – gender, violence in Mexico, the impact of global platforms – as the Festival consolidates its status as a [...]


    Berlin Winner Manuel Abramovich’s “Pornomelancholia” Taps French Funding (EXCLUSIVE)

    MEXICO CITY — Argentina’s Manuel Abramovich, a 2019 Berlinale Silver Bear winner for “Blue Boy,” has tapped French funding for its follow-up, “Pornomelancholia,” one of the highest-profile projects at Mexico’s Los Cabos Film Festival, which kicks off today with a gala screening of “The Irishman,” Financing from the Region Nouvelle-Aquitaine, a building film-TV hub in [...]

  • CDMX-Film-Pitchbox

    Filmarket Hub Announces Projects for First CDMX Film Pitchbox (EXCLUSIVE)

    When Variety unveiled the CDMX Film Pitchbox, a new movie project pitching forum that will take place in Mexico City on Nov. 29, organizer Filmarket Hub announced that executives from Alazraki Entertainment, Cinema 226, Cinépolis, Lemon Studios, Perro Azul and VCS Capital had already confirmed they would attend. Since then, Dynamo, Endemol Shine Boomdog, Exile Content Studio, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content