Film Review: ‘Nuts!’

The forgotten tale of a one-time king among medical quacks is told in this amusing, mostly-animated doc.

Pope Brock, Gene Fowler, James Reardon, Megan Seaholm.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5236900/

The potentiality of a President Trump has many pondering Americans’ susceptibility to snake-oil salesmen, making it a particularly opportune moment for “Nuts,” about a now-little-remembered public figure of great popular appeal nearly a century ago. Penny Lane’s feature relates the bizarre saga of John R. Brinkley in a novel mix of archival materials, latter-day commentators, unreliable voice-actor narration and primarily animated visuals. The stranger-than-fiction result is a prankishly entertaining documentary well-suited for people who think they don’t like documentaries. While continuing on the festival trail it commenced with a Sundance premiere this past January, “Nuts” launches its U.S. theatrical run June 22 at NYC’s Film Forum, with about two dozen additional hardtops booked so far.

Thom Stylinski’s screenplay is billed as based on “The Life of a Man,” a vanity biography of Brinkley written by Clement Wood, a prolific hack writer who, like his subject, claimed expertise on innumerable subjects and for a time pursued a political career. It was published in 1934, the year in which Brinkley’s hitherto whopping good fortune began its irreversible decline. But for the first hour of “Nuts,” Lane (“Our Nixon”) and Stylinski offer Wood’s hagiographic, Horatio Alger-like take on a wholesome poor boy from North Carolina who through sheer industry and innovation scaled the heights of success — despite cruel persecution from jealous Establishment entities such as the American Medical Association.

Brinkley did indeed grow up poor in North Carolina, with dreams of becoming a doctor. By his early 30s he’d established a practice in Milford, Kan. There, a farmer’s impotency complaints purportedly triggered his greatest breakthrough: Implanting goat gonads in patients, a procedure he soon claimed cured just about every other human ailment as well. Astonishingly, favorable word of this spread like wildfire, not only making him the economic engine of tiny Milford, but attracting attention and rumored famous patients far afield. (As illustration of the concept’s pop-culture infiltration, Lane includes a clip from Buster Keaton’s 1922 comedy “Cops” that hinges on a “goat gland specialist” joke.) Eventually Brinkley claimed he was able to reproduce the same results sans surgery, injecting a serum instead.

Popular on Variety

Whatever his medical acumen, Brinkley was undeniably a genius at self-promotion. Discovering the advertising potential of radio, he conquered that medium with a vengeance, creating his own hugely powerful stations (including one just across the border in Mexico when U.S. regulation hobbled his stateside operations) which among other things did much to popularize country or “hillbilly” music. At the height of his public profile, he ran for public office several times, offering a tempting if implausible roster of freebies to each citizen if elected. In fact, he would have become the Governor of Kansas had the political establishment not managed to disqualify thousands of his write-in votes on a questionable technicality.

By that time, however, Brinkley’s nemeses at the AMA and Federal Radio Commission were getting the upper hand. While he continued to broadcast and make vanity newsreels (excepted here) of folky mansion family life, his empire was about to fall, hard. “Nuts’” final third reveals much of the unflattering truth that laid beneath the first hour’s careful, “authorized” bio-fiction: Its hero was in fact a secret bigamist with dubious academic credentials and an arrest record. His professional “quackery” (and accumulated wealth) would come undone in a blitz of wrongful death suits and other legal woes.

By emphasizing Brinkley’s remarkable “self-made-man” accomplishments over their grimmer consequences (no one knows precisely how many patients ultimately died as a result of his “treatments”), Lane and company create a sort of prankish ode to the classic American Dream of hard work and high ideals leading inevitably to fame, fortune and happiness. That’s what Brinkley was really selling, and he mastered its packaging even if the content turned out to be mostly fraudulent. (His pricey cure-all serum was discovered to be distilled water plus blue dye.)

It’s a tale of cartoonish, believe-it-or-not hubris and gullibility that’s well-served by the tactic of being illustrated by different animators for seven successive narrative chapters. While their styles are diverse, they stick to a general template (including mostly B&W or sepia hues), flowing together effectively. Apart from archival footage, the only significant live-action elements are talking-head interviews with a quartet of specialized historians.

There’s little larger-context meaning to “Nuts” beyond that which the viewer brings to it, and sometimes (particularly in the rather broad voice contributions to the animated sequences) the film’s humorous tone verges on the overly juvenile. Yet you can’t really say that’s a betrayal of the subject: “The story of the goat nuts doctor” inherently sounds like a pitch for an Adam Sandler comedy. This now-obscure historical chapter can’t help but be silly in the retelling, and Lane surrenders whole to that silliness. All design and technical contributions resourcefully reinforce her primary desire to amuse.

Film Review: 'Nuts!'

Reviewed online, San Francisco, May 14, 2016. (In Sundance, Rotterdam, San Francisco International, Hot Docs, Full Frame festivals.) Running time: 79 MIN.

Production: (Documentary) An mTuckman Media release of a Gland Power Films and Cartuna presentation. Produced by James Belfer, Caitlin Mae Burke, Penny Lane, Daniel Shepard. Executive producers, Dan Cogan, Elias Savada. Co-producers, David Amillei, Kara Janeczko.

Crew: Directed by Penny Lane. Screenplay, Thom Stylinski, based on the book “The Life of a Man: A Biography of John R. Brinkley” by Clement Wood. Camera (color, HD), Hallie Kohler, Lane, Joseph Victorine, Mark Walley, Angela Walley; editors, Lane, Stylinski, Heather Capps; music, Brian McOmber; animators, Drew Christie, Dane Herforth, Julie Veldman, Michael Pisano, Krystal Downs, Ace & Son Moving Picture Co., Rose Stark, Hazel Lee Santino; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, Tom Paul; sound designers, Andrea Bella, Jesse Stiles.

With: Pope Brock, Gene Fowler, James Reardon, Megan Seaholm.

More Film

  • Andy SambergVariety Sundance Studio presented by

    Andy Samberg Calls Hosting the Oscars a 'Bad Gig' -- That He'd Still Consider

    Andy Samberg has been a reliable favorite hosting awards ceremonies, in recent years emceeing the Independent Spirit Awards, the Emmys and the 2019 Golden Globes with Sandra Oh. So it’s only natural to wonder if Samberg would consider taking the reins on the Oscars, which will return again this year without a host. “They have [...]

  • Shirley

    'Shirley': Film Review

    Shirley Jackson was a real person, a writer best known for her twisted short story “The Lottery,” although the version presented in Josephine Decker’s “Shirley” feels more like a character from one of her own novels. Featuring “The Handsmaid’s Tale” actor Elisabeth Moss in the title role, this queer, hard-to-quantify psychological study isn’t a biopic [...]

  • Us Kids

    'Us Kids': Film Review

    The nonstop drama of the Trump White House has succeeded, among other things, in largely pushing gun control from the forefront of the news cycle — no doubt to the relief of the NRA and its allies, despite the continued frequency of U.S. mass shootings. As a result, and perhaps unfairly, Kim A. Snyder’s “Us [...]

  • Logan Paul Ninja Spree

    How Logan Paul and Ninja Helped 'Spree' Cast Capture Influencer Culture Gone Wild

    When it came to depicting the gonzo nature of influencer culture, “Spree” stars Joe Keery and Sasheer Zamata and director Eugene Kotlyarenko did a deep dive into the haves and have-nots of the internet. “Spree,” which premiered Friday at Sundance Film Festival, follows a rideshare driver named Kurt Kunkle (Keery) who will stop at nothing [...]

  • The Go Go's at Chicagofest in

    'The Go-Go's': Film Review

    In the terrific documentary “The Go-Go’s,” there’s a tasty clip of the band playing an early club gig in 1979, when they were part of the L.A. punk scene. They wear bushy black hair and pale white makeup (with rouge!), as if they were trying to be mannequin versions of Darby Crash, and they have [...]


    Watch the Exclusive Trailer of Rotterdam/Goteborg Entry ‘A Perfectly Normal Family’

    Variety has been given exclusive access to the international trailer of the Danish film “A Perfectly Normal Family,” due to compete both at Rotterdam’s Big Screen Competition, and at Göteborg’s Nordic Film Competition. Malou Reyman’s debut feature has been a hot property for sales agent New Europe Film Sales, ever since it was sneak peeked [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content