×

Film Review: ‘Fraud’

Dean Fleischer-Camp's expert riff on self-documentation holds a funhouse mirror up to the American family's consumerist impulses.

Found-footage sourced from YouTube documents the escalating exploits of an apparently typical lower-middle-class family in Dean Fleischer-Camp’s subversive constructed narrative “Fraud.” Previously best known for his award-winning stop-motion short “Marcel the Shell With Shoes On,” Fleischer-Camp here stakes a claim in conceptually sophisticated documentary territory with a film that, despite frenetic cutting and a lean runtime, rewards contemplation and patience. The audience will be smaller and more specialized than the approximately 40 million views collectively accrued by the three “Marcel” shorts, but festival programmers looking to shake things up would be wise to fall for this “Fraud.”

Gary, like millions of Americans, loves to document his family life. Whether his wife and two kids are unboxing a new iPhone, visiting the mall or taking a trip to the Big Apple, his camera is ever-present, capturing the daily trials and tribulations, the myriad tiny moments of joy and all the ennui in between that comprise a reasonably representative existence for someone his age, nationality and income bracket. To begin with, it appears as if this might be all this film is interested in showing — it’s not a bad subject, after all. But soon, and with an exquisite sense of narrative control, Fleischer-Camp and Rippon begin to sketch a different portrait: first of a family in over its head financially (those iPhones don’t come cheap, after all), and subsequently of an audacious attempt to wipe the slate clean.

While the mounting debts of an everyman might seem like the starting point for a classic film noir, Gary’s original camerawork has a hectic, vividly restless quality to it that verges on nausea-inducing, making this a difficult watch on the big screen; its natural home is probably VOD. This is the understandable result of the fact that the footage was genuinely intended simply for Gary’s family’s YouTube account: Between 2008 and 2015, Gary uploaded over a hundred hours of home movies to the dominant user-generated content platform. Enter Fleischer-Camp, who stumbled upon Gary’s account and apparently spent some years mulling over how to turn it into a documentary before arriving at the premise for “Fraud.”

The result feels deceptively raw yet elegant: In constructing a fictional narrative from genuine footage, Fleischer-Camp arrives at something that, like this year’s Sundance hit “Operation Avalanche,” pushes the boundaries of documentary, gesturing at larger truths. Where some documentaries aim to objectively reflect a subject, “Fraud” recognizes that the notion is a fallacy. Any camera lens can only ever be a funhouse mirror, incorporating the distortions that the filmmaker’s choices (framing, editing, what to show, what not to show) bring to the table.

Fleischer-Camp and editor Jonathan Rippon’s subtle recontextualizations illuminate the family’s attempt to live their lives as outlined in omnipresent commercials as both illogical and understandable — this is not a film intent on hanging its subjects out to dry. The impulse to earn happiness through acquisition is followed to its logical conclusion, with only the narrative’s more outré elements requiring footage from other YouTube sources. The only rule is that no footage is staged.

Rippon, the helmer’s regular collaborator, must share credit for the project’s success. The immediate connections and juxtapositions he forges between sections of footage from Gary’s archive, which in reality were shot years apart, feel almost supernaturally intuitive — it’s hard to spot the joins. Like a good act of sleight-of-hand magic, it’s the fluidity of the project on a technical level that makes it persuasive, allowing the themes to breathe: It would be hard to focus on the picture’s implicit consumerist commentary if we were constantly trying to spot the rabbit up the magician’s sleeve.

At Toronto’s Hot Docs festival, the film world-premiered to considerable controversy, with its director called a “con artist” and “liar” during post-screening Q&As by audience members presumably secure in their adherence to more traditional definitions of documentary. Festival programmers pursuing a reputation for risk-taking and innovation would be wise to check it out. Beyond festivals, the film’s commercial prospects seem uncertain, although it’s easy to foresee a future retrospective of Flesicher-Camp’s work in which “Fraud” features as a rediscovered early-career gem — likely seen by too few at the time.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Fraud'

Reviewed at Hot Docs Film Festival (The Pursuit of Happiness), May 3, 2016. Running time: 52 MIN.

Production: (Documentary) A Memory Production. (International sales: Memory, Los Angeles.) Produced by Sebastian Pardo, Riel Roch-Decter.

Crew: Directed by Dean Fleischer-Camp. Editor, Jonathan Rippon.

More Film

  • Kristen Stewart Underwater

    Watch Kristen Stewart Fight Sea Monsters in 'Underwater' Trailer

    Vampires, ghosts and now sea monsters? Clearly there is no monster actress Kristen Stewart cannot tame. In the first trailer for the submerged thriller “Underwater,” Stewart is a member of a stranded submarine crew. The trailer begins with the radio message: “You are now 5,000 miles from land and you are descending seven miles to [...]

  • Romanian Director Catalin Mitulescu on Sarajevo

    Romanian Director Catalin Mitulescu on Sarajevo Competition Film ‘Heidi’

    A leading figure of the Romanian New Wave, Cătălin Mitulescu has had a heralded career since winning the Palme d’Or for his 2004 short film “Traffic.” His first two features, “The Way I Spent the End of the World” (2006) and “Loverboy” (2011), both premiered in Cannes’ Un Certain Regard sidebar. He also co-produced and [...]

  • Betty Gilpin'Stuber' film premiere, Arrivals, Regal

    'GLOW' Star Betty Gilpin in Talks to Join Chris Pratt in 'Ghost Draft' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Fresh off her Emmy nomination for Netflix’s “GLOW,” Betty Gilpin has found her next project. The actress is in talks to join Chris Pratt in “Ghost Drama,” a sci-fi action film from Skydance and Paramount. Gilpin would join a cast that also includes “Handmaid’s Tale” star Yvonne Strahovski. Directed by “Lego Batman” filmmaker Chris McKay [...]

  • Stephan Komandarev on Sarajevo Player ‘Rounds’

    Director Stephan Komandarev on Sarajevo Player ‘Rounds’ and His Bulgarian Trilogy

    Bulgarian director Stephan Komandarev earned critical acclaim for his 2017 feature “Directions,” which was selected for Cannes’ Un Certain Regard sidebar. The first installment in a planned trilogy about the social inequality and moral ills plaguing both Bulgaria and Europe at large, the film followed six cab drivers over the course of 24 hours as [...]

  • Meryl Streep Best Movie Lines

    HBO Max Lands Steven Soderbergh's Next Film Starring Meryl Streep

    HBO Max has picked up Steven Soderbergh’s next film, the comedy “Let Them All Talk” starring Meryl Streep. Joining Streep in the ensemble cast are Candice Bergen, Dianne Wiest, Lucas Hedges and Gemma Chan. The screenplay was written by short story author and MacArthur Fellow recipient Deborah Eisenberg. It’s the story of a celebrated author [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen FYSEE Opening Night with

    Bruce Springsteen Drops Introspective Trailer for 'Western Stars' Film

    While initial reports about Bruce Springsteen’s forthcoming documentary around his recent “Western Stars” album said that it would essentially be a concert film, the first trailer for it, which dropped today, suggests it’s going to be a more introspective outing, more in line with his autobiographical performances at “Springsteen on Broadway” in 2017 and 2018, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content