×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Cinema Futures’

The significant problems accompanying the analog-to-digital revolution (or coup) are voiced far better by interviewed experts than the director’s own narration.

With:
Paul Klamer, Mirjam Bromundt, David Bordwell, Martin Scorsese, Grover Crisp, Michael Friend, Alex Hernandez, Jeffrey Clarke, Greg Lukow, Mike Mashon, Gerhard Frank, Paolo Cherchi Usai, Ken Weissman, Tacita Dean, Christopher Nolan, Tom Gunning, Jesse Morrow, Kathy O’Regan, Laura Alberque, Clara Auclair, Jacques Rancière, Nicole Brenez, Apichatpong Weerasethakul, Ben Tucker, Deborah Stoiber, George Willeman, Margaret Bodde, Scott Ostrowsky, Tim Schmidt, Hardik Kanakia, Milt Shefter, Paul Klamer, Robert Miller, James Snyder. Voice-over: Michael Palm (German, English, French dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6002238/

It’s good that Michael Palm joins the ranks of directors making documentaries highlighting the significant problems accompanying the analog-to-digital revolution (or is it a coup?), but it would have been better had he allowed someone else to do the voice-over. Or even the writing of the voice-over. “Cinema Futures” is rich in excellent interviews, stuffed with important information, and bursting with unanswerable questions that need to be asked. Yet the film lacks one major element: the pleasure factor. Barely anywhere in the more than two-hour documentary is there a spontaneous, unanalytical emotional response to the joys of cinema, and without this, Palm’s doc becomes a passionless compendium that raises alarms without stoking the fire.

Without the narration, “Cinema Futures” could easily see significant TV sales, but given that Palm’s monotone delivery and deadpan philosophizing recall Mike Myers’ Dieter character, it’s hard to imagine much play outside continental Europe, apart from scattered festivals. It’s a great pity, as the director brings together an impressive array of talking heads and draws attention to issues, such as preservation and custodial problems, that preoccupy the archival world but have yet to filter into the popular consciousness. Unlike Chris Kenneally’s “Side by Side,” which discussed similar matters, Palm’s documentary definitely takes sides and mourns the disappearance of celluloid, yet doesn’t do enough to bring out the aesthetic losses – which really are quantifiable – inherent in the wholesale ejection of analogue.

Much is made of a photo from the late 1990s showing a group of industry people gleefully advertising the death of film stock in anticipation of the premiere of “Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace,” though it’s unlikely anyone in the picture had any idea of the scope of the revolution to come, when Yoda himself would become a mere digitized simulacrum after once being played by Frank Oz. Pity that Palm doesn’t mention Ari Folman’s criminally underrated “The Congress,” with its hard-hitting approach to this very subject.

Blame for the collateral damage of film’s demise is squarely leveled at Hollywood, symbolized by a nighttime aerial shot of L.A. designed to make the city appear like the Death Star, accompanied by John Williams-type music. Fortunately, film historian David Bordwell takes a subtler approach, discussing the disproportionate allocation of power to the distributors who call the shots. By now the train of events has become fairly well-known: the stranglehold of the multiplexes, together with the force-feeding of 3D, coerced theater owners into digitizing their cinemas to the point where now it’s difficult to find movie houses that can project acetate.

The decline of Kodak is addressed, and the very real concern that, despite the company’s reassurances, the continued manufacture of film stock may not be financially viable in the near future considering how few directors continue to shoot on celluloid.  Even when they do, the movies still need to be transferred onto digital in order to get released. Perhaps the biggest value of “Cinema Futures” is that it makes viewers aware that digital files need to be migrated and updated every five years or they lose cohesion, whereas acetate can last over 500 years when stored in the right conditions. What still hasn’t sunk in for the general public is that, as hypothesized by conservation student Laura Alberque, the rate of digital deterioration combined with the lack of understanding that files need to be migrated means that we’ll have far fewer watchable home movies in 20 years than our grandparents had. Yet apart from a handful of Cassandras, no one appears to be screaming about this.

Because Palm wants to tackle all the issues inherent in the analogue-digital divide, he inevitably drops several important points, most notably that while some might like to think we have the ability to screen films as they once were, it’s not true. Even if nitrate were projected (as it is at George Eastman Museum’s annual Nitrate Picture Show), the projectors themselves have changed, and it’s impossible to fully reproduce carbon arc lighting. We can look with fond nostalgia at the shimmering dust particles caught in the bright light of the projector’s throw, but in truth we’ll never be able to replicate the filmgoing experience of the past, also because photochemical emulsions are unstable. That gives them their warmth and beauty, argue Tacita Dean and Christopher Nolan, but also makes it impossible, as pointed out by Eastman curator Paolo Cherchi Usai, to pretend that any print is exactly how it was meant to be.

On the plus side, the documentary champions the work of archivists and acknowledges the monumental challenges they face in terms of preservation. It would have been good to include a few words about the scandalous lack of funds accorded these institutions for the crucial work they do – anyone thinking Martin Scorsese’s World Film Foundation has either the money or the time to save every “worthwhile” movie is living in a fool’s paradise. Also not mentioned are the benighted policies of certain governments that force archives to destroy their nitrate once preservation prints are made, robbing future conservators with improved technology the chance to extract better material from the original sources. Surely that would have been more meaningful than hearing Palm opining that film is like a vampire in a coffin.

Film Review: 'Cinema Futures'

Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (Venice Classics), Sept. 2, 2016. Running time: 125 MIN.  

Production: (Documentary – Austria) A Mischief Films production, in cooperation with the Austria Film Museum. (International sales: Sixpack Film, Vienna.) Producers: Ralph Wieser, Georg Misch.  

Crew: Director, writer, editor: Michael Palm. Camera: Joerg Burger.

With: Paul Klamer, Mirjam Bromundt, David Bordwell, Martin Scorsese, Grover Crisp, Michael Friend, Alex Hernandez, Jeffrey Clarke, Greg Lukow, Mike Mashon, Gerhard Frank, Paolo Cherchi Usai, Ken Weissman, Tacita Dean, Christopher Nolan, Tom Gunning, Jesse Morrow, Kathy O’Regan, Laura Alberque, Clara Auclair, Jacques Rancière, Nicole Brenez, Apichatpong Weerasethakul, Ben Tucker, Deborah Stoiber, George Willeman, Margaret Bodde, Scott Ostrowsky, Tim Schmidt, Hardik Kanakia, Milt Shefter, Paul Klamer, Robert Miller, James Snyder. Voice-over: Michael Palm (German, English, French dialogue)

More Film

  • Cannes: Four Polish Female Directors Embark

    Cannes: Four Polish Female Directors Embark on 'Erotica 2022' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Four Polish female filmmakers have partnered with four top female Polish authors on film project “Erotica 2022.” The producer Marta Lewandowska is in Cannes seeking financing. The pic, set in the near future in Poland, is composed of four stories about women’s issues, loosely connected, and all with an erotic element. The film is directed [...]

  • Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

    Cannes Film Review: Quentin Tarantino's 'Once Upon a Time...in Hollywood'

    It has been 25 years to the day since Quentin Tarantino’s “Pulp Fiction” premiered at the Cannes Film Festival, crystalizing a cinema revolution, and we have never looked back. Yet here’s one more QT anniversary, a bit less monumental but, in its way, as meaningful: It has been 10 years since the premiere of “Inglourious [...]

  • Quentin Tarantino's 'Once Upon a Time

    Quentin Tarantino, 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood' Score Six-Minute Standing Ovation at Cannes

    Twenty five years after Quentin Tarantino took Cannes by storm with “Pulp Fiction,” the maverick director returned with “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” receiving a six-minute standing ovation at Tuesday’s glittering premiere. It’s one of the longest such receptions at this year’s festival, which has been building up to the moment when Brad Pitt [...]

  • 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood':

    'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood': First Reactions Pour in From Cannes

    Reactions to Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” which premiered Tuesday evening in Cannes, have started flooding Twitter, and critics are excited, to say the least. The movie, starring Brad Pitt, Leonardo DiCaprio and Margot Robbie, is set in 1969 Hollywood against the backdrop of the Manson murders. DiCaprio plays washed-up TV star [...]

  • AMMAN, JORDAN - MAY 13: Naomi

    After Hosting 'Aladdin' 'Star Wars' and 'Dune' Jordan Ups Production Rebates (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jordan is raising its cash back rebate for film and TV productions from 20% to 25% after recently hosting Disney’s ‘Aladdin,’ “Star Wars IX, The Rise of Skywalker,” and the Denis Villeneuve-directed “Dune” reboot. Concurrently, the kingdom, which provides one of the few stable environments for filmmaking in the Middle East, has reinstated the Jordan Film [...]

  • Benedict Cumberbatch stars in The Current

    Benedict Cumberbatch's 'Current War' Gets Awards-Season Release

    David Glasser’s 101 Studios is positioning the long-shelved and revamped “The Current War,” starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Michael Shannon, for an awards-season release in October. 101 Studios announced Tuesday that the film would open in limited release on Oct. 4, then go wide on the following weekend. The film presents the story of the “war [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content