You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Independent Spirit Awards: 13 Biggest Snubs and Surprises

There may have been a lot of bruised egos and hurt feelings, as well as unexpected champagne-popping, after the Film Independent Spirit Awards were announced on Tuesday morning. It was a list that neglected to mention some of the most acclaimed performances in independent film — including Michelle Williams (“Manchester by the Sea”), Joel Edgerton (“Loving”), Adam Driver (“Paterson”), Sally Field (“Hello, My Name is Doris”), Jeff Bridges (“Hell or High Water”) and Rebecca Hall (“Christine”).

Perhaps the biggest surprise was the swell of support for “American Honey,” the little-seen but critically heralded road trip movie directed by Andrea Arnold. It picked up six Spirit nominations, tying “Moonlight,” Barry Jenkins’ coming-of-age story expected to be an Oscars favorite. “Manchester by the Sea,” directed by Kenneth Lonergan, scored five nods.

It was a good day for A24, the New York indie distributor that landed 19 nominations. Its feature “Moonlight” also took the Robert Altman Award, which precludes its cast — led by Naomie Harris and Mahershala Ali — from picking up individual acting nominations. Other festival favorites, such as “La La Land” and “Nocturnal Animals,” weren’t eligible because their budgets are too high (the limit is $20 million).

The Spirit Awards, selected by small committees made up of critics, directors and producers, among others, don’t necessarily overlap with Oscars voters. But the quirky group, which hosts a party in a tent in Santa Monica on the day before the Academy Awards, has become a crucial stop on the awards season trail, and can influence buzz.

Here are the biggest snubs and surprises.


1. “American Honey” scores big
When Andrea Arnold’s drama about a group of nomad kids on a cross-country road trip debuted at Cannes last May, it took the Croisette by storm. But sadly, it was ignored by audiences last fall, only grossing $650,000 in theaters. The Spirit Awards were designed to offer recognition to small movies that fall under-the-radar, and “American Honey” fits the bill. The film scored in many of the top categories, including best feature, director, female lead (newcomer Sasha Lane) and cinematography.

2. Shia LaBeouf gets downgraded to best supporting actor
However, LaBeouf, who carries most of “American Honey” with Lane, got recognized in the best supporting actor category. An upside to that: it’s less competitive, and the Spirits could actually give him the prize for his gritty turn.

3. “Other People” makes a comeback
The Sundance opening night cancer dramedy racked up deserved nominations for Jesse Plemons (best actor) and Molly Shannon (supporting actress), as well as best director (Chris Kelly) and best first feature.


4. Michelle Williams, “Manchester by the Sea”
Williams has been a Spirits darling, picking up six nominations over her career and winning for 2012’s “My Week With Marilyn.” But somehow, this year’s group failed to nominate her for a wrenching portrait of a mother dealing with tragedy in Kenneth Lonergan’s “Manchester by the Sea.” Regardless, she’s still seen as a shoe-in for her fourth Oscar nomination.

5. Joel Edgerton, “Loving”
While “Loving” received nominations for best directing (Jeff Nichols) and actress (Ruth Negga), the Spirits overlooked Edgerton, who plays one half of a Virginia couple fighting anti-miscegenation laws in 1967. It’s possible that his restrained performance was too subtle.

6. Jeff Bridges, “Hell or High Water”
Many think that Bridges will get his seventh Oscar nomination for his wry take on a Texas ranger, on the brink of retirement but still pursuing a pair bank robbers. Instead, the Spirits’ committee recognized co-star Ben Foster’s showier turn as a hot-tempered crook.

7. Kristen Stewart, “Certain Women”
Her co-star Lily Gladstone received a Spirit nomination for her heartbreaking portrait of a woman who falls in love with her teacher. But the other half of this onscreen couple, played by Kristen Stewart, didn’t factor into the best supporting actress category. What’s even worse: she’s never been nominated for a Spirit Award, despite a resume filled with edgy fare like “Clouds of Sils Maria” and “Still Alice.”

8. Adam Driver, “Paterson”
Driver’s work as a bus driver who writes poetry in his spare time was a favorite out of last year’s Cannes and picked up a Gotham Award nomination.

9. Sally Field, “Hello, My Name is Doris”
Field should have been a contender for playing a 60-something cubicle worker in the middle of a sexual awakening in this comedy directed by Michael Showalter. It’s one of the best performances of her career.

10. Rebecca Hall, “Christine”
The Spirits seem tailor-made to honor performances like Hall’s, who is superb as troubled 1970s local TV reporter Christine Chubbuck.

11. Kate Beckinsale, “Love and Friendship”
As an amoral social climber, Beckinsale dominates Whit Stillman’s delicious adaptation of a Jane Austen novella. She gets all the best lines, but even her perfectly delivered bon mots weren’t enough to get her an invitation to the Spirits Awards.

12. “Weiner”
James Comey strikes again. The documentary about the sexting congressman’s failed campaign for mayor of New York City received strong reviews out of Sundance. But the recent FBI investigation into his emails that implicated Hillary Clinton (and may have cost her the election) could sideline the movie from future awards glory.

13. “Everybody Wants Some”
Richard Linklater’s spiritual sequel to “Dazed and Confused,” which centers on a 1980s college baseball team, tanked at the box office, but at least it earned a best picture nomination from the Gotham Awards, the New York-based independent film group.  The Spirits didn’t like it as much.

More Film

  • Photograph by Svetlana Cvetko

    Blitz Films' Eryl Cochran Talks About Indie Film in Challenging Market

    Eryl Cochran heads production & development at production and financing shingle Blitz Films, where she works alongside company founders, filmmakers Nikolay and Sergey Sarkisov. Blitz, launched in 2018, is carving out a niche in the indie world with an eye for emerging talent. Blitz’s slate includes “Show Me What You Got,” directed by cinematographer Svetlana [...]

  • Echo in the Canyon review

    Film Review: ‘Echo in the Canyon’

    Arguably the most sturdily crafted and entertainingly anecdotal documentary of its kind since Denny Tedesco’s “The Wrecking Crew,” a similarly nostalgic celebration of artists who generously contributed to the soundtrack of the baby boomer generation, Andrew Slater’s “Echo in the Canyon” offers a richly evocative and star-studded overview of the 1960s Laurel Canyon music scene. [...]

  • Alain Berliner To Direct Cannes-Set ‘Second

    ‘Ma Vie en Rose’s’ Alain Berliner Directs Star Cast in ‘Second to Nun’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    Page Three Media and Artemis Productions, which backed “The Danish Girl,” announced in Cannes “Second to Nun,” a new feature from Golden Globe winning director Alain Berliner. Berliner’s decades-ahead-of-its-time “Ma Vie en Rose,” the tale of a young transgender girl with dreams of growing into a mature woman and marrying the boy next door, was [...]

  • Artist Andrew Levitas Tackles Corporate Greed

    Artist Andrew Levitas Tackles Corporate Greed in Johnny Depp Starring 'Minamata'

    Andrew Levitas has carved out a unique place in the art world, having used his considerable skills across multiple creative platforms. A filmmaker, painter, sculptor, producer, writer, actor and photographer, Levitas is also the founder of Metalwork Pictures, a media production company that develops and produces original content, including his 2014 directorial debut, “Lullaby,” as [...]

  • Oliver Laxe

    Cannes: ‘Fire Will Come’s’ Oliver Laxe on Classicism, Avant-Guard, Egos

    CANNES  —    Spain’s Oliver Laxe returns to Cannes for the third time with“Fire Will Come” (O Que Arde), competing in Un Certain Regard— the first time a Galician-language film is selected for Cannes. He has pedigree. His first time round, in 2010, Laxe snagged a Fipresci nod for his Directors’ Fortnight title “You All [...]

  • Gael Garcia Bernal'La Belle Epoque' premiere,

    Gael Garcia Bernal on Cannes Out of Competition Screening ‘Chicuarotes,’ Hope for Mexico

    CANNES  —  There’s a scene right at the beginning of “Chicuarotes,” Gael García Bernal’s second movie as a director, where Cagalera and Moleteco, two teens from the humble San Gregorio Atlapulco district of Mexico City, board a bus in clown’s makeup, and launch into a clumsy comedic sketch. Maybe because it’s delivered in San Gregorio [...]

  • Italy's Notorious Pictures on Buying Spree

    Cannes: Italy's Notorious Pictures on Buying Spree Takes 'Vivarium,' Ups Production (EXCLUSIVE)

    Italian distribution, production, and exhibition company Notorious Pictures is on a buying spree at the Cannes Film Market where they’ve acquired four high-profile titles, including Jesse Eisenberg and Imogen Poots sci-fi-fier “Vivarium,” which world-premiered in Critics’ Week. On the production side the expanding outfit has teamed up with Belgium’s Tarantula Productions on Islamic terrorism thriller [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content