Charlie Kaufman on Indie Filmmaking: ‘I Have to Have One Commercial Success’

Oscar-winning screenwriter Charlie Kaufman (“Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind”) was nothing if not honest with aspiring scribes at the Karlovy Vary fest this week. In the Czech Republic to take home the fest’s president’s award and to screen the surreal stop-motion love story “Anomalisa,” Kaufman challenged would-be film writers to be brutally honest in their work — but also assured them this is no guarantee for success.

Your fan base in Europe, as a percentage, seems quite a bit higher than in the U.S. so this festival must be heartening for you.

It definitely seems like there’s a response in Europe — and also in places like Brazil there seems to be like people who like me. So that’s pretty exciting to know that it’s going across national borders and languages and that sort of stuff.

And a sign that your stories are hitting a universal human nerve that’s not limited to U.S. audiences?

It’s always the thing you imagine when you’re starting out or fantasizing about your career or something — to touch people, individuals. Like someone says, ‘This moved me or was important to me.’

But the process of creating these stories seems particularly torturous for you.

It takes me a long time. I’m not fast. And, yeah, it’s always worrisome. Especially when you’re not fast because the pressure mounts to deliver something. It’s hard. It’s hard for everybody. I think when I wrote “Adaptation,” a lot of writers felt that mirrored their experience so I figured it’s not unique to me.

You’ve said you don’t consciously think about story arcs or plot when you’re working — so it’s more instinctive for you?

Only instinctive, yeah. I don’t want to intellectualize anything. Sometimes I have themes and philosophical things I’m thinking about but they have to have an emotional core to me and there has to be a vulnerability. Like in “Adaptation” where I’m putting myself out there, either literally or figuratively.

And when do you feel in your gut that you’ve cracked the story and know how to tell it?

I knew when I came up with the idea of putting myself in the “Adaptation” script I really liked the idea but I was terrified about the idea at the same time. I didn’t know if it was good. I just thought, once I started thinking that way, I was able to write the script. I hadn’t been able to write the script before that. So I figured, OK, maybe there’s some value in this. As opposed to excruciatingly trudging forward, trying to figure out how to deal with Susan Orlean and such.

Is it an indicator that you’re on the right track when characters begin to argue with you and start going in their own directions?

I definitely find that there’s a point before which I cannot write dialogue and then there’s a point at which I have to start writing dialogue because it actually informs my understanding of the characters. It’s like I’ll come up with a line and it’ll be, ‘Oh, OK, that’s who this person is.’ And they become easier to write and I go back and sort of adjust things.

But you don’t reject the idea that story arcs and characters growing and changing are a part of story architecture?

I’m interested in all those things as a writer but I’m not interested in knowing where it’s going in the beginning because my belief is you can’t in any way know. Otherwise I would be doing, OK, the character has to get to here and here and here.

When I started writing in TV I didn’t study it. But what I realized immediately was that I knew how to do it because I liked watching those shows. So it’s just instinctive at some point. And I feel the same way about movies. I’m informed by the fact that I watched thousands of movies as a kid. Almost to my chagrin I have this stuff built into me. I try to fight it but it’s there.

You’re generally press averse but you’ve been quite available here at Karlovy Vary. Is this part of a campaign to get your next film made?

There’s no campaign. I’m doing press because they asked me to do press. If they had said you can come and you don’t have to do press that would have been my preference. The only time I do press is when I’m promoting something because it’s my obligation.

So there’s no hope this will help revive the fortunes of “Frank or Francis,” the project that you had Jack Black, Steve Carell, Catherine Keener, Cate Blanchett, Nicolas Cage and others committed to?

Good luck. I mean everybody knows about it. I’ve been talking about it for six years now. It’s like whatever at this point. I have no expectation it’s gonna get made and it’s fine.

You employed a Kickstarter campaign to get Anomalisa made — so maybe all your films need to take off is one wealthy Silicon Valley fan.

No, I think I have to have one commercial success in the indie world and I’m off. Anything that I do in this form that makes its money back or a little bit more than break even. That’s all it is. I don’t think anybody cares about anything else when they’re financing movies.

But the idea of “Frank or Francis” certainly seems topical — and so much a part of the social media wilderness we live in, right?

It’s about the internet and internet anger and the way people interact with each other on the internet. It’s about a guy who is a self-proclaimed film critic, this middle-aged guy who lives in a garage with his parents. He’s got all this power just by virtue of the fact that he posts online and there’s this filmmaker whom he is interested in destroying.

And it’s a musical so there’s a lot of singing in it. There’s about 50 songs in it — I wrote the songs, I wrote the lyrics — but it’s about a bunch of stuff and that’s sort of the main story. We’re estimating we could do it for $11 million — but only outside of the United States.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Sybil

    Cannes Competition Movie 'Sibyl' Finds North American Home With Music Box (EXCLUSIVE)

    Music Box Films has acquired the U.S. and Canadian rights to Justine Triet’s darkly comic drama “Sibyl,” which competed at Cannes and had its North American premiere at Toronto in the Special Presentation section. Represented in international markets by mk2, the film follows the ambiguous relationship between Sibyl, a jaded psychotherapist (Virginie Efira, “An Impossible [...]

  • Kent Jones Directs 'Diane'

    Kent Jones to Exit New York Film Festival (EXCLUSIVE)

    In a surprise move, New York Film Festival’s director and selection committee chair of seven years Kent Jones will step down following this year’s 57th edition, which runs Sept. 27-Oct. 13. The departure comes as Jones’ feature filmmaking career is taking off. Issues of potential conflicts of interest have arisen as his work has moved [...]

  • Ava-Mark-Split

    Ava DuVernay, Mark Ruffalo Selected for SAG-AFTRA Foundation Honors

    Ava DuVernay and Mark Ruffalo have been selected by the SAG-AFTRA Foundation for its fourth Annual Patron of the Artists Awards. The awards will be presented on Nov. 7 at the Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts in Beverly Hills. The show benefits the nonprofit SAG-AFTRA Foundation and is not televised. Previous SAG-AFTRA Foundation Patron of the [...]

  • Wes Anderson

    Fox Searchlight Buys Wes Anderson's 'The French Dispatch'

    Fox Searchlight Pictures has acquired worldwide rights to Wes Anderson’s “The French Dispatch,” extending the indie studio’s long collaboration with the filmmaker. The company has released four of Anderson’s films, including his two most recent pictures, “Isle of Dogs” and “The Grand Budapest Hotel.” “The French Dispatch” is described as “a love letter to journalists” [...]

  • If I Were a Rich Man

    Filmax Nabs Alvaro Fernandez Armero’s ‘If I Were a Rich Man’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    SAN SEBASTIAN – Filmax has taken international rights to Álvaro Fernández Armero’s comedy “If I Were a Rich Man.” Produced by Telecinco Cinema, Think Studio and Ciskul, and backed by Mediaset España and Movistar+, “If I Were a Rich Man” is a Spanish remake of Michel Munz and Gerard Bitton’s French comedy “Ah! Si j’étais [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content