You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘Citizen Jane’ Director on Jane Jacobs’ Heroism and Why Robert Moses is Like Trump

“Citizen Jane: Battle for the City”,” Matt Tyrnauer’s gripping new documentary about urban politics, plays out like a mental boxing match between two heavyweight intellectuals.

In one corner is Jane Jacobs, bespectacled and slight of frame, but with a talent for community organizing and a fierce unwillingness to yield to the powers that be. At the other side of the ring is Robert Moses, the towering city planner, who swept away old neighborhoods, erected motorways in their place, and generally treated Manhattan and its surrounding boroughs as his fiefdom. When Moses tried to realize his vision of the Lower Manhattan Expressway, a highway that would have bisected Jacobs’ neighborhood of Greenwich Village, he discovered what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object.

“What brought me to the story was Jacobs,” Tyrnauer told Variety. “She was a bad ass who used the power of the pen and the force of her intellect in a brilliant and heroic way that was way ahead of her time.”

He’s less charitable about her chief adversary, calling Moses, “one of the great villains of the second half of the 20th century.” But, then again, Moses’ reputation has been badly tarnished since Robert Caro published his magisterial biography, “The Power Broker,” in 1974, revealing that the urban planner had troubling racial views and was indifferent to the social upheaval he caused by placing his city projects in thriving communities. Tyrnauer sees parallels between Moses’ imperious nature and the public persona of Donald Trump, the real-estate-baron-turned-Republican-presidential nominee.

“He is similar to Moses in that he has this authoritarian, racist, white guy knows best thing,” said Tyrnauer.

If Moses’ actions are widely known and documented, then perhaps it is time for a new generation to familiarize itself with Jacobs’ legacy. She was sharply critical of the urban renewal movement in her work for Architectural Forum and in her 1961 book, “The Death and Life of Great American Cities,” arguing that modernist planning was responsible for the decline of major metropolises. Housing projects of the sort that social planners of the day advocated for were overly concentrated and lacked natural gathering places, allowing crime to fester, she maintained. She also believe in the power of creating social movements as a means of combating bureaucracies that could be indifferent to the people on the streets.

“We want to bring her ideas to a mass audience in a way that can inspire a few more Jane Jacobses,” said Tyrnauer.

Jacobs ultimately prevailed and the Lower Manhattan Expressway was never constructed, preserving the original character of SoHo and Little Italy. With his planned highway shelved, chinks began appearing in Moses’ armor and he would eventually fall from power towards the end of the 1960s. But the struggle between their views still plays out in the construction of cities in China and other rapidly urbanizing nations.

“Jacobs won on points,” said Tyrnauer. “She absolutely changed the thinking and the ethos of the urban planning movement and her ideas infiltrated academia. Moses won in the real world… His vision of urbanization, of collusion between moneyed interests and government, has come back with a vengeance.”

“Citizen Jane: Battle for the City”” will premiere today at the Toronto Film Festival, where it is looking for distribution. It is Tyrnauer’s second film following “Valentino: The Last Emperor,” a profile of fashion designer Valentino Garavani on the cusp of retirement, that was highly acclaimed when it debuted in 2009.

Before venturing into directing, Tyrnauer was best known for his work for Vanity Fair, where he specialized in stories of classic Hollywood. That will be the setting of his next project “Scotty,” which will look at Scotty Bowers, who allegedly helped arrange gay encounters for movie stars in the pre-Stonewall era.

“It’s one of the great untold stories of Hollywood,” said Tyrnauer. “It’s part of its secret history.”

More Film

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Tops International

    'Curse of La Llorona' Tops International Box Office With $30 Million

    Warner Bros. and New Line’s “The Curse of La Llorona” led the way at the international box office, summoning $30 million when it opened in 71 foreign markets. The supernatural thriller collected $26.5 million in North America for a global start of $56.5 million. “La Llorona,” based on the Mexican folklore about the Weeping Woman, [...]

  • Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona'

    Box Office: 'Curse of La Llorona' Wins Worst Easter Weekend in Over a Decade

    Warner Bros. and New Line’s “The Curse of La Llorona” ascended to the top of domestic box office charts, conjuring $26.5 million when it opened in 3,372 North American theaters. “La Llorona” is the latest horror movie to outperform expectations, further cementing the genre as one of the most reliable box office draws. Even so, [...]

  • FX's 'Snowfall' Panel TCA Winter Press

    John Singleton Hospitalized After Suffering Stroke

    UPDATED with statements from John Singleton’s family and FX Networks John Singleton, the Oscar nominated director and writer of “Boyz N’ the Hood,” has suffered a stroke. Sources confirm to Variety that Singleton checked himself into the hospital earlier this week after experiencing pain in his leg. The stroke has been characterized by doctors as [...]

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Leads Slow

    'Curse of La Llorona' Leads Slow Easter Weekend at the Box Office

    New Line’s horror pic “The Curse of La Llorona” will summon a solid $25 million debut at the domestic box office, leading a quiet Easter weekend before Marvel’s “Avengers: Endgame” hits theaters on April 26. The James Wan-produced “La Llorona,” playing in 3,372 theaters, was a hit with hispanic audiences, who accounted for nearly 50% [...]

  • Jim Jarmusch in 'Carmine Street Guitars'

    Film Review: 'Carmine Street Guitars'

    “Carmine Street Guitars” is a one-of-a-kind documentary that exudes a gentle, homespun magic. It’s a no-fuss, 80-minute-long portrait of Rick Kelly, who builds and sells custom guitars out of a modest storefront on Carmine Street in New York’s Greenwich Village, and the film touches on obsessions that have been popping up, like fragrant weeds, in [...]

  • Missing Link Laika Studios

    ‘Missing Link’ Again Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by the TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Annapurna Pictures claims the top spot in spending for the second week in a row with “Missing Link.” Ads placed for the animated film had an estimated media value of $5.91 million through Sunday for [...]

  • Little Woods

    Film Review: 'Little Woods'

    So much of the recent political debate has focused on the United States’ southern border, and on the threat of illegal drugs and criminals filtering up through Mexico. But what of the north, where Americans traffic opiates and prescription pills from Canada across a border that runs nearly three times as long? “Little Woods” opens [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content