×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why Not a Documentary for Best Picture?

Ava DuVernay's masterful '13th,' an examination of mass incarceration, deserves consideration for the top award

Ava DuVernay’s “Selma” follow- up, “13th,” opened the New York Film Festival on Sept. 30 and immediately situated itself as one of the year’s best films. Why, then, is it a foregone conclusion that we won’t be talking about it in terms of best picture?

No documentary has ever received a nomination for Hollywood’s top prize, despite true landmarks of the form — like “Shoah” and “Hoop Dreams” (the latter controversially snubbed in the doc category as well) — making strong cases.

In 2013 and 2015, a pair of documentaries by Joshua Oppenheimer — “The Act of Killing” and “The Look of Silence” — topped many critical assessments of the years’ best cinema, but nobody expected noms for best picture. In 2005, “March of the Penguins” became a cultural event that did bang-up box office, but it couldn’t break out of the documentary feature category at the Oscars.

And talk about cultural events: A year earlier, with a Palme d’Or from Cannes in hand, Michael Moore and Harvey Weinstein opted out of submitting “Fahrenheit 9/11” in the documentary feature race, in order to focus on a broader campaign that included a pitch for best picture. They had plenty of money to burn, as the film became (and remains) the highest-grossing documentary of all time. But best pic? No dice.

“Startup.com” (2001), “Bowling for Columbine” (2002), “Touching the Void” (2004), “March of the Penguins,” “Lake of Fire” (2007), “Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father” (2008), “The Cove” (2009), “Exit Through the Gift Shop” (2010), “The Queen of Versailles” (2012), “The Overnighters” (2014), and “Amy” (2015) were, personally speaking, among the very best films of their respective years. But that’s a singular opinion, not a collective one.

And that gets to the heart of the issue. It’s difficult to convince a massive voting body like the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to agree that a documentary deserves to be up for the industry’s top honor, when these films can so easily be ghettoized in their own category. It happens with foreign and animated films all the time.

Circling back to “13th,” the film — set for release Oct. 7 by Netflix — isn’t just a staggering indictment of systemic racism. It’s also an expert piece of cinema. The way DuVernay moves her camera and frames her subjects, the flashes of the word “criminal” on the screen every time it’s uttered (a device positing the label as a derogatory dog whistle), the way she infuses music to help tell the story of mass incarceration in America — it’s not just talking-head video journalism on display. It’s a visual artist telling a story, and doing so with aplomb.

So why, then, should we dismiss it as a best picture player on the basis of form? Here is a movie that contextualizes a complex status quo — the vast work-state provided for by loophole language in the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution — and uses it as a springboard into probing the American psyche. It doesn’t play sides in interrogating the political history of imprisonment in this country, nor the use of crime as a political football, and it presents a platform for substantive discussion about racism and racial bias.

Diversity is sure to be a buzzword all season long. “The Birth of a Nation,” “Fences,” “Hidden Figures,” and “Moonlight” will likely be singled out as opportunities for Academy members to course-correct after two years of #OscarsSoWhite. But DuVernay’s contribution provokes in exciting and vital ways, too. It deserves to be in the mix.

More Film

  • Franco Zeffirelli Remembered

    Franco Zeffirelli: An Artist and a Paradox

    When popular artists pass on, it can often be a surprise to learn just how old they were. But the news of Franco Zeffirelli’s death, at 96, inspired a major double take. The extravagant Italian maestro of theater, opera and film lived to a vibrant old age. Yet for many of us, the name Zeffirelli [...]

  • Evan Tanner, Professional mixed martial arts

    UFC Fighter Evan Tanner Biopic ‘The Power of 1’ in the Works (EXCLUSIVE)

    Producers Christopher Scheimann and Olcun Tan have partnered with top sports director Bobby Razak on “The Power of 1,” a feature biopic of UFC fighter Evan Tanner. Co-written by Scheimann and Razak, the movie is slated to go into pre-production toward the end of this year, with principal photography planned for early next year. Tanner, [...]

  • The Grove Introduces Drive-In Rooftop Movie

    The Grove Introduces Drive-In Rooftop Movie Theater Level 8

    The Grove is ringing in summer with a new rooftop movie theater. The popular Los Angeles shopping mall, located between Fairfax and La Brea, announced today the launch of their new cinema experience titled Level 8 Drive-in, which will kick off with a screening of “Grease” on June 26 and will run through September. Inspired [...]

  • China, Shanghai Exhibition Centre, Soviet-style Facade

    Shanghai: China Market 'Has Always Been a Turbulent One,' Says Infotainment Chief (EXCLUSIVE)

    Movie sales and distribution company Infotainment China comes to the Shanghai International Film Festival optimistic about Chinese audience trends, but gloomy about current business conditions. “The market is bad and industry players are very pessimistic. I just hope it doesn’t get worse,” said Infotainment CEO Cindy Lin, though she noted that such periods of trouble [...]

  • Billy Eichner Power of Pride Variety

    Billy Eichner on the Homophobia He Still Sees in Comedy and Hollywood

    On “Billy on the Street,” Billy Eichner has made a name for himself running up and down Manhattan’s sidewalks, ambushing clueless New Yorkers and interrogating them about pop culture. A brash physical comedian, Eichner has no qualms about asking perfect strangers embarrassing questions, hectoring pedestrians about their willingness to have a threesome with Jon Hamm [...]

  • State of Pride Full

    How Hollywood Is (and Isn't) Getting Better at LGBTQ Inclusion

    Brandon Flynn, one of the breakout actors from Netflix’s “13 Reasons Why,” has spent the last two years fielding questions about his personal life. In 2017, he wrote a passionate post on Instagram, advocating for an Australian vote that allowed for same-sex marriage. Soon enough, news sites such as HuffPost and E! News were reporting [...]

  • Prince Mohammed bin Salman Abdulaziz al

    Saudi Crown Prince Should Be Investigated Over Khashoggi Killing, U.N. Report Says

    Mohammed bin Salman, the crown prince of Saudi Arabia, should be investigated in connection with the killing of Jamal Khashoggi because of “credible evidence” that the prince is among those liable for the dissident journalist’s death, a United Nations report said Wednesday. While no “smoking gun” has yet been found that directly incriminates the prince [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content