Conservative Group, Filmmakers at Odds Over Movie Ratings in France

For decades, France has given the world iconic films that deal frankly with sexual themes: “And God Created Woman,” “Belle de Jour,” “Betty Blue” and “Blue Is the Warmest Color.” But as in more puritanical nations, like the U.S., France is seeing the rise of socially conservative groups that are challenging the country’s traditionally permissive view on sex in movies, leading to an uproar in the film community while the government explores revamping its film ratings system.

Activist group Promouvoir, led by Andre Bonnet, who is affiliated with far-right politicians, has clashed repeatedly with France’s classification board, a government body regulated by the National Film Board (CNC). The board comprises guild representatives, parents, psychologists and various organizations dedicated to protecting families and children. It recommends certificates for films in four categories: all audiences; -12, which prohibits a film to viewers under 12 years of age; -16; and -18.

Promouvoir has won several battles with the board over the years: Virginie Despentes and Coralie Trinh Thi’s “Baise-moi,” Larry Clark and Edward Lachman’s “Ken Park,” Lars von Trier’s “Nymphomaniac: Volume 2” and Gaspar Noe’s “Love” at first had been given -16 certificates from the board, only to be reclassified as -18 after several challenges from the conservative group.

Promouvoir also opened the door for reclassification of Abdellatif Kechiche’s 2013 Palme d’Or winning “Blue Is the Warmest Color,” initially rated -12, more than two years after its original release, due to “realistic sex scenes.” The film’s operating visa also has been suspended, meaning that its distribution in secondary markets is in limbo.

The group’s latest target is Eva Husson’s “Bang Gang (A Modern Love Story),” a steamy coming-of-age tale about suburban youths who experiment with sex, also rated -12 by the classification board.

“We’re seeing the blossoming of an ultra-conservative movement that threatens to abolish rights and liberties we have known for the last 50 years,” says Husson.

Behind the battle over ratings lies the threat of ruining a film’s commercial potential. A -16 rating restricts a film’s financial options in France, and a -18 is akin to a death sentence. While films in the latter category are allowed in theaters, exhibitors often opt out of showing them, not only because of the limited audience, but also due to a higher tax on tickets for such films — more than 16% instead of less than 11% for all other films.

The ramifications also translate to TV. Movies with a -16 are not allowed on prime-time TV, but can air after 10:30 p.m., while those with -18 ratings are banned except on pay TV and can show only after midnight — a slot usually dedicated to pornographic films.

While some producers and filmmakers are playing it safe so as not to draw the attention of conservative groups, others blame the French classification system, which offers no clear content guidelines.

Audrey Azoulay, who last month took over as France’s culture minister, has vowed to reform the local ratings system and strengthen its board, an issue initiated by her predecessor, Fluer Pellerin.

Azoulay says she is in favor of overturning a decree authored by the French State Council dating back to 2001 which states that films that show non-simulated sex automatically must be classified -18. Instead, the minister says she favors the -18 rating for movies that contain scenes of sex (simulated or not) or great violence “without any aesthetic justification,” and that could “disturb the sensibility of minors or lead to trivializing violence.”

The film community has applauded Azoulay’s support.

Filmmakers see the calls for censorship as an attack on freedom. Noe says his family fled a dictatorship in Argentina to come to France — and he loves the fact that movies like Martin Scorsese’s “Taxi Driver,” Liliana Cavani’s “The Night Porter” and John Boorman’s “Deliverance” could air on primetime with a simple warning. “It seems that freedom of expression is now being restricted in films and TV like (in other countries),” Noe says. “France has always been admired for its great freedom of expression. We shouldn’t take it lightly.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Rules Don't Apply

    Warren Beatty and Arnon Milchan Settle Suit Over 'Rules Don't Apply' Flop

    Arnon Milchan and Warren Beatty have settled their two-year legal battle over the disastrous release of “Rules Don’t Apply,” Beatty’s period drama about Howard Hughes. Milchan’s attorneys have filed a notice with the court dismissing his suit against Beatty. Terms of the settlement were not disclosed. Milchan’s company, New Regency, sued Beatty and other investors [...]

  • Brazil's President Jair Bolsonaro attends a

    Bolsonaro LGBTQI Outburst, Subsidy Freeze, Stirs Outrage

    Ramping up the drive into censorship in Brazil, its Minister of Citizenship, Omar Terra, has suspended a call for applications for governmental TV funding – until new criteria are established for its application. The country’s secretary for culture, Henrique Pires, who reports to Terra, has resigned in protest of the incentive freeze. The suspension, for [...]

  • Adam Brody'Ready or Not' film premiere,

    Adam Brody to Executive Produce, Star in 'The Kid Detective'

    “Ready or Not’s” Adam Brody has signed on to star in “The Kid Detective.” Sophie Nelisse will co-star in the dramedy from writer-director Evan Morgan. Brody will star as a once-celebrated kid detective, now 31, who continues to solve the same trivial mysteries between hangovers and bouts of self-pity until a 16-year-old client (Nelisse) brings [...]

  • Alita: Battle Angel VFX

    How Previsualization Helps Create Pitches for Projects Like 'Alita: Battle Angel'

    Filmmakers are increasingly using previsualization, a now-standard technique for planning highly technical shots and sequences, as a tool for pitching a project to production companies, investors and studio executives — before a single full scene has actually been shot. More creatives are relying on the technique, dubbed “pitchvis,” to fashion a compelling and engaging presentation [...]

  • Theo Von arrives at the Global

    Chris Pratt's 'Ghost Draft' Adds Comedian Theo Von

    Comedian Theo Von has boarded the sci-fi thriller “Ghost Draft” starring Chris Pratt. “Lego Batman” filmmaker Chris McKay is directing Skydance and Paramount’s upcoming film, which stars “Handmaid’s Tale” star Yvonne Strahovski alongside Pratt. J.K. Simmons and “GLOW’s” Betty Gilpin are also in talks to join the pic. Written by Zach Dean and Bill Dubuque, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content