Academy’s Vocal Critics Fail to Advance in Board of Governors Elections

It’s been a turbulent year at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences, as an ambitious plan to diversify its ranks led to internal backlash. Some of the most vocal critics have accused the Board of Governors of bowing to outside political pressure when it announced plans in January to double minority and female membership by 2020. Many have also resisted the Academy’s plan, announced simultaneously, to transfer some older members who are no longer active in the business to non-voting status.

The controversy spilled into this year’s board elections, as a handful of members campaigned on a pledge to overturn the board’s actions. But the results of the first round of voting were announced to members on Thursday night, and it appears the internal revolt has mostly fizzled out.

Only one critic of the Board — Bruce Feldman, in the Academy’s public relations branch — finished among the top four contenders in his or her branch, earning advancement to the final round of voting. William Goldstein, who was among the most outspoken opponents, did not advance in the music branch.

“A lot of the people who ran did not address these issues at all,” Feldman said. “They’re running on the old-fashioned, I’m-a-good-guy-vote-for-me.”

Laura Karpman, a candidate in the music branch, did take a firm stand in support of the Academy’s diversity initiative. She advanced to the final round of voting.

“I think what the Academy is trying to do is be in a leadership position, which is exactly the right place for the Academy to be,” she said. “Sometimes it hurts. Sometimes you get backlash. Sometimes people become afraid. But good leadership is about pushing those boundaries.”

Members in each of the 17 branches will now elect a member from among the finalists. Steven Spielberg is among the four candidates in the directors’ branch. Ed Begley Jr., is running for re-election in the acting branch against Laura Dern, Lou Diamond Phillips and Edward James Olmos. The winners will be announced in mid-July.

“It’s a lot of the same old people who have been around,” said Gary Shapiro, a critic of the board who ran in the public relations branch but was not among the finalists. “I think the Academy has learned a bit from the reaction they got.”

Many of the critics have said they support diversity, but were disturbed at the idea that members could be forced into “emeritus” status simply because they haven’t worked in a while. Some were also offended that it appeared the Academy seemed to be blaming its older members — who are disproportionately white and male — for the lack of non-white nominees.

“Saying the membership is racist — it’s insulting for one thing,” said Stuart Gordon, who ran in the directors branch but was not among the finalists. “When we were made members, it was for life. Now to get into an inquisition — to say ‘prove to me you’ve been working’ — I don’t think we have to. To have to go through that is insulting.”

In a statement, Academy CEO Dawn Hudson defended the board’s handling of the issue.

“We’ve engaged our members in this process – along with other wide-ranging inclusion initiatives – to make sure the Academy remains as relevant in the future of our community as it has been for the past 88 years,” Hudson said.

Since the emeritus plan was first announced, the Academy has revised its criteria and it now appears that very few members will be affected — not enough to affect the overall diversity of the organization. “It’s a handful (of people),” said Robin Swicord, a board member in the writers branch, who is up for re-election.

If members are still at all connected to the industry, chances are their status is secure. “If they have been selling real estate for the last 30 years,” Swicord said, “they won’t be kicked out of the Academy but they’ll be moved to this different status.”

The Academy branches are working on lists of members who will be moved to non-voting status, and are expected to notify those members sometime this summer.

More Film

  • 'Tomb Raider' Star Simon Yam in

    'Tomb Raider' Star Simon Yam in Hospital After Stabbing

    Hugely popular Hong Kong actor, Simon Yam was stabbed while on stage Saturday at a presentation in Zhongshan, Guangdong province in southern China. He is in hospital recovering. The incident happened at the opening of a branch of the Beijing Easyhome building materials company, where Yam was a guest. A man was seen rushing on [...]

  • Brazilian President Jair Bolosnaro attends the

    Bolsonaro Threatens Brazil’s Central Film Fund with Censorship or Closure

    In typical shoot-from-the-hip remarks, Brazil’s far-right president Jair Bolsonaro has declared that Ancine, Brazil’s powerful state-backed federal film agency, should accept “filters”or face closure. “If it can’t have a filter, we’ll close Ancine, or privatize it,” Bolsonaro added, attacking Ancine, which plows some $300 million a year into Brazil’s film and TV industries, for supporting [...]


    Director Sara Gouveia on ‘Looking At Resilience Through Art’

    DURBAN–The Mapiko dance of Mozambique’s indigenous Makonde people was long used as a tool for social commentary. But during the colonial era it became an act of political resistance, prompting the Portuguese to stamp it out during Mozambique’s 10-year war for independence. Decades later, the art has been revived as a celebration of freedom. For [...]

  • Don Edkins

    Documentary Filmmaker Don Edkins on ‘Creating an African Voice’ 

    DURBAN–For the 10th Durban FilmMart (DFM), the industry program of the Durban Intl. Film Festival, a new strand was created to look at the unique challenges and opportunities facing documentary filmmakers in Africa. The two-day program, Durban Does Docs, offers a series of conversations, seminars and workshops with an intensive focus on the aesthetics, funding, distribution [...]

  • A Faithful Man

    Film Review: 'A Faithful Man'

    French actor Louis Garrel has been married twice, first to Iranian talent Golshifteh Farahani, and now to model-cum-actress Laetitia Casta. He has also directed two features, the first a free-wheeling love-triangle comedy called “Two Friends” in which Garrel plays the cad who comes between his best friend and the object of his obsession (played by [...]

  • LGBTQ Film Festival Outfest Opens With

    LGBTQ Film Festival Outfest Opens With Documentary About Gay Porn Shops Circus of Books

    Granted, the red carpet at the opening night of Outfest in DTLA may not have been the most star-studded but it was without a doubt the most diverse, inclusive and, yes, fabulous. “I’ve never been here before,” admitted “RuPaul’s Drag Race” vet Trixie Mattel, who stars in the documentary “Moving Parts.” “It’s supposed to be [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Russ Tamblyn's Career Had Legs After Childhood

    With an acting career that spans work for Cecil B. DeMille and Joseph Losey to Quentin Tarantino and David Lynch, Russ Tamblyn’s creativity and longevity is proof that there’s life after child stardom. In Tamblyn’s case, there’s also been a bounty of juicy film and TV roles long after his legendary legs no longer kicked [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content