Guilds Awards’ Rare Split Results Keep Oscar Race Wide Open

Only four times have the industry's top three guilds split three different ways.

For the first time in more than a decade, three of the industry’s major guilds — the producers, directors and screen actors — have split entirely different ways in handing out their top prize, keeping the awards season wide open as it heads into the final stretch.

To recap, “The Big Short” won the PGA honor — using the same kind of preferential ballot among its membership of more than 7,000 as Academy voters will use for the Oscars. “Spotlight” took home the SAG ensemble trophy from a group totaling more than 160,000. And “The Revenant” claimed the DGA prize from 16,000-plus voters.

Historically speaking, the DGA has been the top Oscar barometer. Only 14 times in 67 years has its awardee not seen his or her movie go on to win best picture, including a number of instances when the guild didn’t correctly predict the Oscar-winning director. The PGA has a smaller sample of 27 years to pull from, but only seven times has that group’s decision not presaged the Oscar vote. SAG sports an even smaller sampling of 20 years, with the ensemble winner claiming best picture gold just 10 times.

You can get lost in the statistical history and miss a lot of nuance. For instance, the PGA’s 2001 merger with the American Assn. of Producers drastically altered its makeup (to say nothing of the guild’s adoption of the preferential ballot in tandem with the Academy’s in 2010). The annual SAG Nominating Committee, meanwhile, is a revolving door of 2,000 or so members randomly chosen anew each season — not exactly a model of consistency.

Popular on Variety

It’s also instructive to take a look at the other three years the industry was this divided. The first instance came in the 2000 season, when “Gladiator” won the PGA, “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon” snagged the DGA and “Traffic” claimed the SAG ensemble honor. “Gladiator” ultimately won the best picture Oscar, as well as actor and a trio of craft categories. “Traffic” won for director, as well as supporting actor, adapted screenplay and film editing. “Crouching Tiger” won three crafts categories and the foreign-language prize.

It happened again the next year, with “Moulin Rouge!” winning the PGA, “A Beautiful Mind” winning the DGA and “Gosford Park” winning SAG ensemble. “A Beautiful Mind” ultimately won best picture, director, supporting actress and adapted screenplay. “Moulin Rouge!” won a pair of craft categories and “Gosford Park” won original screenplay.

Three years later, “Million Dollar Baby” was a wild card, thrust into the season at the 11th hour and fast becoming the emotional favorite. “The Aviator” won the PGA before going on to claim four Oscars in the craft categories and another for supporting actress. SAG awarded “Sideways,” which managed only an adapted screenplay Oscar (in the wake of star Paul Giamatti’s unexpected exclusion from the actor category) — and “Million Dollar Baby,” which had taken the DGA honor, walked away with Oscars for best picture, director, actress and supporting actor.

In the first instance, the PGA winner (prior to the org’s merger with the AAP) took the best picture Oscar. In the other two, the DGA was the best picture indicator. For the record, there have been only two instances in which a film has won the SAG ensemble prize but neither the PGA nor DGA award and still managed to pull off a best picture victory: “Shakespeare in Love” in 1998 and “Crash” in 2005.

And lest we be tempted to look to the British Academy’s history for guidance — where “The Revenant” triumphed this year — remember that only since 2012 has it used the same paradigm for selecting nominations and winners as the American Academy (i.e., the various branches determine nominees and the entire membership determines winners). And just last year, the Brits opted for “Boyhood” over eventual Oscar victor “Birdman.”

Ultimately, whatever happens, the winners will not be the story of this year’s Oscar season. Rather, the huge outcry over the lack of diversity among the nominations, the Academy’s heavily criticized rush to correct representation in its membership and various calls to boycott the awards ceremony itself will forever be the legacy of Oscars 2016.

In the face of that, will anyone really care how the math added up?

More Film

  • Spirited Away

    Netflix to Carry Iconic Studio Ghibli Animated Films

    The iconic animated features of Japan’s Studio Ghibli will be available on Netflix from February. The move is a further change of position for the studio which has repeatedly resisted the idea that its beloved cartoons would be released on digital platforms. Netflix, sales agent Wild Bunch, and Studio Ghibli, which counts Hayao Miyazaki as [...]

  • Outstanding Performance by a Cast in

    SAG Awards 2020: 'Parasite' Makes History; 'The Crown,' 'Mrs. Maisel' Earn Top TV Honors

    Neon’s “Parasite” won best motion picture cast at the 26th Screen Actors Guild Awards on Sunday, becoming the first foreign language film to pick up the top prize. Netflix’s “The Crown” was named best TV drama and Amazon’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” earned the prize for best TV comedy in a strong showing for streaming [...]

  • Cho Yeo-jeong, Choi Woo-shik, Lee Jeong-eun,

    SAG Awards 2020: The Biggest Snubs and Surprises

    The Screen Actors Guild Awards are always the first peer group ceremony of the new year, giving those who make films and television series the chance to celebrate each other. Going into the 26th annual ceremony, which took place Jan. 19, the nominees were a mix of industry veterans and beloved favorite and some newer-comers, [...]

  • HAF logo

    Hong Kong Project Market HAF Lines up Cream of Asia for 2020 Edition

    Lin Cheng-sheng (“Betlnut Beauty”), Giddens Ko (“You Are The Apple of My Eye”), Pang Ho-cheung (“Love in a Puff”) and Yeo Siew-hua (“A Land Imagined”) are among the big name Asian directors lining up to participate in the 18th edition of the Hong Kong Asia Film Financing Forum. The powerhouse project market will run for [...]

  • Jennifer Aniston

    SAG Awards: The Complete Winners List

    Korean thriller “Parasite” made history at the 26th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards on Sunday, becoming the first foreign-language film to win best motion picture cast. In another streaming stride, Netflix’s “The Crown” nabbed best TV drama and Amazon’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” took home best TV comedy. In a repeat of the Golden Globes, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content