×

Oscar Voting 101: Academy Secrets and Confusion Explained

In Hollywood, a reputation is hard to shake. The #OscarsSoWhite protests of the past two years have been beneficial, raising the consciousness of the studios and agencies in Hollywood. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences is trying to help make changes as well — but is simultaneously trying to shake the perception that it was the source of the problem.

Oscar voting runs Jan. 5-13, and nominations will be announced Jan. 24. Some AMPAS choices (e.g., surprises and omissions) will undoubtedly be criticized in the coming months, which is fine, but criticism should be based on fact. So here are a few reminders:

Oscars have a secret ballot.
When “Spotlight” wins best picture or Idris Elba does not get an acting nomination, there are no tallies revealed. So the public assumes these were the unanimous choices of every Oscar voter. In many cases, the votes were probably very close, but we’ll never know. Some critics groups actually do sit in a room together when voting, but the Academy doesn’t. The org consists of 7,000 individuals in 17 branches (directors, cinematographers, etc.) and each branch makes its own nominations. Many pundits talk about how “they” voted and who “they” ignored, without acknowledging that people and films may have come in sixth or seventh. “Snub” is awards-season shorthand for “didn’t get enough votes,” but it doesn’t mean that nobody voted for it. In other words, “Straight Outta Compton” and Ridley Scott probably got more votes than we realized.

The Academy doesn’t make greenlight decisions.
Yes, most studio heads are in the Academy. But the majority of members are workers in the trenches. The execs (and crucially, film financiers) make decisions about what film will get made based on past successes (mistakenly believing that these are “safe” choices). Last year, out of 305 eligible films, only a handful came from women and/or minority filmmakers. So when Oscar voters didn’t nominate a lot of diverse films, it could be because there were not enough choices.

Don’t focus too much on acting categories.
This year, there will certainly be some black actors nominated for their knockout work. But don’t think the industry has solved its diversity/inclusion problem. There are still not enough films from blacks behind the camera, as well as Latino/Hispanic filmmakers, Asians, women, Muslims, people with disabilities, LGBT individuals, etc. And no, this is not about quotas or affirmative action. When people aim for industry diversity, they’re talking about more opportunities for the under-represented, and expanding executives’ mindset to hire someone not exactly like them.

White and 62 doesn’t mean senile.
Academy membership has traditionally been for people with lots of experience — and the harsh reality of the industry is that this often means white men. Ever since the L.A. Times’ survey of February 2012, pundits have cited Academy demographics as alleged proof of incompetence or out-of-touch-ness. The assumption was that if you’re over 60 and white, you’re a dopey bigot with boring taste. But Tom Hanks, James Cameron, George Miller, Steven Spielberg, Ian McKellen and Jeff Bridges (aka The Dude), to name just a few, are over 60, but no one would think to describe them as doddering. Academy demographics are expanding, which is a good thing. Inclusion means broadening the demographics — it also means respecting the ones who are already there.

The film industry has a lot of work to do.
The TV and music industries are further along, but there is still room for improvement. With films, the protests were a wakeup call to the industry, which is great. Knock wood, we are already seeing signs of progress. But as a final reminder: AMPAS is a reflection of film industry imbalance, not the cause of it.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Stephan Komandarev on Sarajevo Player ‘Rounds’

    Director Stephan Komandarev on Sarajevo Player ‘Rounds’ and His Bulgarian Trilogy

    Bulgarian director Stephan Komandarev earned critical acclaim for his 2017 feature “Directions,” which was selected for Cannes’ Un Certain Regard sidebar. The first installment in a planned trilogy about the social inequality and moral ills plaguing both Bulgaria and Europe at large, the film followed six cab drivers over the course of 24 hours as [...]

  • Meryl Streep Best Movie Lines

    HBO Max Lands Steven Soderbergh's Next Film Starring Meryl Streep

    HBO Max has picked up Steven Soderbergh’s next film, the comedy “Let Them All Talk” starring Meryl Streep. Joining Streep in the ensemble cast are Candice Bergen, Dianne Wiest, Lucas Hedges and Gemma Chan. The screenplay was written by short story author and MacArthur Fellow recipient Deborah Eisenberg. It’s the story of a celebrated author [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen FYSEE Opening Night with

    Bruce Springsteen Drops Introspective Trailer for 'Western Stars' Film

    While initial reports about Bruce Springsteen’s forthcoming documentary around his recent “Western Stars” album said that it would essentially be a concert film, the first trailer for it, which dropped today, suggests it’s going to be a more introspective outing, more in line with his autobiographical performances at “Springsteen on Broadway” in 2017 and 2018, [...]

  • Phyllis Nagy

    Writers Guild Presidential Candidate Phyllis Nagy Blasts Strategy on Agencies

    Phyllis Nagy, who is challenging Writers Guild of America West’s president David Goodman, has warned of dire consequences from the current stalemate between the WGA and Hollywood agents. Nagy, who announced her candidacy on July 22 as the head of Writers for Negotiation, is running on a platform that the WGA needs to get back to [...]

  • Chris Pine to Play Nixon Attorney

    Chris Pine to Play Nixon Lawyer John Dean in Amazon Studios Feature Pitch (EXCLUSIVE)

    Amazon Studios has nabbed a feature pitch with “Wonder Woman” star Chris Pine attached to play John Dean, a pivotal figure in the Watergate scandal. The film will follow the life and political saga of Dean, who served as White House counsel for President Richard Nixon from July 1970 through April 1973. Amazon bought the [...]

  • 'Bombay Rose,' Venice Premiere, Debuts Trailer

    'Bombay Rose,' Venice Film Festival Premiere, Debuts Trailer (EXCLUSIVE)

    Variety has been given exclusive access to the trailer for animated film “Bombay Rose,” which will have its world premiere opening Venice Critics’ Week on Aug. 28. The film, written and directed by Gitanjali Rao, will also play in the Contemporary World Cinema strand at the Toronto Film Festival on Sept. 7. “Bombay Rose” is [...]

  • Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu speaks during a

    Alejandro G. Inarritu on the Need to Preserve Poetry in Cinema

    Alejandro G. Iñárritu is urging the film industry to guard against the influence of television storytelling in cinema, a looming crisis he said could strip film of the beauty and poetry that make it a unique artistic form of expression. Attending the Sarajevo Film Festival to receive the Honorary Heart of Sarajevo award, the Oscar-winning [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content