×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Kanye West Tricked Fans Into Subscribing to Tidal, Lawsuit Claims

Did Kanye West deceive fans about the release of his latest album to boost Tidal’s numbers? That’s exactly what a new class-action lawsuit alleges.

First, a quick recap: Kanye West released his long-awaited new album “The Life of Pabloexclusively on Tidal in February. At first, the release was meant to be a limited exclusive, but a few days later, West doubled down on Tidal, proclaiming that the album would “never ever be on Apple,” and permanently exclusive to Tidal.

However, in this instance, “never ever” only lasted a little over a month. On April 1st, “The Life of Pablo” did show up on Apple Music, as well as on Spotify and Google Play Music. That was deception, according to the lawsuit against West, Tidal owner Jay-Z and Tidal itself filed in San Francisco Monday. The lawsuit was filed by Edelson PC on behalf of a single California consumer, but seeks class-action status.

“By the time Mr. West changed course and broadly released ‘The Life of Pablo,’ the deceptive marketing ploy had served its purpose: Tidal’s subscriber numbers had tripled, streaming numbers were through the roof, and Tidal had collected the personal information, credit card numbers, and social media information of millions of deceived consumers,”  the lawsuit alleges.

The lawsuit further claims that West and Tidal never really intended for the album to be an exclusive. Instead, they just wanted to boost Tidal’s subscriber numbers — which indeed did get a big bump from the release. Tidal may have signed up as many as two million new subscribers thanks to the album, claims the lawsuit, arguing that this could have added as much as $84 million to Tidal’s valuation.

The lawsuit now aims to not only reimburse users for any subscription fees they may have paid as a result of West’s album release, but also change its course on one key aspect of its business: Free trials aren’t supposed to automatically convert into paid subscriptions anymore.

The lawsuit only demands this change for any trials started as a result of the “TLOP” promotion, but it points to a bigger issue: Most subscription services use what’s commonly called a “negative option” to convert free trials into paying customers.

Users have to enter their credit card number at the beginning of a trial, and then cancel before the trial period is over to not get charged for the next month. Consumers understandably don’t like this, but it’s been a very effective way to amass subscribers. In fact, insiders have pointed to the absence of a negative renewal option as one of the key reasons for the failure of Tidal’s competitor Rdio.

Any judgement that puts pressure on Tidal to change course on negative option renewals could seriously jeopardize its future growth — which may be enough of a reason for Tidal to settle.

A Tidal spokesperson didn’t respond to a request for comment.

More Digital

  • Microsoft Reveals Next-Gen Console, Xbox Series

    Microsoft Reveals Next-Gen Console, Xbox Series X, at The Game Awards

    The next-generation Xbox console is officially called the Xbox Series X, and will be released over next year’s holiday season, Microsoft revealed during Thursday night’s The Game Awards. Head of Xbox Phil Spencer took the stage at Los Angeles’ Microsoft Theater to make the big reveal, and fill in the audience on a few details. [...]

  • The Game Awards

    How to Watch the 2019 Game Awards

    The Game Awards will be taking place on Thursday night and, fittingly, there are plenty of ways to stream the event online. The whole show will be streaming live starting at 5:30 p.m. PT/8:30 p.m. ET from Los Angeles’ Microsoft Theater on The Game Awards’ YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and Twitch pages. Additionally, for the first [...]

  • Neon-Hum-Jonathan-Hirsch

    Sony Music Invests in Podcast Production Firm Neon Hum

    In its latest move into the podcast biz, Sony Music Entertainment announced a strategic investment in podcast production house Neon Hum. Founded by podcast producer Jonathan Hirsch (pictured above), L.A.-based Neon Hum has helped create multiple podcast hits including MSNBC’s “Bag Man” with Rachel Maddow, Dateline NBC’s “The Thing About Pam,” Wondery’s “Room 20,” Crooked [...]

  • Hulu Hopes to Make Ads Part

    Hulu Hopes to Make Ads Part of Your Binge Session

    If you just can’t keep yourself from watching another episode of “The Handmaid’s Tale” or “PEN15,” then Hulu has an ad for you. The streaming-video hub is starting a trial run of new commercials aimed specifically at binge-watchers, which the company defines as subscribers who watch three or more episodes of the same series consecutively. [...]

  • Facebook

    Facebook Pledges $130 Million to Fund Content Oversight Board as It Hits Delays

    Facebook announced an initial commitment of $130 million to launch its new Oversight Board, which is designed as a way for users to appeal the social giant’s content decisions, but the entity is behind schedule with initial board members to be announced in 2020. The Oversight Board — which has been dubbed Facebook’s “Supreme Court” [...]

  • Rey (Daisy Ridley) in STAR WARS:

    Amazon Releases Secret 'Star Wars: Rise of Skywalker' Exclusive Video

    Amazon released a special behind-the-scenes look at “Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker” in partnership with Disney and Lucasfilm, in order to — what else? — sell stuff to fans of the galaxy far, far away. The ecommerce giant debuted the Star Wars video Thursday (Dec. 12) exclusively on Amazon.com and Fire TV, with secret [...]

  • Jay-Z

    Tidal Gets Dolby Atmos Music, Jay-Z to Release Catalog in Immersive Audio Format

    Music streaming service Tidal has partnered with Dolby to bring Dolby Atmos Music tracks to its Tidal HiFi tier. This makes Tidal the second music service to support the high-end format. For now, support is limited to certain Android devices. Consumers may know Dolby Atmos as a surround-sound audio format for movies, which is being [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content