You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why Hong Kong Needs a Bill of Rights, Not Just a New Copyright Law: Opinion

Discussion of a proposed new copyright bill in Hong Kong got under way again this week in the Legislative Council. It had been held up by days of delaying tactics, the Christmas-New Year holidays, and by procedural motions attempting to adjourn the debate until the HK government had rethought its approach to the thorny, but important issue.

Filibuster tactics and demonstrations, even a small explosion outside LegCo, dominated headlines, rather than the issues at hand: performance, piracy, plagiarism and the right to parody.

Part of the reason the issues got lost is a distrust of the government, which is perceived as being largely run for the benefit of local tycoons and the central government in Beijing.

Questions about freedom of expression and business online – “fair use” versus “fair dealing” — have been clumsily handled and poorly explained.

Equally badly, the proposed new copyright law will arrive on the statute books out of date and immediately need to be updated, government admits.

The news in the past week that five Hong Kong book sellers may have been kidnapped and taken across the border to China for questioning by security forces, is a terrifying development. And one that requires the Hong Kong government – constitutionally operating with a “high degree of autonomy” until 2047 – to take a stand.

It needs to come up with a Bill of Rights, like ones currently being drafted in several countries around the world. One that protects its citizens and companies, guarantees freedom of speech (online and off), and ensures that laws will be enforced by independent regulators, police, courts and arbitrators. Not just a copyright law that defines content ownership.

Bills of Rights were recently defined as “based upon broad public participation, which entrench human rights and safeguard space for innovation, while recognizing the legitimate needs of companies to make profits and of governments to fight crime,” by Tim Berners Lee, inventor of the World Wide Web, writing in The Economist.

“This bill is vital to the survival of the cultural industries of Hong Kong; film, television and animation,” says Ma Fung-kwok, a pro-government legislator specializing in the creative sector, of the copyright bill.

Free operation of the media and the courts is just as important if tiny Hong Kong is to maintain its outsized role in Asian media, culture, finance, and dispute resolution.

Flagship Entertainment, the recently-launched Chinese movie movie production joint venture between Warner Bros and China Media Capital did not settle on the Special Administrative Area as its legal seat just for Hong Kong’s iconic scenery.

The best outcome might be for the HK government to bulldoze the copyright bill through LegCo, as it recently did with the IT Development Bureau, and then immediately and earnestly start work on an Internet Bill of Rights. No delaying until after the next Chief Executive election.

Whether the HK government is brave enough to differentiate itself from its political masters in Beijing was doubtful before events of the last weeks. Now it has an opportunity to do the right thing.

Aside from the bookseller kidnappings, December saw a couple of other scary scenarios emerge.

At the World Internet Forum, Chinese president Xi Jinping asserted China’s right to govern the Web according to its own rules. And China edged forward with a new cyber-security law that is likely to require companies operating in China to provide software backdoors to the Chinese security services. That is a development likely to keep Facebook and Google out of China for a while longer.

If the Hong Kong government does not go ahead with an Internet rights bill and it prefers to self-censor, then it increases the risk that HK becomes just another mainland Chinese city — a nightmare scenario for HK government and citizens alike.

Instead, if it succeeds with a Rights Bill, it could keep Hong Kong, on China’s doorstep, as relevant as it was through the decades when China had a closed economy; as a portal to China, but built on a common law system with Western-style separation of powers.

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Blockchain Mania

    AFM: Panel to Launch Blockchain Working Group for the Film Industry

    A group of film executives and tech industry entrepreneurs are to establish a working group seeking to plan how blockchain technology should be applied to the creative industries. The call will be made at the American Film Market on Tuesday in Santa Monica by Manuel Badel from Badel Media and Patrice Poujol from The Lumiere [...]

  • Magic Leap Raising Another Funding Round

    Magic Leap Is Raising Another Big Funding Round

    Augmented reality startup Magic Leap is raising even more money. The company is currently in the process of raising its Series E round of funding, a spokesperson told Variety on Monday. Magic Leap previously raised around $2.6 billion, including $280 million from NTT Docomo in April. “Magic Leap is in the midst of a significant [...]

  • hearst logo

    Hearst Magazines Unionizes With Writers Guild of America East

    The Writers Guild of America East has scored a major victory by unionizing Hearst Magazines’ editorial, video, design, photo and social staff across 24 digital and print brands. The New York-based WGA East, which has about 6,000 members in film, television, news and digital media, announced on Monday that a strong majority of the 500-member [...]

  • Apple AR Headset Coming in 2022:

    Apple Said to Prep AR Headset for 2022

    Apple’s augmented reality (AR) headset won’t be arriving on store shelves until at least 2022, according to a new The Information report. The iPhone maker reportedly updated a large number of employees about the project last month, filling the spacious Steve Jobs Theater on its Cupertino, Calif. campus with employees working on AR hardware. Apple [...]

  • Variety Launches New Video Series, 'Daily

    Variety Launches New Video Series, 'Daily Variety'

    Variety has launched a daily video series covering the business of entertainment. Hosted by Audrey Cleo Yap and executive produced by Eva Wong, “Daily Variety” will feature breaking news coverage and analysis from Variety’s award-winning staff as well as in-depth features and interviews with top industry professionals. Each bite-sized segment and featured clip will be [...]

  • Pluto: Vevo Stations Launching on Ad-Supported

    Channeling MTV, Vevo Launches Linear Programming on Pluto

    Music television is back: Major label-owned music video platform Vevo is launching a series of linear channels for leanback viewing on Pluto TV, the ad-supported video service that got acquired by Viacom earlier this year. A first channel, dubbed Vevo Pop, will launch on November 12; additional channels, including a holiday-themed station, are expected to [...]

  • Instagram tests hiding likes

    Instagram Will Begin Hiding Likes in the U.S.: Smart Move or Misguided Fail?

    Instagram is about to launch a test of removing like counts from posts in the U.S. — and, predictably, the idea has been met with a range of reactions ranging from praise and support to concern and mockery. The hope is that the change can reduce anxiety among Instagram users, to make social media less [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content