×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

VidAngel Countersues Hollywood Studios With Antitrust Lawsuit

VidAngel, an online video service that allows consumers to watch major home-video releases in standard definition for $1, has filed a counter complaint against Hollywood studios who are seeking to shut them down.

Customers of VidAngel buy a movie online for $20, then have the option of setting filters to screen out objectionable content and watch the movie. The customer then sells back the movie for as much as $19.

VidAngel, however, contends that studios have violated the Sherman Antitrust Act by pressuring Google to withhold its Chromecast support services from VidAngel, which depends on streaming services to get access to its customers. Its counterclaim was filed on Tuesday in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles.

VidAngel claims that the Walt Disney Co., 20th Century Fox, Warner Bros. and Lucasfilm “have interfered with VidAngel’s attempts to partner with streaming content providers to filter movies.” They also claim that the studios have sought to “expand their copyright monopoly” by depriving consumers of the right to buy and sell copyrighted works.

VidAngel contends that its service is legal under copyright law and that its filtering is allowed by the Family Movie Act of 2015.

“Once a VidAngel customer purchases a disc, that disc is no longer available for sale,” the company said in its counter complaint. “The purchasing customer may request that the physical disc be mailed to him or her or may allow VidAngel to maintain custody of it. The discs are maintained in a physical vault, which is kept locked and protected by round-the-clock electronic monitoring.”

The customer, after viewing the disc via streaming, also has the option to sell it back to VidAngel. VidAngel contends that studios cannot prevent this arrangement because they lose distribution control over DVDs and Blu Rays after the first sale — akin to the ability of a bookseller or record shop to sell used copyrighted works.

The company also said that it has “designed and engineered its service to promote compliance with copyright law. For example, just as a physical DVD could not be played simultaneously on multiple devices, VidAngel restricts a user’s playback to one device at a time. VidAngel also streams a work to just one of a user’s registered devices at a time.”

It defends its filtering technology as authorized by the 2005 Family Movie Act, which allows for the creation of technology to filter out objectionable content. VidAngel said that its making of a decrypted copies of titles for filtering is “fully consistent’ with the 2005 law and all copyright laws, as well as its remote streams to customers.

The company says that “in asking this Court to impose a consent requirement on VidAngel’s filtering service, Plaintiffs are effectively asking that the Court repeal a federal statute enacted to protect American families.”

The four studios claim that VidAngel is “no different than many other unlawful online services.” They contend that the service appears to circumvent technological protection measures on DVDs and Blu-ray discs to create unauthorized copies that are then streamed to customers.

In their suit, they contend that VidAngel has defended the legality of its service by pointing out that it is “selling,” not renting, the movies to its users, distinguishing it from the likes of Netflix and Hulu that forge pricey licensing agreements for studio movies.”It does not matter whether VidAngel sells or rents movies,” their lawsuit said. “In either case, VidAngel would need copyright owner consent to circumvent access controls on protected discs, make copies of that content, and stream performances of the content to the public.”

The studios contend that VidAngel is undercutting their deals with video-on-demand and streaming businesses.

Among other things, VidAngel is seeking declarations that their service is legal, as well as damages. They are represented by Baker Marquart.

More Biz

  • During an interview at her home

    Judith Krantz, Best-Selling Author and Columnist, Dies at 91

    Judith Krantz, a best-selling author known for her novels “Scruples” and “Princess Daisy,” died Saturday from natural causes, surrounded by family, friends and her four dogs at her Bel Air, California home, her publicist John Tellem confirmed. She was 91. Krantz began her career in journalism, working for Good Housekeeping writing freelance articles for Macleans, [...]

  • Plume of black smoke rising from

    Soundgarden, Tupac and Tom Petty Estates Sue Universal Music Over Fire Damage

    Attorneys representing Soundgarden, Hole, Steve Earle and the estates of Tupac and Tom Petty today filed a class-action lawsuit against Universal Music Group over the master recordings destroyed in a 2008 fire, the extent of which was revealed last week in a New York Times article. The lawsuit, obtained by Variety, seeks some “50% of [...]

  • John Prine, Kamasi Washington, Sub Pop

    John Prine, Kamasi Washington, Sub Pop Win Big at A2IM Libera Awards

    Out of all the awards shows Variety Music attends every year — and we hit a few — in many ways A2IM’s Libera Awards, which celebrate the tight-knit independent label sector, is the most fun. It’s got awards and performances and a host and people get dressed up and all that, but at the end [...]

  • A trading post sports the Spotify

    Spotify Determines That It Overpaid Publishers in 2018, Requests Refund

    When calculating the new, higher rates determined by the U.S Copyright Royalty Board — which Spotify, Amazon, Google and SiriusXM/Pandora have appealed — Spotify has determined that it overpaid publishers in 2018 and would like a refund. “According to the new CRB regulations, we overpaid most publishers in 2018,” a Spotify spokeperson said. “While the [...]

  • Los Angeles LGBT Center CEO Lorri

    Los Angeles LGBT Center Opens New Campus for Community's Most Vulnerable

    When Donald Trump became president in 2016, some had grave concerns about what that could mean for the LGBTQ community. It gave such serious pause to the backers of the historic Los Angeles LGBT Center that they even considered scrapping plans to build their $142 million Anita May Rosenstein Campus in Hollywood. Then again, that [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Judge to Appoint Special Prosecutor in Jussie Smollett Case

    In yet another bizarre twist, a Chicago judge on Friday ordered the appointment of a special prosecutor to review the hoax case against “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett. Judge Michael Toomin ruled that State’s Attorney Kim Foxx should have appointed a special prosecutor when she opted to recuse herself early in the case. Instead, Foxx turned [...]

  • LGBT Rights Around the World

    The State of LGBTQ Rights Globally

    Pride is on the march across the globe as more and more countries recognize the freedom and rights of their LGBTQ citizens. Homosexuality is now legal in a majority of the world’s 195 nations — the latest, Botswana, joined the list June 11 — and marriage equality prevails in nearly 30 territories, covering more than [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content