×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Appeals Court Upholds FCC’s Net Neutrality Rules

A federal appellate court upheld the FCC’s rules of the road for the Internet, a blow to cable and telecom efforts to stall the agency’s net neutrality regulations.

A three judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 in favor of the FCC’s approach, with Judge Stephen F. Williams issuing a partial dissent.

At the heart of the FCC’s action was reclassifying the Internet as a common carrier, akin to the designation given to a utility. In the 184-page opinion, the majority of the judges found that the agency followed proper procedure and was within its authority on imposing rules that require that Internet providers treat all traffic equally.

“Today’s ruling is a victory for consumers and innovators who deserve unfettered access to the entire web, and it ensures the internet remains a platform for unparalleled innovation, free expression and economic growth,” FCC chairman Tom Wheeler said in a statement.  “After a decade of debate and legal battles, today’s ruling affirms the Commission’s ability to enforce the strongest possible internet protections – both on fixed and mobile networks – that will ensure the internet remains open, now and in the future.”

The rules were passed last year, with almost 4 million people filing public comments, setting a record for interest in an FCC proceeding.

Although a major victory for the FCC, observers believe that it is likely to be appealed to the Supreme Court. And congressional Republicans remain opposed to the rules, arguing that it is regulatory overreach.

“We have always expected this issue to be decided by the Supreme Court, and we look forward to participating in that appeal,” said David McAtee, senior executive vice president and general counsel of AT&T, one of the companies that challenged the rules.

The National Cable and Telecommunications Assn., one of the leaders in the effort to overturn the rules in court, said in a statement that “though disappointed in today’s result, we are particularly gratified by Judge Williams’ recognition of the ‘watery thin and self-contradictory’ nature of the FCC arguments used to justify the imposition of common carriage laws on Internet networks.”

“While this is unlikely the last step in this decade-long debate over Internet regulation, we urge bipartisan leaders in Congress to renew their efforts to craft meaningful legislation that can end ongoing uncertainty, promote network investment, and protect consumers,” the NCTA said.

But Andrew Jay Schwartzman, attorney and public interest advocate, said in a statement that Williams’ dissent was “rather limited,” noting that he agreed that the FCC had the authority to reclassify the Internet as a common carrier. He doubted that the Supreme Court would take the case.

The FCC twice has been thwarted by the D.C. Circuit in its effort to impose net neutrality rules. After its most stringent regulations were overturned in 2014, Wheeler sought to write new rules. That began a push for the FCC to reclassify the Internet as a title II common carrier, a regulatory maneuver to give the agency the legal foundation to impose robust regulation.

That is what the FCC did in a 3-2 vote in February of 2015 in an order that prohibits Internet providers from blocking or slowing traffic. The rules also prohibit ISPs from engaging in paid prioritization, or creating fast lanes and slow lanes online based on how much a content provider is willing to pay.

Public interest groups argued that without such rules, the Internet risks consolidating into a tiered system, perhaps akin to the bundling among cable providers.

Internet providers challenged the FCC’s action in a series of lawsuits, characterizing the move to reclassify the Internet as heavy handed and stifling to innovation. They argued that Wheeler shifted course in favor of reclassification late in 2014 after earlier proposing rules with a lighter regulatory touch. That changed, however, after President Obama weighed in in favor of a stronger regulatory approach.

After oral arguments in December, there had been some prediction that the judges would uphold the FCC’s rules for fixed broadband but set aside the regulations for mobile. But the court rejected those distinctions, ruling that the FCC “acted permissibly” in reclassifying that wireless service as well. The judges found that otherwise consumers would be faced with a different set of rules as they switched devices, finding that it was “counterintuitive” to “be subject to entirely different regulatory rules depending on how it happens to be connected to the internet at any particular moment.”

The judges also rejected opponents’ arguments that the rules violated the First Amendment. They also rejected a challenge to part of the net neutrality regulations that allows the agency to monitor, on a case-by-case basis, so-called “interconnection” agreements that allow content providers like Netflix to connect to an Internet service provider’s network.

At December’s hearing, the FCC’s counsel, Jonathan Sallet, faced a series of questions from Judge Williams over paid prioritization. Williams asked whether there was some other means of imposing rules that would prevent Internet providers from creating fast lanes and slow lanes.

Sallet, however, said that the FCC’s approach was “necessary to preserve the virtuous circle” of the Internet, where smaller start-up companies can still be assured that their content can get to consumers.

At the hearing, there were some queries over interconnection, or the agreements by which Internet providers agree to connect and carry traffic of content networks and providers like Netflix. The FCC did not extend the full weight of its rules to such arrangements, but did establish oversight on a case-by-case basis.

“The commission was being very careful here,” Sallet said.

Judge David Tatel, an appointee of former President Bill Clinton, wrote the majority opinion along with Sri Srinivasan, and appointee of Obama. Tatel also wrote two prior opinions that sidelined FCC net neutrality rules. But his 2014 majority opinion found fault with the legal grounds on which the agency imposed its rules, not that they were necessarily outside its scope of authority.

Williams is an appointee of former President Ronald Reagan.

More Biz

  • Electronic Arts Logo

    EA Laying Off 350 People, About 4% of Staff

    Electronic Arts is laying off about 350 of its 9,000-person staff, CEO Andrew Wilson announced in a blog post on its website Tuesday. In the brief, open letter, Wilson noted that the move was made to “address our challenges and prepare for the opportunities ahead,” and to “better deliver on our commitments, refine our organization [...]

  • Jon Platt Martin Bandier

    Read Sony CEO Kenichiro Yoshida's Memo Thanking Martin Bandier, Welcoming Jon Platt

    As outgoing Sony/ATV chief Martin Bandier (pictured above, right) finishes up his final week on the job, Sony CEO Kenichiro Yoshida thanked him for his 12 years of service and welcomed incoming publishing CEO Jon Platt (above, left) who joins from Warner/Chappell. The letter, obtained by Variety and under the subject line “Warm wishes to [...]

  • iHeartMedia Strikes Multi-Year Deal With LiveXLive

    iHeartMedia Strikes Multi-Year Deal With LiveXLive

    iHeartMedia today announced a multi-year agreement with LiveXLive, a digital media company focused on live entertainment. According to the announcement, the deal combines content, production, distribution and promotion. The newly expanded partnership gives LiveXLive exclusive global livestreaming rights for 17 iHeartRadio marquee events this year, including iHeartRadio’s ALTer Ego, iHeartCountry Festival, iHeartRadio Wango Tango, Daytime Stage at [...]

  • Chinese Movie Ticket Giant Maoyan Loses

    Losses Reach $20 Million at China's Maoyan

    Reporting its first financial data since a February IPO in Hong Kong, mainland Chinese movie ticketing firm Maoyan saw its revenue grow by 47% to $560 million (RMB3.76 billion) in 2018. Net losses for the year grew from $11.3 million (RMB76 million) to $20 million (RMB134 million). Though the company also chose to present what [...]

  • Apple Event: Everything We Learned From

    Everything We Learned From Today's Apple Event

    After revealing new services in news, finance, and gaming, Apple CEO Tim Cook kept the biggest, most anticipated announcement until last. Cook, along with heads of worldwide video programming Zack Van Amburg and Jamie Erlicht, and a whole group of Apple’s creative talents, presented the company’s new Apple TV+ streaming service, which is slated to [...]

  • Wynn Nightlife Announces Residency for Roving

    Wynn Las Vegas to Host Residency for Roving Spanish Party Elrow

    One of Las Vegas’ biggest music players is doubling down on the power of a global brand instead of just a single DJ to help them stay on top of Sin City’s increasingly competitive clubbing scene. Wynn Nightlife has announced a year-long residency and partnership with Spain’s Elrow, a respected Ibiza-born party that last year [...]

  • PledgeMusic Down to a ‘Skeleton Staff,’

    PledgeMusic Down to a ‘Skeleton Staff,’ Although a Potential Buyer Is in the Wings

    PledgeMusic, the direct-to-fan marketplace that has faced serious financial troubles in recent months, is down to a “skeleton staff” and payroll in the U.S. office ceased within the last month, sources close to the situation tell Variety, although a potential buyer is “very interested” in the company and has been in due diligence for several [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content