Madison Avenue Kickbacks? Trade Group Alleges ‘Pervasive’ Media-Buying Malfeasance

An influential Madison Avenue trade organization unveiled an investigation that alleges kickbacks, unauthorized rebates and the undisclosed resale of ad inventory at higher prices could be “pervasive” in the arcane but important world of media buying.

The Association of National Advertisers on Tuesday released the findings of a seven-month probe into what it calls “non-transparent business practices” among media agencies: Forty-one  individuals interviewed by investigations firm K2 reported that they had firsthand knowledge of rebates being passed back to agencies. Of those 41 sources, 34 said the rebates were not disclosed to advertisers, were not passed through to advertisers, and may also have been demanded by agencies.  The firm interviewed 150 different sources overall.

“The media business ecosystem is not transparent. Marketers are not getting full disclosure on the information they need,” said Bob Liodice, chief executive of the organization, which represents the interests of hundreds of companies and the 15,000 brands they market with about $300 billion in spending, during a conference call Tuesday. “There are billions of dollars at stake.”

K2 said it found “a range of instances” in which media owners paid rebates to agencies, “in amounts ranging from 1.67% to approximately 20% of aggregate media spending, depending upon the deal.” In some cases,  the percentage of the rebate owed increased along with agency spend, the company’s report stated. The company also found instances in which media agencies could purchase advertising inventory from a supplier, then mark up the price as much as 30% to 90% before passing it along to a client. In some cases, a media agency’s owner, typically one of five or six global holding companies, may have pressured individual buyers to direct a client’s ad money to these areas where a markup might be possible, the report stated.

While the report stated the practices could be found across a range of media, including print, digital, TV and outdoor, the ANA declined to provide the names of the agencies where the alleged misbehavior is said to have taken place. According to Liodice, the goal of the investigation was not to seek legal remedy or punish; indeed, in some cases, terms allowing such practices may have been written into contracts.

What could be at issue are transactions involving the sale of new kinds of ad inventory that have gained new allure as technology makes the sales process easier. More advertisers have shown an interest in so-called “programmatic” inventory, which is purchased according to a predefined set of data put in place through software. Some of this inventory is sold through private exchanges, reducing the transparency around the purchase. One media executive familiar with the ANA report suggested some agencies may be buying up digital and programmatic inventory at one price, then selling it to clients at another price, making a profit in the process.

The ANA wishes to spark a broader conversation about media-buying practices, and alert its members to some of the issues that may be taking place under their aegis, Liodice said. The ANA intends to issue new guidelines about contracts that are struck with media agencies before the end of June, the executive said.

“This may be a troubling report” for the advertising industry, said Liodice, but it aims to navigate a “disconnect” that has grown between agencies and clients over the practices governing how advertising dollars ought to be spent.

At least one of the world’s big ad companies took umbrage at the report. “The ANA has failed its members, advertisers, agencies and the entire industry by releasing a report that relies on allegations about situations involving unnamed companies and individuals to make broad, unsubstantiated and unverifiable assertions,” said Publicis Groupe, the French holding company, in a prepared statement, noting that “the document hides behind suspicions and anonymity rather than encouraging real accountability.” Publicis recently restructured its media buying operations after one of its agencies, Starcom MediaVest, saw a passel of important clients defect to rivals.

Yet the controversy has brewed for some time. In March of 2014, a survey conducted by the ANA and Forrester Research found nearly half of respondents had concerns about the level of transparency between advertisers and their media agencies. The report found 42% had concerns about transparency that had increased over the past year. Only 13% said their concerns decreased.





Popular on Variety

More Biz

  • Led Zeppelin Stairway to Heaven

    Department of Justice Backs Led Zeppelin in ‘Stairway to Heaven’ Copyright Case

    The U.S. Department of Justice has weighed in on the next big music copyright case on the horizon following the Katy Perry “Dark Horse” decision, and taken Led Zeppelin’s side in the long-running copyright dispute that pits the writers of the group’s anthem “Stairway to Heaven” against the publishers of the earlier song “Taurus” by [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein

    Harvey Weinstein Prosecutors Make Last-Minute Move to Bolster Case

    The Manhattan D.A.’s office is making a last-minute bid to strengthen its case against Harvey Weinstein, who is set to be tried next month on charges of rape and sexual assault. Prosecutors notified the court on Tuesday that they will seek a new indictment. The D.A.’s office wants jurors to hear from Annabella Sciorra, the [...]

  • Jeffrey Epstein

    Jeffrey Epstein's Autopsy Rules That He Died by Suicide

    Jeffrey Epstein’s death earlier this month has been ruled a suicide by hanging. The New York Times reported on Friday that the city’s medical examiner has officially made the ruling six days after Epstein was found dead in his jail cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan. According to the Times, which cites a [...]

  • America Ferrera Eva Longoria

    America Ferrera, Eva Longoria and More Sign Letter to Latinx Community: 'We Will Not Be Broken'

    America Ferrera, Eva Longoria and more have signed a letter published in several media outlets on Friday standing in solidarity with the Latinx community. In response to the heightened tension surrounding President Trump’s immigration agenda, the El Paso shooting that targeted Latinx people and the ICE raids in Mississippi, the letter addresses the language used [...]

  • Research Firm Screen Engine/ASI Acquires TicktBox

    Screen Engine/ASI Acquires TicktBox, an Entertainment Marketing and Ticketing Startup

    Screen Engine/ASI, a market research firm that specializes in focus-group testing of movies and TV pilots, has acquired ticktBox, which operates a digital marketing and ticketing platform used by movie distributors, exhibitors, and TV networks. Terms of the deal, which closed Aug. 9, weren’t disclosed. With ticktBox, SE/ASI will have one of the largest databases of [...]


    Eric Reid, Jemele Hill – and Colin Kaepernick? - Take Jay-Z to Task Over NFL Partnership

    When news of the presumably lucrative entertainment and social-justice deal between Jay-Z’s Roc Nation and the NFL leaked on Tuesday, initially there was a surprising lack of public reaction or outcry. But after a press conference where Jay and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell officially announced the deal at Roc Nation’s New York offices yesterday — [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content