Cable, Satellite Companies Warn of FCC’s Set-Top Box Proposal

Cable and satellite companies are pushing back against an FCC proposal to “open up” the set-top box, claiming that it may raise prices for consumers and lead to less choice in diverse programming.

FCC chairman Tom Wheeler is proposing an open platform for the set-top box, something he says will boost competition as consumers would have the choice of renting the devices from their pay-TV provider or buying one on their own. Many cable and satellite companies charge their subscribers a fee to rent a box.

A group of cable and satellite companies, along with some nonprofit associations representing minority groups, have formed the Future of TV Coalition to oppose the proposal. On Tuesday, the coalition’s co-chair, TV One CEO Alfred Liggins, and NCTA president-CEO Michael Powell, held a conference call to argue against it.

The FCC proposal “would require an enormous amount of time, effort, re-engineering and cost,” said Powell. “It would take four, five, six, seven years to fully implement, even by their own admission, and by that time, who knows what the video marketplace will look like, or whether this is a solution in search of a problem.” The coalition believes most companies are moving to mobile apps, not a new set-top box, to distribute content on a myriad of new screens. Powell pointed to Netflix, Amazon Prime and Hulu as companies that were making content across screens and devices.

The proposal will be brought to the FCC’s next open meeting on Thursday. If it passes, there then will be a period for the public to file comments. The commission would then make a final vote on a final proposal.

The MPAA also opposes Wheeler’s proposal, which critics say would jeopardize copyright and privacy protections or hobble innovation.

Executives suggested the plan would give the manufacturer of the new set-top box model undue power over content and consumer privacy. At a time when most content producers are eager to recoup the costs of their production, said Powell, allowing a single technology concern to help stream or distribute content without paying some sort of recompense appeared unseemly.

“The big kick I get is that AT&T and the cable companies have been putting out statements that say, ‘This is going to thwart innovation,'” Wheeler told Variety‘s “PopPolitics” on SiriusXM earlier this month. “And I scratch my head and say, ‘My goodness, let’s see. When it the last time that competition thwarted innovation rather than spurring innovation?’ And you are telling me that a locked down, closed system will have more impetus to be innovative, than a competitive, open system? I think that history shows that it is exactly the opposite of what happens in reality.”

He said that what it could lead to are fewer remote controls and easier navigation, where consumers can “shape television to how they use it.”

Wheeler said that the average consumer is paying $231 per year to lease set-top boxes, even after cable and satellite companies have already recovered the cost to make them.

“All we are saying is, ‘Cable operators, you can go ahead and control your product,” he said. “But have an open platform so that anyone can build a device, and then let’s compete on who can offer the better device.’ Let’s have the cable company say, ‘You want to pay me for my interface, because it does all these things nobody else does.’ Rather than, ‘You must pay me.’ We are just trying to get to that basic American concept of competition.”

He also said that copyright, privacy and other protections would remain in place.

On Tuesday, Rep. Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.) and 12 other Democratic lawmakers signed a letter in support of the proposal.

They wrote that the FCC should “ensure that the agency maintains its statutory obligation to give consumers an alternative to having to rent a set-top box from their pay-TV provider every month.”

They also wrote that “while we agree that apps offer consumers another option for watching video programming, they may not necessarily provide the same features and functionality that are available through a pay-TV provider’s leased set-top box.”


More Biz

  • A police line forbids the access

    L.A. County Orders Closure of Beaches and Hiking Trails

    Those hoping to escape to the beach this weekend after being pent up at home are out of luck. On Friday, Los Angeles County ordered the closure of beaches and hiking trails, hoping to avoid the crowds that could cause the spread of the coronavirus. State and local officials had previously ordered the closure of [...]

  • Viacom HQ LA

    ViacomCBS Sets $2.5 Billion Debt Offering as Company Faces Tough Scrutiny

    ViacomCBS has disclosed plans for a $2.5 billion debt offering, an effort that comes as the newly merged company faces tough scrutiny of its growth strategy and balance sheet amid the coronavirus-related economic crisis. ViacomCBS said it would seek to raise $2.5 billion for cash that may be used to help pay down some of [...]

  • A2IM

    A2IM’s Indie Week and Libera Awards Go Virtual for 2020

    In yet another sign of the times, the American Association of Independent Music (A2IM) today announced that the 2020 installment of its Indie Week conference — the world’s biggest gathering point specifically for the independent music community — is moving online this year, obviously due to the coronavirus pandemic. The event, which also includes the [...]

  • Amber Heard Johnny Depp

    Johnny Depp Allowed to Pursue Defamation Suit Against Amber Heard

    A Virginia judge on Friday refused to dismiss Johnny Depp’s lawsuit against Amber Heard, allowing him to proceed with a claim that she defamed him in a Washington Post opinion piece. In the piece, published in December 2018, Heard alluded to her previous claims that Depp had assaulted her during their marriage, though she did [...]

  • Disney World crowd

    Disneyland and Walt Disney World Now Indefinitely Closed Amid Coronavirus Outbreak

    While Disneyland and Walt Disney World had initially planned to close through March in an effort to prevent the spread of the novel coronavirus COVID-19 and comply with shelter-in-place guidelines, the U.S. Disney parks have now announced that they will “remain closed until further notice.” “While there is still much uncertainty with respect to the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content