You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Facebook Says Investigation Revealed ‘No Evidence of Systemic Political Bias’

Facebook’s general counsel says that an investigation into its Trending Topics feature has revealed “no evidence of systemic political bias,” and that the rates of approval of liberal and conservative topics “are virtually identical” in the feature.

The comments from Colin Stretch, the company’s general counsel, came in a letter of responses to Senate Commerce Committee chairman John Thune (R-S.D.). Thune asked the company to respond to a series of questions about how selections are made for its influential Trending Topics feature after a Gizmodo story quoted unnamed former employees who said that workers skewed results to downplay conservative comments.

Stretch wrote that Facebook “spoke with current reviewers and their supervisors, as well as a cross-section of former reviewers; spoke with our contractor; reviewed our guidelines, training, and practices; examined the effectiveness of operational oversight designed to identify and correct mistakes and abuse; and analyzed data on the implementation of guidelines by reviewers.”

He wrote that they were “unable to substantiate any of the specific allegations of politically-motivated suppression of subjects or sources, as reported in the media. To the contrary, we confirmed that most of those subjects were in fact included as trending topics on multiple occasions, on dates and at intervals that would be expected given the volume of discussion around those topics on those dates.”

But he added that the investigation “could not exclude the possibility of isolated improper actions or unintentional bias in the implementation of our guidelines or policies.” He also noted that in some cases before July 2015, some popular topics may have been excluded if it did not include a post from a major news organization, a primary source or a verified profile or page. But the guidance that Facebook provided to reviewers was updated that month to allow topics not covered by major sources.

His complete letter is here.

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg met last week with a group of conservative journalists and personalities, including Glenn Beck and S.E. Cupp.

Thune met with Stretch on May 18 to discuss his concerns.

In a statement, Thune said that “Facebook’s description of the methodology it uses for determining the trending content it highlights for users is far different from and more detailed than what it offered prior to our questions. We now know the system relied on human judgment, and not just an automated process, more than previously acknowledged.”

He said that Facebook “has recognized the limitations of efforts to keep information systems fully free from potential bias, which lends credibility to its findings.”

But he said that “transparency – not regulation – remains the goal.”

Stretch outlined a number of changes that Facebook is making, including a “refresher training” for reviewers to emphasize that content decisions can’t be made on the basis of politics or ideology. He also said that the company would add more controls and oversight around the review team, expand their help center, and eliminate their reliance on external websites and news outlets to assess the importance of trending topics. Facebook will discontinue the use of the top-10 mist of news outlets, the media 1K list and the RSS feed.

More Biz

  • Jussie Smollett

    Judge Refuses to Dismiss Chicago's Lawsuit Against Jussie Smollett

    A federal judge on Tuesday refused to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the City of Chicago, which is seeking to recoup investigative costs from former “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett. Judge Virginia M. Kendall rejected Smollett’s contention that he should not be made to pay $130,000 in police overtime costs, plus $260,000 in damages, because he [...]

  • It Is 'Unlikely’ That PledgeMusic Artists

    It Is 'Unlikely’ That PledgeMusic Artists and Creditors Will Be Paid, Receiver Says

    PledgeMusic, the direct-to-fan marketplace that went out of business earlier this year, was more than $7.4 million in debt when it entered liquidation, and its receiver says it is “unlikely” that artists and others owed money by the company will be paid, according to a report from the bank-appointed receiver. “I do not anticipate that [...]

  • Lori Loughlin

    Lori Loughlin Charged With Bribery in College Admissions Case

    Actress Lori Loughlin and her husband, designer Mossimo Giannulli, were indicted on a charge of conspiring to commit federal programs bribery on Tuesday, in connection with allegations that they paid $500,000 to get their daughters into the University of Southern California. Loughlin and Giannulli already faced charges of conspiring to commit mail fraud and money [...]

  • Gary Newman

    Fox TV Group Alum Gary Newman Joins Attention Capital as Executive Partner

    Former Fox TV Group chairman Gary Newman has joined Attention Capital, the startup venture launched earlier this year by another Fox alumnus, Joe Marchese. Newman and another media biz veteran, Lisa Gersh, were named Tuesday as executive partners of Attention Capital. Newman will focus on acquisition and investment opportunities. Marchese, who previously headed advertising sales [...]

  • Clio-Brand-Storytelling-Award

    Clio Awards, Brand Storytelling Team to Launch 'Storytelling for Good' Award

    Clio, the international advertising awards competition, announced Clio Brand Storytelling, a new program in partnership with Brand Storytelling, a media company exclusively built to support and inspire investment in the practice of brand-funded content. The inaugural Storytelling for Good Award will celebrate branded entertainment and content that promotes or creates awareness for a cause, foundation, [...]

  • Matt Lauer Kurt Sutter

    From Sutter to Lauer, Hollywood Sees a Flurry of Letters From the Edge (Column)

    Let’s talk about the whacked-out letters that hit the media sphere in the past eight days. One was that bizarre mea culpa dropped Oct. 17 by the no-holds-barred showrunner Kurt Sutter in response to getting canned from his series “Mayans MC.” No stranger to complaints of unprofessional behavior on his sets over the years, Sutter [...]

  • ICM Partners

    ICM Partners Promotes Victoria Gutierrez, Charlotte Lichtman and Brittany Perlmuter

    ICM Partners has promoted three — Victoria Gutierrez, Charlotte Lichtman and Brittany Perlmuter — to agent. Gutierrez will work in the concerts department, Lichtman will be an agent in the international and independent film department and Perlmuter moves to the talent department focusing on comedy. Gutierrez started her career at ICM Partners in 2014, working [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content