Charter-Time Warner Cable Merger Faces Fierce Opposition From New Coalition

The conventional wisdom has been that Charter Communications faces a smoother regulatory approval process in merging with Time Warner Cable than Comcast did.

A Charter-TW Cable combination would not be as mammoth, New York regulators have already signed off on the merger and Netflix CEO Reed Hastings, a vocal opponent of the Comcast deal, supports this one.

But some opponents are raising the volume on their opposition, particularly when it comes to what the potential combination would mean for the growth of online video services.

On Thursday, Dish Network, USTelecom, Public Knowledge and a number of other groups launched the Stop Mega Cable Coalition, with members sharing criticisms of the transaction, but differing on whether they would like to see the deal blocked outright or subject to stringent conditions.

“Comcast was a category 5 hurricane; Charter is a category 4. It is still really bad,” said Jeff Blum, senior vice president and deputy general counsel of Dish Network, which believes the merger should be blocked. He noted that Charter would have the incentive to try to restrict programmers from offering content to Dish’s online service Sling TV, a cheaper alternative to cable bundles.

Gene Kimmelman, the president of Public Knowledge, said that the merger would create a cable giant that would control the “overwhelming majority” of high-speed broadband homes in the country. From an antitrust perspective, he warns of two dominant players, Comcast and Charter, that could coordinate the way that they treat video programmers and the emerging market of online video, also called “over-the-top” services. Public Knowledge is asking regulators to address the potential duopoly and other issues.

Other members of the coalition also include the Writers Guild of America, which opposed the Comcast merger as well.

They contend that the newly merged company would control 35% of the market for cable pay TV and 36% for cable broadband, with a dominant position in markets like Los Angeles and New York.

In a statement, Charter said that it “should come as no surprise that Dish and other parties seeking to use the regulatory review process to extract concessions are also engaging in tired PR tactics to further their self interests. Their arguments against the pending transactions are baseless.” Charter has said that it would impose no data caps, which pose a potential limitation to online video.

Charter noted its support not just from Netflix, but independent channels like Fuse Media and RFD-TV, as well as groups like the National Urban League and the National Action Network.

“These parties have taken a close and honest look at the benefits of these transactions and have all come to the same conclusion: they are in the public interest.”

Last week, representatives from Time Warner (the former parent of Time Warner Cable and not a member of the coalition) and HBO met with FCC officials to raise concerns that the Charter-TW Cable merger would “be inclined to take action directed at programmers in response to the development of” online video services. HBO has launched HBONow, which offers the ability to subscribe to the premium service on platforms like Apple TV. The meeting was at the invitation from FCC staff.

Critics of the merger have cited comments made by Charter CEO Tom Rutledge, who told CNBC in 2014, “Anybody who sells their content over-the-top and also expects to continue to exist within a bundle sold to cable or satellite providers is really deluding themselves.” That comment came before Charter had proposed to acquire TW Cable.

Late last week, Charter posted a blog entry in which it said that it was the “most friendly” operator to online video distributors, along with more recent comments from Rutledge on CNBC.

“We like over-the-top television because it makes our broadband product look better,” he said in November. “We like it because it pressures the price of video. Obviously, if consumers are unwilling to pay for video at a certain price, we’re unwilling to pay for that as well. So our cost structure is positively impacted by over-the-top.”

In its filings with the FCC, Dish has charged that the merger would only increase the incentive for Charter to limit the growth of online video services because they pose a threat to the more lucrative cable bundle. Dish said that Rutledge’s 2014 comments were “outright threatening behavior” to discourage content providers from granting rights to online video services.

Dish’s Blum was asked at a press conference why Netflix, the online video giant, would support the Charter merger after opposing the Comcast deal. Hastings praised it in the Netflix earnings call as a “tremendous positive for the [over-the-top video] industry.”

“I don’t know what deal Netflix and Charter entered into,” Blum said.

Another issue raised has been the role of John Malone, and whether he would withhold Discovery Communications programming from competitors. Malone is chairman of Liberty Broadband, an investor in Charter and its biggest shareholder, and the largest shareholder in Discovery Communications.

In an FCC filing, Discovery said that they would not have an incentive to favor Charter, “because doing so would cause each economic harm.”

“Despite having had a common owner in John Malone for a number of years, Charter and Discovery are both structurally and operationally independent of each other,” Discovery said in the filing.

Popular on Variety

More Biz

  • Frank Grillo'Avengers: Endgame' Film Premiere, Arrivals,

    Matt Phelps Tapped as President of Joe Carnahan, Frank Grillo's Warparty

    Frank Grillo and Joe Carnahan’s Warparty productikon banner has appointed Matt Phelps president of the company. Phelps will head the Los Angeles office and be responsible for overseeing all film and television projects. “We searched long and hard to find the right fit for Warparty and felt that Matt embodied everything that we were looking [...]

  • Jack Gilardi, Longtime ICM Partners Agent,

    Jack Gilardi, Longtime ICM Partners Agent, Dies at 88

    Jack Gilardi, a longtime ICM Partners agent who represented such stars as Burt Reynolds, Sylvester Stallone, Jerry Lewis, Charlton Heston and Shirley MacLaine, died Thursday at his home in Los Angeles. He was 88. Gilardi was known for his gentlemanly style, love of the Los Angeles Dodgers and his skill at representing top actors. He [...]

  • Nexstar Completes Tribune Acquisition, Sean Compton

    Nexstar Completes Tribune Acquisition, Sean Compton to Head Programming

    Nexstar Media Group has become the nation’s largest owner of TV stations after completing its $4.1 billion acquisition of Tribune Media. The deal creates a broadcasting colossus with more than 200 stations serving more than 100 markets, although a number of stations will be divested to keep Nexstar in compliance with FCC ownership limits. Nexstar, [...]

  • Leaving Neverland HBO

    Judge Sides With Michael Jackson Estate in 'Leaving Neverland' Dispute

    A federal judge is leaning towards granting the Michael Jackson estate’s move to take HBO to arbitration in its dispute over the documentary “Leaving Neverland.” Judge George Wu issued a tentative ruling on Thursday in which he denied HBO’s motion to dismiss the estate’s case. Wu is expected to make the ruling final by the [...]

  • Homecoming

    Peak Storytelling Here as Podcasts, Short Form Ride New Wave

    The concept of peak TV is nothing new. But scratch the surface of original content these days, and it’s no longer about television — from podcasts and short-form video, storytelling itself is at a peak. Thanks to audio, video and other new platform companies including Gimlet, Quibi, Wondery, iHeartMedia and Serial Box, listeners and viewers [...]

  • Patti Smith Cambridge Folk Festival

    Patti Smith Muses Over the Many Ways to Tell a Story

    It’s Sept. 11, and Patti Smith has been thinking a lot about people who died. This is understandable. It is, of course, the 18th anniversary of the attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon, and an annual time of mourning for New York City, the city that Smith adopted as her hometown 50-plus years [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content