You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

AT&T + Time Warner: 3 Reasons a Merger Makes Sense and 3 Hurdles

AT&T is said to be moving forward quickly in a bid to snap up Time Warner — potentially finalizing a deal in the next few days that could be worth $85 billion or more.

Such a union would give AT&T a new avenue of growth and combine Time Warner’s premiere entertainment assets, including Warner Bros., HBO, and Turner, with the telco’s powerful DirecTV, wireless, and broadband distribution. But AT&T’s ambitions also would encounter some significant challenges.

Here are three factors that support the logic behind the vertical integration of two massive companies, and three reasons it might be tough to pull off.

1. AT&T Has Faced Stagnating Growth in Its Core Wireless and Wireline Businesses. In fact, that was the major reason AT&T bought DirecTV for $49 billion last year — to diversify and grow its revenue base. “AT&T creates value through M&A — within two years of closing a deal we assume they are looking for the next one. And as the company grows, it takes ever bigger deals to move the needle,” New Street Research analyst Jonathan Chaplin wrote in a research note. In some ways, we’ve seen this movie before: Comcast acquired NBCUniversal, bringing the No. 1 U.S. cable operator together with top TV networks and Universal Studios.

2. AT&T and Time Warner Could Accelerate Their OTT Strategies: AT&T is gearing up to launch DirecTV Now, a suite of three over-the-top pay-TV packages, and Time Warner now owns 10% of Hulu — which is prepping an OTT live TV service for 2017. “A deal with Time Warner could strengthen its content ownership position, which holds great value in an OTT world, particularly if AT&T could control distribution,” said Macquarie Securities analyst Amy Yong. “Content from cable nets and a film studio as well as rights to sports broadcasts and franchises (intellectual property) could help AT&T enhance its leverage against competitors.” That, Yong added, would help its competitive positioning to not only traditional rivals like Verizon, T-Mobile, and Sprint, but also players like Comcast and Netflix.

3. Time Warner Is a Comparatively Motivated Seller Without Familiar Ownership: Unlike with Viacom/CBS, 21st Century Fox, Discovery Communications, or Scripps Networks Interactive, there is “no blocking/family shareholder,” Credit Suisse research analyst Omar Sheikh wrote in a note. “Control over a leading film and TV studio, plus valuable sports and drama networks, TWX is the partner of choice if any consolidation is to take place in U.S. media in our view.”

That said, here are things that may prove thorny:

1. The Deal Would Be Pricey: No price tag has been floated, but recall that Time Warner rejected 21st Century Fox’s $80 billion bid two years ago. Buying Time Warner would require AT&T to assume considerable additional debt. Analysts assume a successful bid for Time Warner would have to top $100 per share; the stock climbed above $90 on Friday. AT&T has $7.2 billion of cash and equivalents, and expects to generate $16 billion in cash from operations in 2016. That means a deal for Time Warner would be highly leveraged, on top of AT&T’s existing $126 billion in debt — some of that from the DirecTV buy — and some analysts don’t think there’s payback in the cards. “Though there could be some industrial logic to the speculated Time Warner-AT&T combination (similar to Comcast-NBC Universal in hindsight), we believe the upfront financial benefits do not seem as readily apparent,” Barclays analysts Kannan Venkateshwar and Amir Rozwadowski wrote in a research note. “It is difficult for us to see the positive financial benefits on a standalone financial basis.”

2. Regulatory Baggage May Be High: While AT&T-Time Warner would be a vertical combo, rather than a horizontal merger (of competitors), antitrust regulators would take a hard look at any proposed deal. “The FCC and DOJ have historically highlighted concern that the vertical integration of content owners (in this case Warner Bros., Turner, and HBO) with distribution platforms (DirecTV/AT&T) may result in harmful effects for consumers,” Sheikh said. In the Comcast-NCBU transaction, the FCC imposed several long-term conditions on the combined company, designed to prevent Comcast from using the Peacock as an anticompetitive weapon. Even so, “we think D.C. has had many regrets over CMCSA/NBCU,” noted Wells Fargo Securities analyst Marci Ryvicker.

3. Benefits From AT&T Owning Time Warner May Be Negligible: The gigantic price tag required to buy Time Warner could be overkill, according to Cowen & Co. analyst Doug Creutz. One, licensing content has become more pervasive than it was a few years ago and two, “exclusivity is not necessary and in fact may not be a good use of Time Warner’s valuable content,” he wrote in a note. “It is not clear how 1+1 in this case equals something greater than two despite AT&T’s success with other large acquisitions.” To Creutz, the strategy of marrying content and distribution has generally failed (note that Time Warner divested Time Warner Cable in 2009) and that Comcast-NBCU is the exception. There are also potential “cultural integration risks,” the analyst pointed out.

Other questions that the AT&T-Time Warner merger talks raises:

Could Another Bidder Be in Play? It’s possible that a move to buy Time Warner by a large bidder (Apple?) prompted AT&T to accelerate its move to nab the media conglomerate. Sources say Rupert Murdoch and Fox are not interested in a return bid. Tech companies might be interested in Time Warner “for its scarcity value,” RBC Capital Markets analyst Steven Cahall wrote in a note. “If content companies are key acquisition targets, then TWX is unique in being both heavily focused on owned content and perhaps more importantly is a single-class equity share structure that has no familial considerations.” The latter sets it apart from FOXA, CBS, Viacom, SNI, and DISCA. That basically only leaves DIS, which might be an impossibly big deal at nearly $150 billion market cap.

Whither Jeff Bewkes? He has signed a contract to remain CEO of Time Warner through 2020. But in the event that AT&T acquires the company, Bewkes may exit the post early — and the question then would be who would oversee the Time Warner empire. Peter Chernin, head of Chernin Group, already has a relationship with AT&T via the two companies’ Otter Media joint venture for over-the-top content, and he could be a candidate to step in to oversee the Time Warner operations, either under AT&T Entertainment Group CEO John Stankey or in a newly created role.

More Biz

  • Hipgnosis Acquires Catalog From Jeff Bhasker

    Hipgnosis Acquires Catalog From Bruno Mars-Harry Styles Collaborator Jeff Bhasker

    Hipgnosis Songs Fund has acquired a music catalog from five-time Grammy-winning producer, songwriter and musician Jeff Bhasker. Terms of the deal were not announced, but Bhasker has worked extensively with such artists as Mark Ronson and Bruno Mars (on “Uptown Funk” and Mars’ “Unorthodox Jukebox” album), Kanye West (“808s & Heartbreak” and “My Beautiful Dark Twisted [...]

  • Kasi LemmonsNew York Women in Film

    Kasi Lemmons, Jane Rosenthal, Ann Dowd Talk Golden Globes Female Director Snub

    The absence of women among director nominees for the Golden Globes is another example of how much work remains to be done to achieve gender parity in the entertainment industry, honorees said Tuesday night at the 40th annual Muse Awards presented by New York Women in Film and Television. “Harriet” director Kasi Lemmons, “The Irishman” [...]

  • Juice WRLD - Jarad HigginsWireless Festival,

    Juice Wrld Streams Climb Nearly 500% After His Death

    As often happens after an unexpected death, Juice Wrld’s music soared in popularity after his passing on Sunday, with streams climbing nearly 500% on that day alone. On-demand audio streams for the rapper, who died at the age of 21 after suffering a seizure at Chicago’s Midway Airport, climbed 487% on Sunday to more than [...]

  • Netflix headquarters in Los Gatos, California,

    Netflix Ordered to Stop Poaching Fox Employees

    A court on Tuesday issued an injunction barring Netflix from poaching employees from Fox and confirming the validity of fixed-term employment agreements. The ruling marks a hard-fought victory for Fox — now owned by Disney — which set out three years ago to stop Netflix from raiding its employees. Netflix had sought to invalidate Fox’s [...]

  • Harry Styles performs at the Greek

    First Look at Harry Styles' Ticket-Giveaway Bus (EXCLUSIVE)

    Harry Styles announced Tuesday he is partnering with American Express to give away tickets to his concert at the Forum in Los Angeles on Friday — on a special custom bus. At the show, “Harry Styles Fine Line Live: One Night Only!,” the singer is expected to perform his entire new album, which is also [...]

  • Weeknd

    The Weeknd Takes Top Two Spots on Rolling Stone Singles Chart

    Fighting off a seasonal surge from Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You,” The Weeknd’s two new singles topped the Rolling Stone Top 100 songs chart this week. “Heartless” and “Blinding Lights,” both of which dropped last week, rocketed to No. 1 and 2 respectively with more than 40 million streams between them. [...]

  • The Olympic Rings adorn an event

    NBCUniversal Expects More Than $1.2 Billion in Ads for Tokyo Olympics

    Madison Avenue is rushing to get money down in NBCUniversal’s broadcast of the 2020 Olympics from Tokyo, the latest big TV-sports event to spark heavier demand from advertisers at a time when finding truly big media audiences has grown more difficult. NBCUniversal said it is on track to take in more than the $1.2 billion [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content