×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

FBI Director Defends Legal Effort to Force Apple to Unlock iPhone

FBI Director James Comey defended the agency’s legal pursuit of access to suspects’ digital information, including that of an iPhone owned by one of the San Bernardino terrorists, but he faced some skeptical lawmakers on Capitol Hill who worried about cases setting a precedent that would jeopardize privacy.

Comey was speaking to the House Judiciary Committee, which held a hearing on Tuesday devoted to the issue of encryption, just as the FBI is engaged in a legal tussle with Apple as it seeks the tech giant’s help in unlocking the iPhone owned by Syed Farook, who with wife Tashfeen Malik shot and killed 14 people in the Dec. 2 terror attacks in San Bernardino.

The FBI is asking that Apple “turn off the auto erase and delay features so that we can try to guess the password,” Comey told the committee.

“Essentially we are asking Apple, ‘Take the vicious dog away. Let us pick the lock,'” Comey told lawmakers.

A judge has ordered Apple to comply, but the company is appealing.

Apple General Counsel Bruce Sewell, who also testified, called the FBI’s request an “extraordinary circumstance” in that “the FBI has asked a court to order us to give them something we don’t have.”

“As we have told them — and as we have told the American public — building that software tool would not affect just one iPhone. It would weaken the security for all of them,” he said.

Comey acknowledged that a mistake was made in the 24 hours after the attack, when the FBI asked San Bernardino authorities to change the password on the iCloud backup for the phone. That foreclosed a potential backup solution, although Comey said that “the experts have told me we would still be in litigation because there is no way we would have gotten everything from an iPhone from a backup.”

Comey defended the FBI’s pursuit of court orders to unlock devices in criminal cases. Moreover, he worried about future technology that makes access to devices impossible, asking about the “consequences” of “warrant-proof spaces in American life.” He said that it was the agency’s job to pursue all avenues of a criminal or terrorist investigation.

The Justice Department has cited the government’s authority under the All Writs Act of 1789 in seeking to compel Apple’s assistance.

The chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, Rep. Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.), said that the questions over the balance of privacy vs. security had to be left to Congress.

“We must find a way for physical security not to be at odds with information security,” he said. “Law enforcement must be able to fight crime and keep us safe, and this country’s innovative companies must at the same time have the opportunity to offer secure services to keep their customers safe.”

But Rep. John Conyers (D-Mich.) said that what concerned him is “that in the middle of an ongoing congressional debate on this subject, the FBI would ask a federal magistrate to give them the special access to secure products that this committee, this Congress and the administration have so far refused to provide.”

“I would be deeply disappointed if it turns out that the government is found to be exploiting a national tragedy to pursue a change in the law,” he said.

Comey said that if they didn’t seek court action in the San Bernardino case, “I ought to be fired, honestly.”

Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.) pressed Comey on whether the FBI had pursued potential alternatives, and said that “it befuddles me” that the agency had not yet asked Apple for their source code. He suggested that was one avenue for unlocking the iPhone.

Comey said that they have been engaging “all parts of the U.S. government” for help, and that he was “totally open for suggestions” in the matter.

Issa and Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.) wrote an op ed for the Los Angeles Times in which they argued that allowing the “government ‘backdoor’ access to just this one phone would undo years of technological advances in online security.”

Apple’s Sewell told the committee that what the FBI is asking for is “a backdoor to the iPhone — specifically to build a software tool that can break the encryption system which protects personal information on every iPhone.”

“As attacks on our customers’ data become increasingly sophisticated, the tools we use to defend against them must get stronger too,” he said. “Weakening encryption will only hurt consumers and well-meaning users who rely on companies like Apple to protect their personal information.”

Another issue has been the movement toward so-called “end-to-end encryption,” making it all but impossible for law enforcement to access digital conversations.

Sewell said that Apple has been developing strong encryption security as “we see ourselves in an arms race with criminals, cyberterrorists and hackers.” He suggested that terrorists are finding their own encryption “independently of the issues discussed today,” and would continue to do so even if Apple and other tech firms are asked to forego stronger protections on their devices.

On Monday, a New York federal magistrate judge turned down a Justice Department request to compel Apple’s assistance in unlocking an iPhone in a drug case. The judge, James Orenstein, rejected the government’s argument that the All Writs Act allowed for such an order.

“Ultimately Congress must decide this issue,” Sewell said.

Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-Wis.) was critical of Apple for not offering up a legislative solution. Otherwise, he said, “you’re not going to like what comes out of Congress.”

More Biz

  • Daily Show Viacom

    DirecTV, Viacom Avert Blackout After Marathon Negotiation

    DirecTV and Viacom have agreed on a carriage renewal pact covering a raft of Viacom’s cable channels after a marathon negotiation over the weekend. In a joint statement early Monday, the companies said: “We are pleased to announce a renewed Viacom-AT&T contract that includes continued carriage of Viacom services across multiple AT&T platforms and products. [...]

  • Discovery CEO David Zaslav Sees 2018

    Discovery CEO David Zaslav Sees 2018 Compensation Soar to $129.4 Million

    Discovery Inc. president-CEO David Zaslav is once again making headlines for an enormous compensation package. Zaslav’s 2018 compensation soared to $129.44 million in 2018, fueled by stock options and grants awarded as the longtime Discovery chief signed a new employment contract last July that takes him through 2023 at the cable programming group. Zaslav received [...]

  • Jonathan Lamy RIAA

    Jonathan Lamy Stepping Down From RIAA

    Jonathan Lamy, the Recording Industry Association of America’s longtime executive VP of communications and marketing, is stepping down from his post after 17 years, he announced today. As he put it in an email to Variety, “I started back in 2002, which means it’s been 17+ years, four different RIAA CEOs, three format changes and [...]

  • Fox Layoffs

    Disney-21st Fox Layoffs: TV Divisions Brace for Deep Cuts

    A second day of layoffs has begun on the Fox lot in the wake of Disney completing its acquisition of 21st Century Fox on Wednesday. Longtime 20th Century Fox Television Distribution president Mark Kaner is among the senior executives who were formally notified with severance details on Friday morning. 21st Century Fox’s international TV sales [...]

  • anthony pellicano

    Hollywood Fixer Anthony Pellicano Released From Federal Prison

    Anthony Pellicano, the Hollywood private eye whose wiretapping case riveted the industry a decade ago, was released from a federal prison on Friday, a prison spokeswoman confirmed. Pellicano was sentenced in 2008 to 15 years, following his conviction on 78 charges of wiretapping, racketeering, conspiracy and wire fraud. He had been in custody since 2003, [...]

  • This image taken from the Twitter

    HBO’s Reaction to Trump’s ‘Game of Thrones’ Campaign

    Everyone wants a piece of the “Game of Thrones” lemon cake. From Bud Light to Red Bull the world of Westeros is open to a lot of brand partnerships, unless you’re using that iconic typeface to push a political agenda. In November of 2018 President Donald Trump unveiled a “Thrones” inspired poster with the words [...]

  • Leaving Neverland HBO

    'Leaving Neverland' Lawsuit Proves to Be a Judicial Hot Potato

    The Michael Jackson estate sued HBO last month for airing the documentary “Leaving Neverland,” which accuses the late King of Pop of serial child sexual abuse. Since then, the case has had a difficult time finding a judge to handle it. Three federal judges have recused themselves in the last week, citing potential financial conflicts [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content