×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Are Screenwriters Becoming Obsolete in Hollywood?

We have plunged into the season of back-to-back awards and acceptance speeches, when every winner reminds us that filmmaking is a collaborative endeavor. In these recitations of all the collaborators, however, I’ve noticed that screenwriters are rarely if ever mentioned, which is ironic since the speeches usually are in need of a rewrite.

Such omissions have become increasingly apparent lately, since more and more films have either been written by the director or perhaps not written at all. I’m convinced that no director named Anderson has ever hired a writer. Further, “Birdman,” with all its frenetic energy, plays like it was created scene-by-scene by its hyper-caffeinated cast (the director, Alejandro G. Inarritu, takes screenplay credit along with three other scribes, including two friends).

Arguably, the visually arresting “Interstellar” would have been a far more satisfying film had a talented writer worked on its dialogue and plot (Chris Nolan and his brother, Jonathan, are listed as the writers). I admired “Boyhood,” but, again, it plays as if the actors, year after year, invented scenes as they slowly aged.

The obsolescence of the screenwriter also is apparent in the trend toward what some critics call the “post-plot” movie. “Guardians of the Galaxy” is a prime example of a movie that offered great shtick and a wisecracking raccoon but no true narrative. “The movie encourages you to enjoy yourself even though you’re not sure what’s going on,” observed Los Angeles Times critic Kenneth Turan (he’s a traditionalist, to be sure).

To the contemporary filmmaker-writer, panache and camera movement are more important than compelling dialogue. Author Stephen Farber (another traditionalist) reminded me of Billy Wilder’s declaration: “I like to believe that narrative movement can be achieved eloquently and elegantly without shooting from a hole in the ground, without hanging the camera from a chandelier and without the camera dolly dancing a polka.”

The argument about writers and writers’ credits dates back at least to Andrew Sarris’ pronouncements in the ’60s about “auteur” filmmaking. Sarris venerated directors like Alfred Hitchcock, who distrusted both writers and actors. Pauline Kael then came along to advance the cause of Sidney Lumet, who ranged from “Network” to “Serpico,” and who closely worked with prominent screenwriters.

The painful truth is that many of the films of Hollywood’s vintage years, despite their often pedestrian, studio-driven structure, were exceptionally well written in terms of plot and dialogue. I once took a week off and read my way through some old studio scripts crafted by the likes of Nunnally Johnson and Dalton Trumbo, who labored in the old studio writers buildings, and I was enormously impressed by their craftsmanship and richness of dialogue. I even read unproduced scripts written by the likes of F. Scott Fitzgerald and Ben Hecht — it was clear why they were never made, but they deserved to be published.

My late friend Roddy McDowell, a keen student of studio history, once advised me to read some screenplays he’d collected that had been developed by studio chiefs explicitly as starring vehicles for their favored mistresses. It was a unique collection — superbly written scripts by top screenwriters that were never made (the relationships usually blew up before the films got their greenlights).

I realize that good writing doesn’t necessarily create good filmmaking. It’s more important today to capture the “big scene” than the elegant moment between characters. Superheroes don’t have to talk pretty. Raccoons in an outer galaxy are not expected to be eloquent.

But I can see why there’s discussion in at least one agency to change the title “motion picture lit agent” simply to “lit agent.” That way, they can remove the movie stigma.

More Voices

  • Hollywood Has Come Far With Diversity

    An Insider's Look at Hollywood's Diversity Efforts and How Far It Still Needs to Go

    I am a white man working in Hollywood. I grew up in Beverlywood, an all-white, predominantly Jewish, Los Angeles neighborhood sandwiched between 20th Century Fox Studios and MGM, where my elementary school had only one black student. I am compelled to write about diversity in Hollywood because “diversity” — in front of and behind the camera [...]

  • Venice Film Festival A Star is

    How Venice, Toronto and Telluride Festivals Stole Cannes' Luster (Column)

    In all the years I’ve been attending film festivals, I have never seen a lineup that looked as good on paper as Venice’s did this fall, boasting new films by Alfonso Cuarón (“Roma”), Damien Chazelle (“First Man”), Paul Greengrass (“22 July”), Mike Leigh (“Peterloo”) and the Coen brothers (“The Ballad of Buster Scruggs”) in competition, [...]

  • Black Women in Medicine BTS

    Hollywood Needs to Include People With Disabilities on Both Sides of the Camera (Guest Column)

    In five years, nothing has changed. Despite open calls for greater diversity and inclusion, recent research shows that there was little change in the number of characters with disabilities in popular films in 2017. A study conducted by the Annenberg Inclusion Initiative of the University of Southern California’s Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism found that [...]

  • Seven Seconds

    Fighting the Racial Bias at the Core of Hollywood’s Cop Shows (Guest Column)

    If fiction is the lie that tells a deeper truth, the TV crime genre has been, for the most part, the lie that simply tells a lie. As a storyteller (Veena) and an advocate for racial justice (Rashad), we collaborated for the past two-and-a-half years in an attempt to reimagine the roles of cops, victims, [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein Trial

    Column: Documentarian Barry Avrich Ponders Whether Harvey Weinstein Will Be Convicted

    Will Harvey Weinstein go to jail? That’s perhaps the most debated topic in Hollywood. It’s a question that makes me miss my friend Dominick Dunne, the controversial Vanity Fair columnist who would have already succeeded in interview-ing the chambermaids at Harvey’s sex-addiction clinic. Dunne once prophetically told me there would be a massive reckoning in Hollywood. He [...]

  • Janet Mock Pose

    'Pose' Writer Janet Mock on Making History With Trans Storytelling (Guest Column)

    I first met Ryan Murphy on location in Hollywood in July. The set was a nightclub, filled with background actors staged as glistening go-go dancers, shirtless revelers, and twirling drag queens. They were all basking under the glow of a spinning disco ball — a fitting setting for my first Hollywood job interview. I was [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content