Internet Keeps Big Musicians Big, But Doesn’t Launch New Acts

In music, a few superstar acts are making all the dough, and the rest are blaming the Internet and Spotify for decimating their finances.

But the truth is, most people are lonely, disconnected. They want to belong, and therefore they partake of what’s popular in order to have a basis of conversation.

In the information economy, it’s simple to ferret out what is a quality product. It happens in phones, it happens in social networks. Facebook succeeded not because of advertising, but because unlike MySpace, it just worked, and therefore people gravitated to it and spread the word about it.

And that’s the ultimate success — word of mouth. Which is why you can have a huge advertising campaign that results in a dud. Kinda like last year’s Tom Petty release, and definitely like this year’s Keith Richards release: incredible PR efforts with no one talking about the underlying product. And there’s new product every week, so why should we spend time digging deeper on the mediocre?

Unless you’re going to put out incredible music, you’re playing to your fans only; your audience isn’t going to grow. People are constantly exposed to great new stuff, and they’d rather listen to that. In fact, it turns out we all want the same thing.

So the tail is wagging the dog. And it hasn’t been this way since the dawn of advertising. You can make people aware, but with everything available instantly, with quality assessments easily accessible, and the ability to communicate with the world at your fingertips, it turns out the public is in control. This is not the way it was supposed to be. The Internet was supposed to level the playing field, let the cream rise to the top. Allow everybody to begin from the same starting line, and let the best person win.

Well, the starting lines are now staggered. Unless you have a head start, you’re almost definitely going to fail. And when we reach the finish line, we’ll find only a few men and women standing.

You can’t tour because no one wants to see you, not because expenses are so high. You’re broke not because streaming services don’t pay well, but because no one wants to listen to you. You can’t get ahead because you’re not in bed with the usual-suspect powers, with all their connections, not because your music isn’t good enough. You need the A-level manager, agent and label to push you.

You may be mad that everybody knows Bieber and Gomez, Perry and Swift, and not you. But the former are playing the game most people are paying attention to. And they’re the beneficiaries of committees of the best people creating and pounding their product.

You can play to your niche; there’s nothing wrong with that.

But to rail against music by committee, to agitate against streaming payments, is a fruitless effort. Wanna make change? First be a success. Create something as good as Max Martin does. Max not only helped add to Taylor Swift’s international pop phenomenon, he pushed the Weeknd into the top ranks.

There are fewer new stars than ever before. But that does not mean they will all sound the same forevermore.

Innovation works. We’re looking for the new and different. “Straight Outta Compton” proves this. But no review said “Compton” sucked. “Compton” had to vault a high bar. And once it did, its fans got the rest of America to go too.

We’re in the midst of a great consolidation. You can either obey the new rules or get left behind.

Popular on Variety

More Voices

  • Tegna CEO Dave Lougee

    Coronavirus Pandemic Puts a Bright Spotlight on Value of Local TV

    The TV station group Tegna has been the subject of acquisition rumors for nearly a year. Finally, bids started to surface earlier this month that pegged the company’s market value at about $8.5 billion.  But in the space of a week, the assets up for grabs at Tegna have taken on a very different kind [...]

  • SXSW

    How Canceling SXSW Because of Coronavirus Affected These Filmmakers

    The 2020 South by Southwest Film Festival was set to be a career-making moment for many creators, and a particularly bright spotlight for women, as 70% of the films in competition were directed or co-directed by female filmmakers.  But when the 27th edition of the Austin-based festival was canceled on March 6 due to the [...]

  • Sugical mask isolated on yellow surface.

    How I Raised $6,000 During the Coronavirus Pandemic by Asking for Couples' Drama (Column)

    When you have a generalized anxiety disorder and a daily existential crisis, you end up self-isolating long before the city of Los Angeles mandates it. My coronavirus co-quarantine result is an apartment-turned-shared-home-office between a graduate student (my boyfriend) and a social media editor (me) who attempt romance from six feet apart without leaving their loungewear. [...]

  • Sam Mendes Bong Joon Ho 1917

    Final Oscar Predictions: Who Will Win in the Major Categories?

    The 92nd Academy Awards are almost here… For films like “Joker” and “Marriage Story,” the journey to the Oscars began five months ago with their premieres in Venice. “1917” had the least amount of time on the campaign trail: The Sam Mendes war movie didn’t start screening until late November. In the end, however, it [...]

  • Harriet Movie BTS

    Academy Needs to Start Taking Chances With Noms; Rewards Will Follow (Column)

    Throughout its history, the Academy Awards has been subject to intense criticism for the issues it embraces — and ignores. This year’s uproar over the lack of diversity among nominations in the highest-profile awards categories is the latest example. This failure reflects a chronic dearth of opportunity at Hollywood’s top artistic and financial levels. The milestone nominations [...]

  • Baby Yoda The Mandolorian

    Media Giants Make Smaller Moves With an Eye Toward Future Gains in Streaming Era

    Maybe the empire can strike back. Or at least strike anew. Over the past few months, a number of developments have emerged for traditional media companies that indicate a spirit of reinvention and experimentation is spreading across the industry. There’s a new willingness to take a hard look at long-standing operations and make big and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content