Script and Direction Don’t Always Get Equal Love Come Emmy Time

Ask this year’s crop of nominated directors and writers how to distinguish between a well-written and a well-directed episode of television and the answer you will get is largely the same: You can’t. On television shows, particularly cable series where the creative team is small, the relationship between director and writer is often so collaborative that separating the two elements is virtually impossible.

“If something is badly written or directed, I’m thinking, this is poorly written or poorly directed,” says “Silicon Valley” executive producer Alec Berg, nominated for writing the HBO comedy’s second season finale, “Two Days of the Condor.” “But if things are effectively rendered, you’re just thinking, ‘Wow, this is awesome.’ Or, ‘I love this,’ or ‘I can’t wait to see what happens.’ You’re not really thinking about the craft.”

Logically, this would mean that when submitting the episode that represents the best a show has to offer there would be overlap in the writing and directing category at the Emmys, yet for the past five years, overlap has been minimal, even when a series is represented in both categories. Which begs the question, if a strong script is necessary for a director bring the words to life, and solid direction elevates an already strong script to even greater heights, why is the same episode not represented in both categories?

Those tasked with deciding which sample of their work demonstrates a particular expertise contend that choosing often comes down to instinct. “Veep” showrunner Armando Iannucci submitted “Testimony” for directing, an episode where direction and editing would make or break or break the episode, and the HBO laffer’s season finale, “Election Night,” which features a delicious plot twist, for writing.

“You think, let’s choose something where you can see the style of it, the format of it, that there’s something specific about that episode that lends itself to being the nominee for directing,” Iannucci says. “[‘Testimony’] felt different from the other episodes. It felt like there was something fresh about it. Also, personally, it was the culmination of four years of ‘Veep’ for me. So it felt like the right one to submit.”

“Transparent” creator Jill Soloway submitted the Amazon dramedy’s pilot for writing and “Best New Girl,” a visual departure from the rest of the show, for directing. While both choices felt like the best examples of pushing her own boundaries, Soloway finds that as a showrunner who wrote the majority of episodes and directed several, a real distinction is hard to make.

“I think editing, the scripts, they fall under the directing,” she says. “A good director can stand there and say, ‘I’m responsible for every single moment in this. I give notes to the editor. And I found the music. I gave the writers notes on the script. I ask them to cut this scene.’ That’s what a director does.”

What most nominees agree on is that, unlike movies where a cool angle is something worth noting and even celebrating, being aware of the techniques utilized on a TV show is almost a disadvantage.

“I don’t ever want to draw attention to myself as a director,” says David Nutter, nominated for directing “Mother’s Mercy,” the eventful season finale of HBO’s fantasy epic. “I don’t want people to watch something and say ‘that was a good shot,’ ‘that was a cool shot.’ When they focus on the shot it takes them out of the story, and the story is the No. 1 thing that I serve. I want to be truly invisible so that I support what the audience is watching.”

But without a solid script, even the most talented director cannot shine.

“Visual storytelling is the writer’s domain as well,” says “Mad Men” creator Matthew Weiner, nominated for penning the AMC series finale “Person to Person.” “I don’t know if people realize that. People think the writer writes a whole bunch of talking, and the director comes in and figures out everything else. It doesn’t work that way on our show. It didn’t work that way on ‘The Sopranos,’ I can tell you one thing: No one has ever won a directing Emmy with a script that’s bad.”

More TV

  • 'The Bachelor' Recap: Finding Love Among

    'The Bachelor' Recap: Finding Love Among Hometown Dates

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched the eighth episode of Season 24 of “The Bachelor.” For the first glimpse of the real world in weeks, titular bachelor Peter Weber took his women back home. With only four women remaining — Hannah Ann Sluss, Kelsey Weier, Madison Prewett and Victoria Fuller — [...]

  • Drew Carey Price Is Right

    'Price Is Right' Tapings Delayed After Drew Carey's Ex-Fiance Killed

    “The Price Is Right” tapings have been postponed following news that host Drew Carey’s ex-fiance was killed last week. Family and sex therapist Amie Harwick, 38, was found Saturday morning at her home in Los Angeles with injuries consistent with a fall. She later died at the hospital. Her ex-boyfriend Gareth Pursehouse has been arrested [...]

  • Caroline Flack

    'Love Island' Returns to Air As ITV Defends Treatment of Caroline Flack

    ‘Love Island’ was back on air Monday for the first time since the death of former host Caroline Flack on Feb. 15. Amid the reality series’ return, broadcaster ITV insists it supported the star after she was removed from the show. Monday night’s episode began somberly with narrator Iain Stirling providing voiceover over scenes of [...]

  • Tiffany BooneEntertainment Weekly Pre-SAG Party, Arrivals,

    Actor Tiffany Boone Addresses Her Decision to Quit 'The Chi'

    Actor Tiffany Boone addressed her exit from “The Chi,” the Showtime series she departed in November 2018 after making harassment allegations against her former co-star Jason Mitchell. Mitchell was fired from the show last May as a result of intimidation and abuse accusations made by Boone and showrunner Ayanna Floyd Davis. Mitchell was subsequently dismissed [...]

  • Amazon Prime nabs ‘Russian Affairs’ for

    Amazon Prime Nabs ‘Russian Affairs’ for Germany, France and the Netherlands

    Amazon Prime Video has acquired the first season of series “Russian Affairs” for distribution in Germany, France and the Netherlands, from Russia’s Start Studios. The eight-part drama that follows the lives of Russia’s elite and those who aspire to that position is set in contemporary Moscow. Under the title “Gold Diggers,” the series was broadcast [...]

  • MODEL RELEASED Mother with baby, 1

    Channel 4 Orders ‘Baby Surgeons’ From Wonderhood Studios

    U.K. broadcaster Channel 4 has commissioned Wonderhood Studios for a documentary series with the working title “Baby Surgeons.” The series will explore the journeys parents go through to save their babies during complex pregnancies and will feature cutting-edge baby surgeries, some performed inside the womb. It will also use CGI, MRI and Ultrasound to enhance [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content